The Captain's Pup (1938) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
Technically Superior.................
redryan649 October 2018
......................But Artistically ? Not So Much !

AND JUST WHERE are Hans & Fritz ?

THIS ENTRY INTO MGM's animated short subject category could best be described as adequate at its very best. We know that they had done some of these CAPTAIN AND THE KIDS one reelers and actually had seen some of these years ago on local TV here in Chicago. As we recall, unless our memory is failing us, there were at least some of the series entries that were done in color.

AS FAR AS this film is concerned, there is a bare minimum of elements infused int the various aspects of production. This assertion refers to: story-line & "plot" (such as it was), cast of characters, settings and originality & tailoring of gags to the characters.

IN GIVING THE Devil his due, we must make mention of what may well be not only an act of "follow the leader" in reference to the product of the "big boys" in the animation field. We refer to Walt Disney and Max Fleischer. Their advancement would be in their numbering of characters digital appendages (that means fingers, Schultz!) Not only do the human characters here (being only Mama and the Captain) have a thumb & 3 fingers on their hands (a la Mickey Mouse & Company), but the same lineup applies to their feet !

WHENEVER ONE CONSIDERS the comic strip characters of Hans, Fritz, Mama, the Captain, the Inspector and others; it should be stressed that there was a duplicitous situation here. There were in fact two separate and distinct comic strips featuring the same cast in similar, if not identical, situations. (You can read all about it in Wikipedia or in many other sources)

ALTHOUGH THIS WAS not a successful series, the characters were very familiar to the movie going public. There were both live action and animated cartoon screen adaptations dating from the earliest of movie history. Remember that THE KATZENJAMMER KIDS Strip started in 1897 and continued being produced with original material until January 1, 2006; after which reprint strips are still being syndicated to this day. THE CAPTAIN AND THE KIDS competitor strip lasted until 1979. That was "only" a six decade run.

THIS ANIMATED SERIES, however, was the only screen presentation of the Katzies under that title.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
a one joke cartoon, average at best, though the ending is good
llltdesq11 April 2015
Warning: Spoilers
This is a Captain and the Kids short from MGM. There will be spoilers ahead:

The MGM series, The Captain and the Kids, wasn't a very good one, as the humor didn't translate well fro the comic strip to the screen. This one is a prime example of that problem.

As a Sunday strip, this would have probably worked, because it's essentially one joke-the Captain buys a dog, Mama objects and the Captain gets in trouble because of the dog. That's really all there is to the plot. It's not enough to sustain almost nine minutes of animation.

So you wind up watching the dog squirm around, or the Captain sleeping, Mama scowling and it all adds up to one rather long and static cartoon with sporadic action and the one joke effectively beaten into a coma. There are a couple of amusing bits with a hot dog and one where the dog is stalking the Captain's big toe, but there's far too little that's funny. The ending is cute, if predictable. This is worth watching once.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
People tend to forget that the Pied Piper rid his land . . .
oscaralbert11 October 2018
Warning: Spoilers
. . . of rats BEFORE he lured all the area kids into a cave of doom when the government welshed out on paying him the agreed upon fee for his rodent removal services. In THE CAPTAIN'S PUP, the title mutt "Hamlet" has a special talent: He's a mouse whisperer. "The Captain's" Missus is overjoyed to see this gift exercised once, rewarding the not-so-Great Dane (perhaps a drop or two) with a bone. But when the enterprising pooch soon rounds up eight MORE mice, how does "Ma" react? Common Sense would suggest that she'd give the diligent dog at least half a dozen more bones--if not an entire steak!--and Google up some mouse-meat pie recipes. However, since this brief cartoon emanates from the Billionaires' Boys Club (aka, M-G-M), she does nothing of the kind. The ingrate wench sends Hamlet (along with his hen-pecked sponsor) to bed without supper! Nearly every MGM film--no matter how brief--tries to come up with examples of how to short-change we working stiffs, and THE CAPTAIN'S PUP is no exception to this rule.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed