He was nominated for a 1993 Joseph Jefferson Award for Actor in a Supporting Role in a Musical for "The First: A Musical", at the Marriott Theatre in Chicago, Illinois.
He was nominated for a 1994 Joseph Jefferson Award for Actor in a Supporting Role in a Musical for "Windy City", at the Marriott Theatre in Chicago, Illinois.
He was nominated for a 1996 Joseph Jefferson Award for Actor in a Supporting Role in a Musical for "The Sound of Music", at the Drury Lane Theatre in Oakbrook, Illinois.
He was nominated for a 1996 Joseph Jefferson Award for Actor in a Supporting Role in a Musical for "Eleanor", at the Drury Lane Theatre in Oakbrook and Marriott Theatre in Chicago, Illinois.
He was nominated for a 1998 Joseph Jefferson Award for Actor in a Supporting Role in a Musical for "Gypsy", at the Marriott Theatre in Chicago, Illinois.
He was nominated for a 2007 Joseph Jefferson Award for Actor in a Principal Role in a Musical for "The Adding Machine", at the Next Theatre Company in Chicago, Illinois.
Jeff Still and his musical, "Adding Machine: A Musical" at The Hypocrites Theatre in Chicago, Illinois was nominated for a 2016 Joseph Jefferson (Equity) Award for Midsize Musical Production.