User Reviews

Vince, the younger brother of exiled mafioso, Frank Ginetta, comes to visit his sibling in Sicily, where he has been hiding. Vince has come on a mission although we must wait until much later because we are taken back to get to know Frank's involvement in crime in New York.

In flashbacks we are taken to Vince's wedding to Emma Bertolo, the daughter of a prominent mafia bigwig in Brooklyn, where Frank controls the criminal operations. Vince, a man that has gone into the US army and has studied, is also drawn into the illegal activities by loyalty to his brother. Family, among these men matters more than anything else. Vince, who grows disillusioned with Frank, is given the ultimate mission anyone in the organized crime can get.

No one can accuse Lewis John Carlino, the screenplay writer, with copying the more famous "The Godfather", which came out later. The film, directed by Martin Ritt, is uneven, at best. The story is about power more than gore and shootouts. Kirk Douglas, the star, produced the film as well as appeared as Frank.

Mr. Ritt got the atmosphere right, although the Sicilian locations are just a passing thought. Alex Cord, who made a career on television, is impressive in his take of Vince. Irene Pappas and Susan Strasberg have nothing to do. Luther Adler, Murray Hamilton, Eduardo Cianelli, are among the supporting players.

A famous failure when it premiered, The Brotherhood is a prime example of how badly made gangster films were before Coppola's The Godfather. Populated by actors who are Jewish, Greek, Mexican--and whatever Murray Hamilton is, The Brotherhood has no feel for Italian culture, New York City (where it's primarily set) or how modern gangs are structured and operate. Director Martin Ritt is most famous for rural-based films or films of social conscience and is seriously out of his depth in a crime film. The acting, save for Kirk Douglas' shameless over-acting, is competently done. Douglas gives the kind of hammy, schmaltzy "ethnic" performance that blemished much of Anthony Quinn's later career. The other actors seem to know their lines and recite them clearly enough for the audience to hear. The script is a time-worn template: the older, hot tempered traditionalist brother vs. the younger, college-educated one as they struggle to run their business. The one potentially interesting sub-plot, a Senate investigation of the mob,is mentioned but never developed. Like most of the film, it's lost in a sluggish flow of clichéd brother vs. brother generational conflict. Finally though, The Brotherhood isn't a bad film, just a very dull one. Watch this only if it's late and you're home sick with the flu.

This one should have been great with director Martin Ritt, screenwriter Lewis John Carlino, and star Kirk Douglas. But instead it's just okay, a very talkie film with only hints of intrigue and not much to praise outside of a few of the performances, some nice location photography and a few sequences that show the potential. I loved the opening of Alex Cord arriving in Palermo to visit brother Douglas, showing him driving through the picturesque mountains with curvy roads and the sea just below the foot of these giant hills.

The intrigue of Cord's troubled relationship with brother Douglas is interesting too, but there's lengthy bits of nothingness between important scenes often makes the film seem interminable. Irene Papas and Susan Strasberg as the wives have one or two good scenes each, but the charscters feel underdeveloped. The plot revolves mainly around discussions of the past, mob family rivalries and innumerable discussions over possible mob hits, and whom Douglas believes is out to put a hit on gin.

The best scene surrounds another mob family leader, Luther Adoer, estranged from Douglas and his family, given an opportunity for reconciliation over a big meal. The viewer can tell through Douglas's friendly discussion over an ancient hit that Adler is being set up, and as the town car drives along the west side highway up to the George Washington Bridge, it's only a matter of when and how Adler gets his. So it's a letdown, no rival to "The Godfather", sadly because it could have been a contender.

The Brotherhood was made 4 years before the legendary blockbuster classic, The Godfather. However, it's amazing how much of this earlier film about the "brotherhood" is so similar to the Godfather. Alex Cord is the younger brother of mob boss Kirk Douglas. There's a wedding scene (sound familiar?), as Cord returns from the war (Viet-Nam), and gets married in his army uniform. Godfather begins with a wedding; Al Pacino arrives back from the war(WWII), wearing his marine corp uniform. The Brotherhood is a story of tradition, as well-as the desire for power, power that's stronger than family ties. Two brothers in conflict. The Godfather has similar scenes and themes. I'm giving the ending away (sorry), but Alex Cord gives his brother Frank(Kirk Douglas) the "Kiss of Death" and kills him with a shot-gun to avenge the family's honor. Godfather II is similar with Al Pacino's character ordering the murder of his older brother Fredo.

The Brotherhood is well acted. Kirk Douglas is out-standing in one of his better "later" roles. Alex Cord gives his best on-screen performance. Veteran actor Luther Adler is out-standing as well as the traitor. The scene in which Adler is hog-tied and strangled is one of the most brutal and graphic in screen history. This is a non-romanticized looked at the Brotherhood. There are no heroes, or big shoot-outs. It's raw, brutal, edgy, and realistic. An out-standing work, even some 37 years later.

Apparently, when "The Brotherhood" debuted, critics disliked it and the film lost money as the public never embraced it. Now, more than 40 years later, the film has a completely mediocre IMDb score of 6.1. And, I am left to wonder why the film is so maligned. After all, I really liked the film and thought it was exceptionally well made and quite compelling. It's like I saw an entirely different film than the one everyone else saw...or I just have absolutely no taste.

"The Brotherhood" is a mobster film that is actually highly reminiscent of "The Godfather". Like Don Corleone from "The Godfather", Frank Ginetta (Kirk Douglas) is a bit of a dinosaur in the mob. While respected and powerful, he doesn't like the direction the organization is going and fights change--choosing instead to hold on to the old ways. The problem is that the longer he does this, the more he makes himself an impediment--one that might just be eliminated.

At the same time, Frank's brother, Vince (Alex Cord) joins the family business and does well. In fact, when Frank gets on the bad side of the other bosses, there is talk that Vince should perhaps take his older brother's place.

Into the mix comes another reason for the mob to take out Frank. It seems that one of the bosses (Luther Adler) had been responsible for the death of many mobsters many years ago--and Frank just discovered this. To make matters worse, this traitor also was responsible for the death of Frank and Vince's father! What happens next? See the film for its gritty finale.

All around, it's a very good film. Kirk Douglas was surprisingly convincing as a Sicilian-American. I have no idea how good his Sicilian and Italian was throughout the film but it sounded good. I'd love to hear what some Italians think of his portrayal. Otherwise, the script is tight and well written, the film is well directed. The only possible negative I saw was if you an Alex Cord fan--he really didn't have a lot to say or do--it was clearly Douglas' film.

If you do watch the film, one bit of warning. While you'd expect a mob film to be violent, you might think since it came out in the 60s that it would be very sanitized. Well, there are some gritty scenes--especially when Douglas murders someone--it's VERY vivid and tough to watch.

PREDATING the Mario Puzo tale of Mafiosi in immediate Post World War II NYC by over four years, THE BROTHERHOOD (The Brotherhood Company/Paramount Pictures Company, 1968) was a great example of the underworld life, every bit bas good as THE GODFATHER (Paramount Pictures, 1972) It did not compare to the latter in respect to its stature and epic standards, but nonetheless it has the proper spirit and twisting storyline to make it ever so engaging.

TOLD in flashback from the point of view of Frank Ginetta (Kirk Douglas), the elder and prominent Underworld Mob Boss and Vince Ginetta (Alex Cord) the younger and much less criminally involved of the family. Frank has returned to the land of his ancestors, being in Sicily in current times; being 1968, when the film was made.

BOLDLY the scene returns to NYC several years earlier, where Frank Ginetta is celebrating at the Wedding of his younger brother, Vince. Shortly thereafter, he is confronted by a couple of old line Mafiosi or "Mustached Joes"; being Sicilian born, transplanted to the New World. The two men, Don Peppino (Eduardo Cianelli) and Pietro Rizzi (Joe DeSantis) have information about certain now High-Ranking Mafia Bosses had been instrumental in having many a Sicilian born mobster killed years earlier.* One of the victims was the Ginetta Boys Father.

Further complicating matters is the revelation that the main informant was the now Mob Boss, Dominic Bertolo (Luther Adler), who's Daughter, Emma (Susan Strasberg) has just married Vince Ginetta (Alex Cord) in a sort of Royal Underworld Wedding and a securing a veritable political alliance at the same time.

BEING a highly traditional type, Frank knows that it is his Sacred Duty to avenge this foul deed; so with Pietro Rizzi (Joe De Santis, again) acting as his chauffeur, Frank lures Dominic into a trap. Following an impromptu luncheon, Frank relates some amusing "war stories" from the "Old Days"; after which he confronted him with being the informer of those long days ago. With the help of Pietro Rizzi, he binds the hands of Bertolo and rig a neck to feet over the back rope, which slowly strangles the victim as his strength is ebbed away with his impossibly successful struggling.

AS the doomed Bertolo lies struggling, unquestionably facing the eventual fate that Frank has decreed him, the elder Ginetta reads the names of the slain who the bound and gagged gangster-chieftain had condemned.

MAKING the traditionalist Ginetta the obviously prime suspect is the fact that he uses so many of the old-line signs and symbols of intentional "hits"; such as his favourite of shoving a dead canary into the mouth of the "fink", leaving no doubt as to the reason for the murder.

FLEEING to Sicily, among many relatives, Frank and Mrs. Ida Ginetta (Irene Pappas) are in a seemingly endless Mediterranean vacation, when Brother Vince suddenly shows up in Sicily. The revelation doesn't upset Frank any, but it obvious that there's some major event by the expression on Ida's countenance.

MEETING the younger Brother and Junior Partner in their Construction Company at the Palermo Airport, Frank takes Vince to lodging among relatives and talks of tradition and its relevancy to today's world. Drinking Wine together and walking out into the Sicilian hills, Frank hands a Sicilian shotgun to his younger brother; imploring him to shoot, saying' "Go ahead, shoot! They got you by the throat!" THE 'they' referred to in Frank Ginetta's dying declaration were the modern day Crime Syndicate's Bosses, who demand that the Bertolo Slaying must be avenged by the younger Ginetta Brother.

THE BROTHERHOOD in addition to being a work of fictional gangs and mobsters, is maybe the first to emphasize the multi-ethnic make-up of the modern American Underworld. Gangsters of Irish Ancestry such as Jim Egan (Murray Hamilton), Jewish like Jake Rotherman (Val Avery) and others are present and prominent from the earliest of scenes in the Picture; emphatically underscoring that the Italian Mobster is far from being alone in the Nation's Underworld.

MAKING the one point crystal clear, that the make-up of the Crime Syndicate in modern days is far from being populated strictly with Italian hoods; but rather it is a sort of League of Nations. It is one that has a large number of ethnicities on its long list; being an ever growing roster of organized crime.

NOTE: * This event of many multiple executions of the "old line" gangsters is referred to in Urban Legend as "the Night of the Sicilian Vespers." There are two sides to the argument, with both great numbers of believers and just as many detractors who believe that the Sicilian Vespers never occurred.

POODLE SCHNITZ!!

A precursor to "The Godfather", "The Brotherhood" is a 1968 crime drama by director Martin Ritt.

Another forgotten auteur of the 1960s, and at one time loosely affiliated with left-wing and communist groups, the majority of Ritt's films feature ideological clashes. His 1965 masterpiece, "The Spy Who Came In From the Cold", for example, features Russian "communists" and Western "capitalists" engaging in games of deception and infiltration. "The Molly Maguires" (1970), meanwhile, features union groups being infiltrated by strike busters, whilst "Norma Rae" (1979) does the opposite, with unionists and agitators covertly infiltrating a textile factory. Such themes infect the majority of Ritt's films. "The Front" (1976), for example, finds an unwitting communist sympathiser hounded during the Red Scare years, whilst his 1963 and 1967 masterpieces, "Hud" and "Hombre", revolve around very specific cultural clashes, unhinged greed winning in "Hud", altruism and self-sacrifice in "Hombre", both to disastrous effects. The rest of Ritt's films ("Sounder", "Conrack", "Great White Hope" etc) tend to focus on the victims of racism, sexism or early 20th century capitalism. In this way, Ritt resembles many of the iconoclastic auteurs of mid century American cinema (Altman, Ashby, Michael Ritchie etc).

One of Ritt's lesser films, "The Brotherhood" stars Kirk Douglas as Frank Ginetta, a powerful mafia lord. Frank belongs to a "brotherhood" of gangsters, a collection of warlords who have their own codes, laws and shared interests. When this "brotherhood" attempts to diversify, expand and extend its reach in the search of new profits, Frank protests. Market expansion is fine, he says, but gangsters have their place. Encroach on the spheres and monopolies of the state and/or other "legitimate" businesses, and you'll draw unwanted attention. The other crime lords don't agree. They can make the transition, they insist.

As he remains steadfast in his convictions, the "brotherhood" attempt to oust Frank; they hire Frank's brother Vince to assassinate him. In scenes which recall the many "undercover agents" which litter Ritt's filmography, Vince "infiltrates" Frank's island stronghold and plots the latter's demise. Vince then takes over his brother's business, his entire body now epitomising the objectivity and impersonality of the New Economic Order.

At its best, "The Brotherhood" watches as a kind of nascent, tribal capitalism tries to sneak its way into the 21st century. All who oppose are killed, an act which echoes the fratricide of Ritt's "Hud" and genocides of Ritt's "Hombre". Caught in the middle of this "progress" is Ginetta, who embodies the kind of ideological confusion most Ritt leading men face. "Don't get confused which side you're on!" a character in Ritt's "The Molly Maguires" bluntly states.

Whilst "The Brotherhood" is interesting in relation to Ritt's other films, as a standalone picture it's mostly weak. Lewis John Carlino's script is superficial and Douglas is wholly miscast.

7.5/10 – Worth one viewing.

You cannot truly enjoy Francis Ford Coppola's "The Godfather" with Marlon Brando and Al Pacino unless you've seen Martin Ritt's "The Brotherhood" with Kirk Douglas and Alex Cord. Ritt's saga about La Cosa Nostra lacks the scope and spectacle of "The Godfather," but it touches all the traditional bases for an Italian crime thriller. Kirk Douglas is an old-fashioned Mafioso named Frank Ginetta and he refuses to change with the times. Alex Cord plays Kirk's brother Vince who has survived a tour of Vietnam with the U.S. Army. Unlike Al Pacino ex-G.I., Vince knows he must get into the family business. He explains that he is too old and it's been too long since his college days. He wants into the business and Frank couldn't be happier. Initially, all Vince does is review business deals. Eventually, Frank finds out that the board that he is a part of plans to expand. Frank worries about this change. He worries about the repercussions of the deal and he fears the government. Frank is traditional and likes to hang out with the old mafia types. These types were the company that his father kept. Frank discovers that one of the board member is a canary. Earlier, in the first display of violence, Frank ordered the murder of a canary. Moreover, Frank learns that this canary was responsible for the death of his dad. Later, Vince questions Frank's decision about these new interests. As it turns out, Vince's father-in-law is a member of the board on which Frank serves with other business-minded people. When the feces hits the fan, everybody is into conflict, and blood isn't thicker than business.

Despite several similarities, "The Brotherhood" differs. Whereas Brando refused to traffic in narcotics, Douglas doesn't want anything to do with electronics. Whereas Pacino didn't want to be in the business, Cord asks to be in the business. "The Godfather" cannot match the climax when brother turns on brother. Nevertheless, "The Godfather" boasts more violence and characters in a narrative that occurs over decades. "The Brotherhood" is really the last reel in "The Godfather." Vince commits an unpardonable crime against the board and flees to the safety of Sicily. Frank knows it is only a matter of time before the board dispatches somebody to ice him. When his brother Vince shows up in the old country to visit Frank, Frank welcomes him with open arms and assure everybody, including his suspicious wife that Vince isn't going to kill him.

Kirk Douglas makes a convincing mafia don, and Alex Cord looks like he could be Douglas' kin. Director Martin Ritt takes the subject matter of Louis John Carlino's screenplay with sobriety. The body count of "The Brotherhood" amounts to three. The canary dies in an isolated field. Later, Douglas kills more out of revenge. Finally, his younger brother Vincent carries out an underworld rite of passage. Basically, "The Brotherhood" doesn't wallow in one bloodbath after another. Ritt puts his first-rate through the paces in 94 minutes without let-up, but half of the time nothing exciting happens. The dialogue is largely forgettable, but the situations are genre conventions. Unfortunately, too much talking takes place when more shooting should have rung out. Ritt treats the subject matter as if he were making a crime version of "Death of a Salesman." Lalo Schifrin contributes a fine orchestral score. Part of the action is told in flashback. "The Brotherhood" is a dignified crime drama without a surfeit of violence.