Our Man in Havana (1959) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
69 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Games With Agent 59200/5
slokes22 March 2013
Comedy and espionage make uneasy bedfellows in this Alec Guinness vehicle. Viewers should expect more of a morality play than a gleeful farce.

Guinness frequently played characters leading double lives. Here we see his character Wormold tripped up by one that may cost him his life. Wormold is a vacuum cleaner salesman in Havana who is approached by a fellow named Hawthorne (Noel Coward), alias Agent 59200, who wants Wormold to serve the British Secret Service "for $150 a month and expenses" as his subagent, 59200/5, collecting secret information regarding pre-Castro Cuba.

Encouragement for this comes not only indirectly from his love for his spendthrift daughter Milly (Jo Morrow) but more directly from his best friend, a castoff German doctor named Hasselbacker (Burl Ives), whose advice forms the heart of the message from screenwriter Graham Greene, adapting his own novel:

"That sort of information is always easy to give. If it is secret enough, you alone know it. All you need is a little imagination...As long as you invent, you do no harm. And they don't deserve the truth."

The joke, which is also the story's tragedy, is Wormold invents too well, convincing not only his London paymasters but the opposition of his fiction's veracity. Director Carol Reed famously made a spy film, "The Third Man," which blended tragedy and comedy in equal measure. This time, the comedy is more front-and-center, but efforts at creating a light tone conflict with the more serious message and various characters' fates. "Our Man In Havana" struggles at times with what kind of film it wants to be.

Perhaps Guinness's own difficulty with his part contributes to this confusion. He reportedly found Reed's instruction ("Don't act!") unhelpful. Ives is especially heavy for the film's most delicate part, making it oppressively sad; I wish that Reed's collaborator Orson Welles could have taken this part and invested it with some of his trademark cunning and craft.

Much of "Our Man In Havana" does work, and well. Oswald Morris's cinematography employs actual Havana locations to great effect, using unusually angled shots of the crumbling, sun-drenched city. You feel the tension of Wormold's world in every scene. Ernie Kovacs, a hero of early TV comedy, gets a lot out of a thanklessly straight part, the menacing but sensitive Segura, who lusts for Milly and explains his position with real sensitivity even though he never loses the cruelty of the character.

"Do you play checkers, Mr. Wormold?" he asks.

"Not very well," answers Wormold.

"In checkers, one must move more carefully than you have tonight."

Wormold isn't kidding; he only knows enough to lose. In a world this topsy-turvy, it proves the right approach.

Coward does much to serve the comedy, which would be almost entirely absent without him. His recruitment of Wormold, which is played like a seedy homosexual liaison in bars and men's rooms, is a riot when one knows not only Coward's own legendary proclivities but his friendship with that master of spy fiction, Ian Fleming. Some of the film is even set in Fleming's own Jamaican stomping grounds; one can imagine the creator of James Bond must have enjoyed this send-up of his work before it was a gleam in Albert Broccoli's eye.

"Our Man In Havana" plays with your mind and conscience for an hour and a half. It capably establishes a dark mood with cheerful undertones though it would have worked better vice versa, which was my takeaway from reading the novel. Anyway, it's intelligent, entertaining, and worth a look.
18 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A splendidly acted movie about "real" spying before the genre was established. The Government's ready and willing acceptance of misinformation is chillingly relevant in light of the recent Iraq ma
bids26505 December 2004
This movie is a good example of how a story can be carried by the force of the actors' skill and director's art rather than relying the science of special effects. The absence of "action" means that the audience's attention has to be held by the sheer force of the story line, the actors' interpretations of it and the director's presentation of the product as a whole.

It deals honestly with what intelligence gathering is. A mundane craft open to manipulation not only by governments but also by lowly operatives. Sir Alec Guinness, as he later became, portrays the ordinariness of the seedy characters who carry on this trade. Ernie Kovacs gives a splendid presentation of the laid back but sinister not so secret policeman while Burl Ives is as powerful as ever.

The pre-Castro Cuban setting is well portrayed and one can almost feel the tropical heat as the cast of misfit characters go about there subterfuge business.
56 out of 64 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
a bit underrated
planktonrules1 July 2005
Although most Americans have little knowledge of his work other than Star Wars, Alec Guinness produced an amazing body of work--particularly in the 1940s-1950s--ranging from dramas to quirky comedies. I particularly love his comedies, as they are so well-done and seem so natural and real on the screen--far different from the usual fare from Hollywood.

This spy farce is about a man who is a paid spy in Cuba during the latter years of the Batista regime. The problem is, he has absolutely no idea what he is doing and is in way over his head because he is NOT a trained spy--just some guy dumped into the role despite his objections. So how do you think he should deal with this dilemma? Of course, make up EVERYTHING and pretend you are doing your job. The problem is, he is too good at it and the lies take on a life of their own! This comedy is a bit silly at times and unbelievable compared to some of his earlier work, but it is still an excellent film. Don't be put off by mediocre reviews that came out since its release--it's well worth your time.
54 out of 63 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Classic Guiness!
celtic_flute6 October 2004
One of my favorite scenes is when Alec Guiness must get the chief of police (Ernie Kovacs) so drunk that he passes out. He arranges a game of checkers played with miniature bottles of scotch. You know,the kind served on airlines. Each time one is taken, it must be opened and drunk immediately. This leads to hilarious results. Guiness is excellent in the beginning for his famous "fusby" look. Meek, almost sheepish. Only when Kovacs is finally "knees up", can Alec Guiness complete his plan. (Watch the movie to see what this is!). This movie used to be a staple of late night television, before cable and the advent of talk shows, when movies reigned supreme. Of course, it was usually horribly butchered.
26 out of 27 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
This Man in Havana Is No Third Man
evanston_dad22 July 2009
"Our Man in Havana" has all of the elements of a sure-fire classic: a cast that includes Alec Guinness, Burl Ives, Noel Coward, a very lovely Maureen O'Hara and Ralph Richardson; a screenplay by Graham Greene adapted from his own novel; and direction by Carol Reed, who had tackled Greene before and made one of the best films in history ("The Third Man").

So why doesn't "Our Man in Havana" entirely work? I'm not sure, but I found myself wanting to like this movie far more than I actually did. Guinness plays a vacuum cleaner salesman living in Havana who gets recruited by the British secret service to do spy work for them. He doesn't want to be a spy but wants the fat paychecks that come with it, so he feeds them fake information to avoid having to do any actual work. But when very real consequences arise from his false information, he suffers a moral crisis.

And maybe that's where the movie stumbles. That moral crisis is never made explicit, and the movie gets sidetracked into a revenge storyline as Guinness plans the murder of another agent out to get him. The film isn't as playful as the book, so it's not very funny when it should be, but since it doesn't examine the more serious themes inherent in the story as thoroughly as it could, there's nothing to fill the gap where the humor used to be.

This film isn't exactly a misfire, but it's certainly no "Third Man."

Grade: B
13 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
My idea of paradise
bob99822 February 2005
My idea of paradise would be sitting down with a DVD boxed set of Alec Guinness comedies from the 1950's. What will it be tonight? The Man in the White Suit, or The Ladykillers (both by Mackendrick)? Or Kind Hearts and Coronets, where he played eight parts to perfection? No, tonight will be Our Man in Havana, the blackest of black comedies, directed by Carol Reed from Graham Greene's novel. The tone of confusion and mounting panic, the sense of things sliding hopelessly out of control is perfectly caught by Reed, who had already given us the classic The Third Man.

The casting is very good. Noel Coward, Gregoire Aslan, Ferdy Mayne and especially Burl Ives as Hasselbacher, the most reluctant of spies are all impressive. Maureen O'Hara is a Rolls Royce when a Morris would have done for this story, but she plays well. I liked Ernie Kovacs as Segura, the brutal police chief; he had a nice vulgarity blended with sensitivity that worked for me.

Now my pleasure would be complete if this picture were available on DVD, and if IMDb would give us the memorable quotes this film abounds in. Like Segura: "one never tortures except by a kind of mutual agreement", or Beatrice's description of her estranged husband: "He was very beautiful; he had a face like a young fledgling looking out of the nest in one of those nature films..."
60 out of 67 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Big Joke.
rmax30482318 August 2010
Warning: Spoilers
Carol Reed directed some matchless films, "The Third Man" among them. He was capable of clunkers too, like "The Public Eye." This one is somewhere in between but probably closer to "The Third Man." At any rate, it's light years ahead of most of the junk showing up on screens today, though they cost a million times more.

Alec Guiness, in a performance both effective and casual, runs a vacuum cleaner shop in Bautista's Havana. He's not doing that well. The palmetto bugs object to the noise. His daughter, Jo Morrow, though is now a budding seventeen-year-old in a convent school and has expensive tastes. And Guiness wants to send her to school in Switzerland, an expensive proposition. In other words, Guiness finds himself in a dilemma common to us non-millionaires, in a vice whose heads consist of expenses and income.

But his life changes. He's contacted by the prim, cautious Noel Coward who wants to hire him as a spy for the British Secret Service. Guiness sensibly pooh-poohs the proposition until Coward mentions the salary, at which Guiness gulps and nervously accepts.

Coward explains the deal. Guiness will receive his tax-free salary and just "keep an eye on things", sending regular reports to London. He will also have to hire his own agents, who will also receive salaries through Guiness, and who will submit regular reports.

A dream come true for the impecunious vacuum shop proprietor. Giddy with delight, he begins making up the names of agents, picking them from phone books and dance hall placards. Pressed for specific information, he draws a picture of one of his vacuum cleaners, claims it is based on the report of one of his agents, that it is a huge installation in the mountains, and sends that in.

Regrettably, London takes the report seriously, although Coward remarks tentatively that it looks a little as if it's made up of vacuum cleaner parts. The Chief, Ralph Richardson, admits that it does, but why not build a giant vacuum cleaner as a weapon? The revelation is important enough for London to send an experienced agent and cryptographer, along with staff and equipment, to Havana, where all lodge in Guiness's cramped quarters. His chief assistant is Maureen O'Hara.

Somewhere around the point of no return, the story turns rather serious. The Havana constabulary get wind of the operation. And there is "another side" that tries to assassinate Guiness. A couple of deaths, one of them tragic, precede the ironically happy ending.

It's usually billed as a comedy and I guess it is, but don't expect to laugh out loud at any of the dialog or scenes. They're smile worthy but low key. A good deal of the humor depends on Guiness's performance and he delivers. But, again, the pace is never frantic. I'll give two examples.

When Coward recruits Guiness, he takes him into the men's room of one of the local bars, where he checks for hidden microphones, turns on the taps, and makes Guiness hide in one of the stalls so that, should anyone enter, Coward and Guiness won't be seen together. That's pretty ridiculous in itself, but it gets worse when Guiness tries by himself to recruit an engineer as one of his agents. He approaches the astonished man in the men's room and tries to coax him into one of the stalls while explaining that he'll tell the engineer what to do later. The engineer mistakes Guiness's intentions.

The preceding paragraph was a single example of the humor, though it may look like two. Here comes the second example. It's short. Ready? After the story takes a serious turn, Coward invites Guiness to lunch al fresco and tells him matter-of-factly that persons unknown are out to kill him by poisoning him. Guiness is in the middle of slurping a Planter's Punch and does a semi-spit take. Carol Reed frames the shot of Guiness so that he's almost hidden by a bankful of lillies in full bloom. (Kids: Lillies? Funerals?)

Oh, well. Let me add that just before this exchange, in a practiced gesture at keeping their conversation hidden, Coward gets up and closes the door between the bar and the tables outside, but the door, like the wall, is nothing more than a few poles of bamboo criss-crossing wide open space.

Whether or not it was intended as a comment on Noel Coward's own proclivities, everywhere he goes, dressed like a British gentleman, he's accompanied by an enthusiastic band of mostly young musicians playing guitars and singing, "Donde Va?" Maureen O'Hara is remarkable. She looks magnificent, for one thing. And this is twenty-two years after her film debut. And it's her finest performance, one of the few in which she's cast as something other than a caricature. What a woman.

The movie's well worth seeing, keeping in mind that this is not an Ealing comedy or some kind of farce.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Can great Spies and Secret Agents have great imagination?
theowinthrop2 April 2007
Warning: Spoilers
Graham Greene, with his unfaltering sense of reality and irony, plays no favorites in the world of espionage. He knew (as Eric Ambler did, and as John Le Carre did) that no country is really an innocent - that all countries have guilty secrets that other countries (for purposes of self-interest, including security and economic strength) have to discover. Keeping this in mind one easily has the situation in OUR MAN IN HAVANA.

Alec Guinness is Wormold, an Englishman who runs a vacuum cleaner agency in Havana, Cuba in the late 1950s (actually before Castro seized power). He lives with his daughter Jo Morrow, who has some spending habits of her own. He does not make much money, and is in debt. He is approached by British Secret Service official Noel Coward to become a British agent, reporting on Cuban military information for a monthly stipend. Guinness agrees reluctantly because of his debts, but he really does not know how to develop a spy ring. Coward gives him some vague tips that he takes up, but he fumbles them. He attempts to approach some local Cubans he knows from his social club, and they think he is trying to come onto them.

Soon he is joined by Maureen O'Hara, who is to be his "bookkeeper"/assistant, but was sent by Coward and his boss Ralph Richardson. Struggling to make something to report about his activities, Guinness starts lying. He makes it sound like he was successful getting those Cuban gentlemen to be his information gatherers. But worse, he decides he has to prove he found something. He notices that the vacuum cleaners, if taken apart and blown up a huge number of times, they look like odd buildings for scientific or military purposes. He sends these to England, and Richardson is deeply impressed, although he does comment that one would think they look like parts of a vacuum cleaner. Coward happens to hear this while he is behind Richardson, and suddenly realizes what Guinness is sending. But he keeps quiet.

There are people who are suspicious of Guinness. O'Hara catches on early, but she has fallen in love with Guinness and is keeping (despite misgivings) quiet. But the local police chief (Ernie Kovacs) is aware - after hearing of the approaches Guinness was making to those local fellows, that Guinness was recruiting spies. However, Kovacs (for his own reasons) is mum about this - he is interested in getting Guinness's agreement for him to marry Morrow (who doesn't like him). Guinness's closest friend, a former German army officer played by Burl Ives, also figures out what is going on, and willingly sells his information (or a variant of it) the the Russians.

Soon Guinness finds his seemingly harmless fraud is actually dangerous. Coward comes to see him to warn him that the Russians are so impressed at Guinness's "successful" discovery of military secrets that they have decided to silence him by assassination, most likely poisoning at a public dinner Guinness has to attend of vacuum cleaner salesmen. Guinness manages to figure out who the threatening Russian agent is, but he is unable to prevent one murder. In seeking to avenge it, Guinness has to allow Kovacs to outwit himself in a checker game (you'll see what I mean).

Guinness, according to the biography by Piers Paul Read, was not happy about his performance in OUR MAN IN HAVANA. He and director Sir Carol Reed (THE THIRD MAN's director) disagreed on how Guinness should play Wormold (his character), and Sir Alec said he lost interest in it. He also did not feel comfortable with Kovacs and Ives. Noel Coward, in his diaries, did not like Ives, who he said was a bore. But still the performances are highly watchable (in Coward's case it is one of his best film roles), and the Greenean irony stays on until the end of the film. It is a clever movie, and well worth watching.
35 out of 40 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
His inventive imagination
bkoganbing6 December 2013
To me Our Man In Havana was a strange film. It would have been far better had it been played more broadly and for satire. The potential was there, the cast actually a perfect one for it. But instead the film was played seriously.

What an incredible premise. MI6 always on the lookout for agents and they can be recruited in a variety of ways spots expatriate vacuum cleaner salesman Alec Guinness living in Havana with his daughter Jo Morrow is scraping by on his job and it's expensive sending Morrow to a Catholic Convent school.

Along comes Noel Coward from British Intelligence with a proposition some extra income to work for them and recruit other agents and send back reports on loose information he picks up. And he has to recruit other agents to report to him with them getting a stipend from MI6.

It takes his good friend Burl Ives to show him the possibilities there. Ives is a German expatriate living in Havana as a doctor since the 30s. Invent stories, make up agents, pocket their stipends this could be a real money maker.

I'm sure you can see the possibilities there for broad comedy. Yet though some laughs are here, it gets deadly serious when the other side expresses an interest in killing Guinness because his reports to British Intelligence are giving the reputation to Our Man In Havana as one of the best they have.

One thing the British take pride in is their spy service. Since the days of Francis Walsingham who developed it for Queen Elizabeth I this something they take seriously. So of course when Guinness is finally found out to be a fake, they've got quite the conundrum.

Also in the cast are Maureen O'Hara who said that she and Guinness got along well during the shoot in Cuba which was right after the Revolution of 1959. She even met Che Guevara there and was impressed by him. She and Guinness both devout Catholics always attended mass together.

Ernie Kovacs plays a lecherous Cuban police captain who has his eyes on Jo Morrow. He's not sure what Guinness is about but he knows he's up to something. For the price of Morrow he'll cover for Guinness. O'Hara said that the new Cuban government watched the shooting of this film with intense scrutiny and wanted it made clear that Kovacs was a Batista supporter. Kovacs was the kind who would have been shot right off when Castro took power.

Although Our Man In Havana is well done it misses being a classic. What Mel Brooks could have done with this plot though.
8 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Graham Greene at his cinematic best.
jamesbkozak-111 April 2006
This is one of Alec Guiness's best performances. The whole film is understated and takes into account the arid wit of the novel. Graham Greene usually buries humor in dark text that deals with one man's coming to grips with some moral or religious crisis. In Our Man in Havana Greene sets aside his usual level of introspection-made-manifest and dwells upon the absurdity of a small man with a small life that is drawn into circumstances that quite outdistance his usual worldly sphere of experience and expectation. A vacuum cleaner salesman is drawn into a vortex of espionage and intrigue. He has to create from whole cloth scenarios to satisfy his spy-master contacts. Due to his agility at fabrication he becomes regarded as an indispensable operative and ultimately draws upon a well of heretofore untapped personal resources in order to save the day. Guiness, alternating between bewilderment and resolve paints a lovable portrait of a man pinned between a bedrock sense of duty and a stomach-emptying realization of being completely out of his depth. It's a sin and a shame that this film is not available in any format in any country.
32 out of 37 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A very dry martini of a movie
rhoda-97 September 2008
From the first shot, of Noel Coward in a dark suit and hat, tightly rolled umbrella, and immobile face striding down a Havana street besieged by grinning musicians and beggars, we know what we're in for: a story of chilly British imperturbability undermined by Latin misrule. The usual way this happens is through love or lust, but this movie has a subtler and darker theme--an amusing fantasy, in a dictatorship, turns into something seriously and horribly real.

Attracted by the money that secret-service work will bring, but clueless as to how to do it, Wormold (Alec Guinness), a vacuum-cleaner salesman, makes up reports inspired by comic strips. But not only does London take them seriously--so does the other side, which has cracked his code.

Our Man in Havana starts out as a comedy, but the humour turns to satire and then to a very black comedy indeed. Wormold's spy stories result in misunderstanding, then embarrassment, then murder, until he is put in a position where, though it's the last thing he wants, he has to become a hero, perhaps a dead one.

An irony that went unappreciated at the time was of Alec Guinness expressing his disgust of homosexuals in one scene and, in another, being comically mistaken for one (in a maneuver shown him by Noel Coward!).

Not many big laughs, but lots and lots of knowing and rueful smiles are what this movie inspires--it's a very dry martini in a world of brightly coloured alcopops.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Classic Carol Reed
trojanjim11 January 2005
A GREAT MOVIE: classic performances, despite some miscasting with the women. The film never has any trouble deciding what it will be, despite the fact that some viewers seem put off by the shading of genres. Some of the comments above referring to a "weak" screenplay or Guinness's inability to fully develop the role only reveal how taste has changed over the years. This is classic British humor, of the black variety, very underplayed, as it always was done before the Brits succumbed to American taste. While his treatment is lighter than the book, Reed (a man, by the way, as others have noted) captures the wry cynicism of Greene perfectly. The film displays touches of the same sensibility that produced "The Third Man," which also contained humorous moments (The literary party for Holly Martins). Reed's juxtaposition of comedy and tragedy, while unsettling to some, is the essence of his profound commentary on "the spy game." As mentioned above, this deserves a DVD!!!
53 out of 64 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Out-Dated, but still Interesting
legwarmers198027 August 2006
Just saw Our Man In Havana on a VHS that I won on e-bay. I had seen this movie as a child, but had little memory of it. Seems that the Tailor of Panama with Pierce Bronson was a remake of this movie. Interesting, but clearly out-dated movie. Has an historical element as it was filmed in pre-Castro Cuba. Amazingly, the Cuban Revolution didn't occur during the filming of this show. I'm not Cuban, but it was still very interesting to see the streets of Havana.

Great performances by everyone involved, but Ernie Kovacks steals the spotlight as the evil Police commander. A few very funny scenes, one with a gay overtone, and the other regarding a "supposed" desire to have a threesome. I'd rate Our Man In Havana a 7.
5 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Disappointing
doriob-28 January 2001
Given the pedigree of this film, one would expect much more of it. Oddball casting -- Burl Ives as a German doctor? Maureen O'Hara as a strangely accentless English secretary? Ernie Kovacs as a brutal Cuban police official? -- is a distraction, as is the odd juxtaposition of tone.

Ostensibly a "spoof" of spy thrillers, the film never achieves a consistent comic tone. Unfortunately, it also fails to succeed as a thriller.
23 out of 44 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A warm-hearted Cold War comedy of life
jjconjr3321 November 2000
This afternoon I chanced upon this terrific film on Channel 4.I had seen it years ago as a child,and couldn't understand why my father kept referring to the brilliant " Our Man in Havana" Now I know what he meant.Alec Guinness hit the perfect note in the part,as he invariably did.Havana is rendered almost tangible by director Carol Reed, a difficult feat to achieve.The rest of the cast shine too.Ernie Kovacs makes a human being out of his police-thug character.The script seems almost improvised,so fresh , pointed and witty.Compare this movie to the bulk of today's garbage,and prepare to feel very let-down by what you can see at your local Multiplex.This strange and sharp movie has re-affirmed my intention to spend some time in Havana.Buena Vista Social Club first whetted my curiosity.This movie is timeless and a great 2 hrs of entertainment/art.Enjoy! And look at Maureen O ' Hara, is she not quite splendid? !
25 out of 29 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
A very lopsided spy story played for laughs most of the time...
Doylenf6 June 2008
If you can get past the absurd storyline that has ALEC GUINESS pretending to be a spy and even inventing his fellow agents so that he can pose as the real thing for NOEL COWARD and RALPH RICHARDSON--well, it's a tall order. Graham Greene must have been in a very imaginative mood when he concocted this bit of farce and not all of it works as intended. It's an odd mixture of acting styles and it all seems more than a little foolish by the time Alec has become such a valuable "spy" that the Russians want to assassinate him.

The best scenes are after Guiness realizes that things have gone too far and someone actually intends to kill him at a banquet he is forced to attend. He's told how to play the game of avoiding food and drinks and there's a clever bit of attempts on his life at the function that are chilling and yet provoke laughs at the same time. Interesting too is his final confrontation with the man who is a hired assassin.

MAUREEN O'HARA enters the picture rather late in the story as a woman who is hired to be secretary for "our man in Havana" and has little to do, but is charming and as attractive as always. Unfortunately, RALPH RICHARDSON is completely wasted in a nothing role but NOEL COWARD has a fine time with an amusing part as the man who recruits Guiness.

ERNIE KOVACS is surprisingly well cast as a member of the police force during the last days of the Battista regime, before the revolution. And BURL IVES is an odd bit of casting as a man who knows too much.

The overall result is somewhat of a misfire and yet there are moments that are calculated to stir your interest in the offbeat story. ALEC GUINESS gives a marvelous performance as the reluctant spy who finds himself in hot water when he decides to play the game the way Ives told him to. Filmed entirely in Cuba in glorious B&W, the authentic backgrounds give it a nice flavor.

Not bad, but not the best thing Greene ever wrote and the story lacks credibility at too many key moments.
4 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Funny, clever, timely...a great spoof years ahead of Kubrick
secondtake14 January 2010
Our Man in Havana (1959)

A lovely movie, funny and trenchant in its own way, and a precursor to Dr. Strangelove with its wry criticism of the Cold War and government ineptness. In this case, it isn't the atom bomb at hand, but the spread of communism into the colonies--though, to be fair, I don't think the word communism ever comes up.

Anyway, the simple trick of a recently hired agent trying to save his minor reputation by inventing things right and left, and having the upper levels not see through it, is hilarious. Yes it's implausible as shown, but the idea isn't so far fetched, and Alec Guiness, the protagonist, pulls it off with droll, steady humor and cleverness.

Cuba, of course, was in upheaval, and the truth of the revolution in the hills became a dramatic revolution shortly before filming took place. For political reasons, a note declares at the start that the film is set before Castro's takeover, so the corruption shown would be attributed to the overthrown government. A terrific background is given at the TCM site here (www.tcm.com/thismonth/article/?cid=143178).

The writing, by Graham Greene, is first rate, and keeps the farce in perfect balance, even with some of the secondary actors (Burl Ives, Noel Coward) hamming it up slightly. The director is the legendary Carol Reed (The Third Man) and between Guiness and him (and Greene), the movie has a British tilt--indeed, it was filmed mostly in Havana with followup work in Shepparton Studios, London. It's completely fun, well filmed, and if at times frivolous, maybe that's just a tonic for the times, and the real life drama of 1959 Cuba.
12 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Waste of Talent
kenjha3 April 2009
Before the revolution in Cuba, a vacuum cleaner salesman is recruited by the British Secret Service for the title role. This cold war comedy sets up a premise ripe with comic possibilities but fails to deliver the laughs. The script by Greene, adapting his own novel, is good for only a few chuckles. A marvelous cast is wasted, including Guinness as the recruited spy hoping to make a quick buck, Coward as his recruiter, O'Hara as his devoted secretary, and Richardson as a befuddled Secret Service superior. Kovacs steals the film as a slimy Cuban police chief who has designs on Guinness's daughter. A disappointment, considering the cast and the director (Reed).
6 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Excellent throughout
ebbets-field31 December 2000
This superb noir comedy has wonderful depth and balance -- based on a fine novel, well-scripted, spectacularly well-lit and photographed, and vwey well performed, particularly by Alec Guiness and Ernie Kovacs, who was virtually as good an actor as he was a comedian. Havana itself is another major contributor to this masterpiece, shot at perhaps the peak period of its physical condition.
35 out of 44 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Ingenious spy satire needs more satire and less drama
cherold11 May 2018
Set in Cuba shortly before the revolution (and filmed there after), Our Man in Havana stars Alec Guinness as a man reluctantly persuaded to spy for Britain. He shows no talent for the job, but a considerable talent for making things up.

There's a point in the middle of the film, as his lies become amplified by competing factions, that I thought what had been a rather sedate but interesting start was going to move into hilarity. But instead the movie became less comedic after that point.

Unfortunate the dramatic elements aren't all that interesting. The movie seems to know that, as it keeps a lot of dramatic threads sketchy. But that just makes the drama weaker; Burl Ives character is never properly explored, and a romance late in the film flowers out of virtually nothing.

The movie is well-filmed (at times it's reminiscent in style to director Carol Reed's masterwork The Third Man) and has some good performances (Ernie Kovacs is quite good as a genial yet brutal police captain), but much of it feels like a lost opportunity to push it's brilliant satirical premise to the dark comedy it seems so capable of.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Guinness is good for you
dhwillis-230 September 2006
Sir Alec is, as always, magnetic. Guinness described himself as someone who liked to put on the mask, preferring to live someone else's life in order to keep his own private. Here his character tries to do something like that, with mixed results.

What is it about Guinness that makes it so hard to take our eyes off him? This role is, in a way, a variation on Col. Nicholson: the simple soul who discovers, a little too late, that he has understood nothing. In both cases their innocent acts start a chain of events that comes close to tragedy (but for Hollywood endings), and yet we never think of blaming either character for what they have brought about.

On the contrary, it's hard not to feel that Wormold deserves all of his undeserved good fortune, which appears to come at no cost. And even after Greene's story dispels that illusion, we still feel that his decency ought to count for something, even if his intentions were less than pure.

You can read this movie as an allegory for the common delusion on the part of great powers that they can direct events to their liking. If so, then Guinness has, even without the tacked on ending, subverted it. And even if we know better, it is hard not to cheer for him.
23 out of 29 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Cuban comic relief for spy-masters
Philby-330 May 2008
Made nearly 50 years ago in black and white (though in Cinemascope), this film still has some charm. It was filmed in Cuba in 1959 just after Castro came to power and the Havana of the film is not the crumbling city it is today – the 1950s American cars for instance are in showroom condition. The setting is the better parts of town just before the revolution and we glimpse the sybaritic life the doomed upper classes led. Revolution or not, Carol Reed here takes a holiday from directing serious films and along with Graham Greene as screenwriter concentrates on sending up espionage thrillers. Alec Guinness is comfortably at home in the role of as Wormold, a vacuum cleaner salesman for Hoover who suddenly has the role of secret agent thrust upon him. Ernie Kovaks (hitherto a US TV comic) puts in a nuanced performance as the chief of police in a seriously bent town. Jo Morrow, who more or less disappeared after this film, is quite effective as Wormold's pretty young daughter Milly.

The M15 of the day is accurately portrayed as a bunch of incompetent snobs, with Ralph Richardson the boss being the master of the cover-up. No-one is better at carrying on in the face of disaster as if nothing has happened than he. Noel Coward plays the role of Hawthorn, Wormold's controller, pretty well without acting at all. That such a person should stride round Havana in dark suit, bowler hat and umbrella drawing attention to himself is utterly ridiculous, of course, but Coward gets away with it by just being Noel Coward. The lovely Maureen O'Hara as the agent sent from London to assist our man in Havana seems lost, or at least as if she is in another movie, a romantic spy drama perhaps. (I can imagine her as Ms Moneypenny). Burl Ives as Wormold's not –so-loyal friend Hasslebatcher is a curious character – his fate does not match the otherwise knockabout comic tone. Ives was not much of an actor, but his role here is minor.

Looking back at it now, this film seems to fall in the Ealing comedy tradition - little man triumphs over the powers that be - though of a glossier and more expensive kind than usual as Columbia was paying the bills. It does suffer from an unevenness of tone, as if Greene as writer was veering between pure comic relief and serious drama. It's not one of Reed or Greene's better efforts (they were responsible together for the sublime "The Third Man") but still quite watchable, which is something to be said after 50 years.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Noel Coward and his Ensemble
B2416 July 2003
The novel was infinitely darker than the film. Satire is never casually light-hearted; it has a serious purpose. But this film is touched by the hand of slapstick artist Ernie Kovacs and, in an entirely different comedic way, Noel Coward. As many reviewers have noted, Alec Guinness seems at a loss in more ways than one to bring together all the different strands of entirely disparate story lines that are woven around him. The parts are indeed greater than the whole.

The one scene that I have carried with me, lo, these many years is the one where Sir Noel is having a confidential tête-à-tête with Sir Alec in a tropical garden surrounded by a rattan shell, and he suddenly shushes Sir Alec and cautiously moves to close the putative entry door. One of the best sight gags ever.

The sad thing about "Our Man in Havana" is that it came out the same year that Cuba traded in one tyrant for another. And there is nothing funny at all about either Fulgencia Bautista or Fidel Castro. I recommend the excellent film "Before Night Falls" for those persuaded that the latter was the lesser of two evils.

In short, one has to choose the comedic elements over the political ones in order to enjoy the film. And that means essentially anchoring it to the role of Noel Coward and everyone else who falls in his shadow.
24 out of 34 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Our Man In Havana
stevemaitland28 May 2018
Carol Reed echoes the musical score and, at least latterly, the dynamic compositions of earlier Graham Greene collaboration The Third Man in this 1959 Cuba-set spy outing. Alec Guiness is well cast as Wormold, a vacuum cleaner salesman covertly recruited by a British Intelligence agent (Noel Coward). In humourous scenes Wormold then clumsily attempts to recruit others in the same manner - notably in a Gent's lavatory.

...After that I'm afraid I lost the thread. Too many spies and their associates to keep track of. But the film is a good watch all the same and you always get the gist of what's going on. The authentic Cuban setting - its people and customs milling around central characters - makes for a refreshing escapism too.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Mediocre!
RodrigAndrisan6 January 2020
I had heard about this movie a long time ago and wanted to see it. But I haven't had the opportunity so far. In my chilldhood's Romania was considered dangerous to be showed. So, I was expecting something more and better, specially from Carol Reed, the maker of "Oliver!" and "The Third Man", two very good films. The story disappointed me, nothing extraordinary. A banal story about a vacuum-cleaners salesman who starts to lie everybody... Childish! Very good actors in the cast: Alec Guinness, Noël Coward, Ralph Richardson, Ernie Kovacs. The best are Ernie Kovacs and Noël Coward.
6 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed