User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
A mother finds money in the garden - and it changes life for a string of unfortunates.
phyllisbrookss22 March 2005
This must be an excellent movie -- after all, I've been thinking of it from time to time over 50 years! I saw it when it was first released in the 50's and it's stuck in my memory. A gentle, wistful tale of life in a black township, with the hero a small-time thief who plays a penny whistle. I looked for it on line when search engines were less efficient and databases smaller. Now I've found it. I'm eager to see it again.

The cast are non-professionals, but the pacing and visuals are certainly of high quality. High point: When the local police lift a garbage can lid and see the thief inside, one looks at the other and says, "Man, the housing shortage is worse than I thought." Dumb, but endearing. Especially since they carefully put the lid back on, and go on their way.

It sits in my memory beside the original Theodore Bikel "Little Kidnappers." A keeper.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Glad to find reference to Pennywhistle Blues
pierre-mackay15 September 2007
phyllisbrookss has it exactly right. I too have been haunted by the memory of seeing Pennywhistle Blues in the 50s. I have also been haunted by its opening theme, which is running in my head right now. I am delighted to learn that it can be found on tape. It ought to be re-saved on DVD as well, so that it does not follow tape into obsolescence.

As has already been remarked, it must be a superior film if it lingers in the memory for 55 years. I have recalled other films this way, however, and have been disappointed when I finally saw them again. An example is O Cangaceiro, with its splendid opening scene as the bandits appear coming up from behind a ridge in silhouette. That scene turns out to be much shorter than I remembered it, and one hears far too little of "Mulher rendera" as a result. Other music in this film does not last as long as I recalled it, either.

So I hope that the music I remember from Pennywhistle Blues lives up to my recollections of it. From previous comments, it seems that it may.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
"Eish, this housing problem is getting serious!"
trevormoses-628245 December 2023
Warning: Spoilers
Odd for a cinema industry emerging from the birth of apartheid in 1948, several films were produced from 1949 - 1951 in which the focus was on Black South Africans, rather than their oppressive rulers. The films were Donald Swanson's African Jim aka Jim Comes To Jo'burg (1949), Hyman Kirstein's Zonk (1950), Emil Nofal's Song of Africa (1951) and this gloriously funny musical comedy, filmed in the Johannesburg suburb of Alexandra and featuring almost all of its' residents in a madcap chase in pursuit of a thief who stole money from a church whose oldest parishioner had just donated his life savings to that church. Among the hugely funny moments is a scene set in a dustbin of all places: the thief is hiding in one and when the police confront him, he claims the bin as his home, leading one police officer to say "This housing problem is getting serious."

There is only one dark spot in this film's legacy and that is the fact that the film's screenwriter, James Ambrose Brown attempted to track the film down in 1988 and found it at the National Film, Video and Sound Archives in Pretoria. Once there, he was made aware of the fact that not only was the film there in 16mm print format but its' negative masters as well: all well preserved for many years.

All well and good, until Brown demanded that the negatives be released to him as he claimed copyright on it, despite only being the screenwriter and the fact that producer and director Donald Swanson had passed away in 1977. This demand was entertained by the archivists on the condition that Brown could produce proof that he was the actual rights holder: this he could not do and thus went away in a huff, later writing an article in the The Star newspaper in which he alleged that "the film is available in Europe but in Pretoria, the film moulders in a vault".

In light of the positivity of this long unseen film, it is troubling that the next three features made by foreign filmmakers with Black South Africans as the focal point - Zoltan Korda's bleak, depressing Cry The Beloved Country (1952), Lionel Rogosin's covertly filmed awful disaster Come Back Africa and Henning Carlsen's dire Dilemma aka A World Of Strangers - chose the negative view typical of anti-South African foreign filmmakers of this country instead and chose to portray South Africa as a ghastly hell hole with no chance of redemption nor rescue from the pit of despair that apartheid had spawned.

Simply put: South Africans should tell their own stories, nobody else has the right or should be allowed to. With Dolly Rathebe, Tommy Machaka and Willard Cele.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
First All South African Film Cast
johnsonlj200324 January 2006
Warning: Spoilers
Charming story with humorous elements about a lucky find in a 'Magic Garden' which starts a chain of events in which the audience can decide whether the recipient of the 'treasure' gets his or her just desserts. Lovely penny-whistle music throughout.

Much of its charm is to do with the age of the film and the success of the Cinematographer in actually teaching the actors to act as this was a first film for all the cast.

This film is used in USA universities as the first of its ilk from early 1930s with an all-black cast. Fun. Nice countryside and scenery, giving the viewer a taste of South Africa before its troubles.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed