"Out of the Unknown" The Machine Stops (TV Episode 1966) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Why is this never shown?
tom_prendergast16 April 2005
I remember reading this book, whilst at Grammar school, in England, in the 60's. It was only after that time, that I realised that it was written in 1909. I thought, back then, that it was written in the 30's, which only makes its predictions even more astounding. Obviously, it is dated and naive, but bear in mind that it was written over 90 years ago.

This short story by E M Forster, foresaw the advent of TV, E-mail and the Internet. It predicts a bleak future where humans live underground and communicate via Cinematophote. An astounding vision of the future, remarkable for its time.

We haven't got that far yet, whereby direct human contact is avoided at all costs, but who knows what the future might bring?
16 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
"What's the good of going to Peking when it's just like Shrewsbury?" Thought provoking sci-fi drama.
poolandrews20 October 2010
Warning: Spoilers
Out of the Unknown: The Machine Stops is set in the far future where humanity now live underground in small subterranean rooms in a vast network of tunnels that is maintained by machines & computers, the machines & computers provide everything for humanity including air, music, food & transport. The idea of human contact is almost obsolete as people communicate through the computer & there is no need to visit the surface of the Earth anymore, a young man named Kuno (Michael Gothard) tries to convince his mother Vashti (Yvonne Mitchell) that the machine may stop & that humanity has become to reliant on it...

Episode one from season two of this sci-fi series this was directed by Philip Saville & is apparently regarded as the best surviving episode from Out of the Unknown which I am not sure about myself but it's a worthy watch none the less. Adapted by Kenneth Cavander & Clive Donner based on the novel The Machine Stops by E.M. Forster first published in 1908 this was actually the oldest story to be adapted for the show although I suppose one could say it's theme about over reliance on machines is pretty timeless. However, having said that the theme that technology is bad & as a society we shouldn't be too reliant on it is hammered home at every opportunity through some fairly unsubtle & blunt dialogue but to balance that out the script does make it's points rather well. Generally quite thought provoking & still relevant to some extent even today the central social message The Machine Stops gets across is a fairly effective one. What will happen when the machine stops & the question of who will mend the menders when they need mending? Also, in answer to Vashti's question, because Peking is in reality nothing like Shrewsbury woman, that's why.

Originally broadcast in October 1966 the start of the second season of Out of the Unknown saw a change in duration, most episodes from season one ran about sixty odd minutes while season two episodes ran about fifty with the notable exception of episode four Level 7 (1966) which did run for an hour. Only four episodes still survive from the second season's thirteen episode run so there are huge gaps in the archive thanks to the BBC's wiping & junking policy of the 60's & 70's. The production design is quite nice, some of it predictably looks dated like the huge computer (I think my Samgung Wave mobile phone is more sophisticated) but I did find the scene in which Kuno drops something onto the floor & a section rises up so he wouldn't have to bend down to pick the object back up amusing & a nice visual image of how the machine caters for all of humanity's needs.

The Machine Stops feels like a stage play & may be a little slow for modern tastes but the core story is interesting & fairly intelligently put across, even the futuristic setting is quite well realised considering. Serious sci-fi fans should definitely watch it if you can actually find a copy which is easier said than done having never been officially released anywhere. The following episode, Frankenstein Mark 2 (1966) is yet another missing one from the BBC archive & is not known to exist.
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Excellent adaption of E.M. Forster's remarkably prescient cautionary tale
jamesrupert201416 June 2022
In a distant future in which humans live in underground isolation and have every need taken care of by an ubiquitous, omniscient Machine, one man dares to try to see beyond the Machine's omnipotent control. Written long before computers or the instantaneous transmission of images and data, Forster's remarkably foresighted work envisions a world were humans are so dependent on their technology that life without it is almost unimaginable (and trying to imagine it borders on heresy). This episode of the British mid-60's sci-fi anthology series 'Out of the Unknown' is quite well made considering the budget, with imaginative set design and sound, a literate script, and good acting from stars Michael Gothard and Yvonne Mitchell. That the BBC destroyed thousands of hours of quality programming like this to save a bit of space and a few quid is tragic.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Amazingly prophetic
steve-butten30 March 2021
Much is made of the fact that this was written in 1909 as little more than short story and rightly so; its visions of TV, email, internet and remote health care are astonishing. I read this at school as part of a short story project and was much affected by it. I was lucky to see this 1966 BBC treatment of it and it is spellbinding despite its now obvious problems with future fashion predictions.

It is a dark vision, that today brings to mind Blade Runner, Wall-E, Total Recall and just about any dystopian message you care to bring up. Sadly it is a piece that has now all but disappeared behind the BFI pay wall and may only rarely get a free airing.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed