Poor Brenda Vaccarro is really in trouble as an office worker mistaken for the sought after Carlotta in this comedy/drama which showcases a capable cast including Roddy McDowall and Vincent Price (in an untypical low brow turn) as hoods and Jack Warden as the police detective who tries to help Brenda out of this mess. Joanne Worley as Brenda's confidante and Michael Learned as a thug also appear, as does Edmond O'Brien towards the end.
A spunky performance from Vaccarro and all around likeable characters help this movie hold its interest until the satisfying conclusion.
This was made as an ABC Movie of the Week.
4 Reviews
Brenda Vaccaro's nice performance make this worth seeing.
planktonrules30 May 2020
The biggest reason to watch "What's a Nice Girl Like You...?" is the nice performance by Brenda Vaccaro as a smart-mouthed and sassy lady from the Bronx. She's fun to watch and makes an otherwise mediocre film well worth seeing.
The story begins with a couple goons trying to kidnap Shirley (Vaccaro). She is shocked....after all, who would want to kidnap a single working girl who isn't rich nor famous. Well, the spunky lady manages to crash the kidnsappers' vehicle that she was in...and they are killed and she manages to escape. Soon she shows up at Lt. Burton's office (Jack Warden) to report the attempted abduction. At first, the Lieutenant seems a bit incredulous but soon sees that yes, indeed, this unlikely lady was abducted, briefly, by some notorious hoods. Why? What would they want with her? See the film and find out yourself.
I loved Vaccaro in the film...she was great. I was a bit less thrilled by the plot--it seemed like it should either be funnier or more serious. But this is not a huge problem and the good far outweighs the bad.
By the way, it's interesting to see Robert Ito playing a morgue attendant in one brief scene, as soon after this he'd star as Quincy's assistant...in the city coroner's office!
The story begins with a couple goons trying to kidnap Shirley (Vaccaro). She is shocked....after all, who would want to kidnap a single working girl who isn't rich nor famous. Well, the spunky lady manages to crash the kidnsappers' vehicle that she was in...and they are killed and she manages to escape. Soon she shows up at Lt. Burton's office (Jack Warden) to report the attempted abduction. At first, the Lieutenant seems a bit incredulous but soon sees that yes, indeed, this unlikely lady was abducted, briefly, by some notorious hoods. Why? What would they want with her? See the film and find out yourself.
I loved Vaccaro in the film...she was great. I was a bit less thrilled by the plot--it seemed like it should either be funnier or more serious. But this is not a huge problem and the good far outweighs the bad.
By the way, it's interesting to see Robert Ito playing a morgue attendant in one brief scene, as soon after this he'd star as Quincy's assistant...in the city coroner's office!
Don't call me Shirley.
mark.waltz24 February 2023
Warning: Spoilers
The ironic thing about that line said by Brenda Vaccaro in this very entertaining TV movie is that her character's name is Shirley and certain people think that she's a rich socialite named Carlotta. Vaccaro says that line (which Leslie Nielsen made immortal in "Airplane!") To police officer Jack Warden who interviews her after she is kidnapped by two men, is taking her for the mysterious Carlotta. Vaccaro and Warden manage to hit it off as he takes her testimony after the two men are killed when she makes their car go out of control. Now there's the danger of other people mistaking her for the unseen socialite, and it's up to Warden and her good pal, the wacky Joanne Worley, to keep her from getting into more trouble even though a bunch of weird characters keep popping up, insisting that Shirley is Carlotta.
This TV movie s quite amusing even though it is extremely farfetched. The opportunity to see such great supporting players as Roddy McDowell and Vincent Price, Edmund O'Brien, the then unknown Michael Lerner and other actors familiar by face if not by name is an absolute pleasure, and the script is witty and sardonic. Vaccaro and Warden have great chemistry, and Price (altering his voice to sound even more sinister, almost cartoon like) seems to be doing a Charles Nelson Reilly impression. This is Vaccaro at her most appealing, and it makes me wonder how she would have been in a 70's sitcom as a very emancipated woman dealing with wacky situations like she faces here. A reference to "My Fair Lady" is quite amusing. Ironically, Vaccaro's Oscar nominated role in "Midnight Cowboy" just two years before had her playing another New York City girl named Shirley.
This TV movie s quite amusing even though it is extremely farfetched. The opportunity to see such great supporting players as Roddy McDowell and Vincent Price, Edmund O'Brien, the then unknown Michael Lerner and other actors familiar by face if not by name is an absolute pleasure, and the script is witty and sardonic. Vaccaro and Warden have great chemistry, and Price (altering his voice to sound even more sinister, almost cartoon like) seems to be doing a Charles Nelson Reilly impression. This is Vaccaro at her most appealing, and it makes me wonder how she would have been in a 70's sitcom as a very emancipated woman dealing with wacky situations like she faces here. A reference to "My Fair Lady" is quite amusing. Ironically, Vaccaro's Oscar nominated role in "Midnight Cowboy" just two years before had her playing another New York City girl named Shirley.
Comedy or drama, hard to tell and not worth the effort
kevinolzak22 November 2022
1971's "What's a Nice Girl Like You...?" was an ABC TV movie boasting an impressive cast for an ill conceived outline that proves to be neither comedy nor drama, just improbably drawn out and deadly dull. Brenda Vaccaro headlines as Bronx working girl Shirley Campbel, enduring a whirlwind week in which she is kidnapped, threatened at gunpoint, and even yelled at by a myriad bunch of hired goons just because of her resemblance to a wealthy heiress who later is revealed to be deceased. Jack Warden is her unlikely love interest, a put upon police lieutenant concerned about their age gap while putting himself in harm's way. Things should take a turn for the better at the midway mark, with Roddy McDowall as would be actor Albert Soames and Vincent Price as extortion mastermind William Spevin, but even their efforts aren't enough to raise one's hopes, let alone those of the old man (Edmond O'Brien) whose promised cash payout to see his long lost daughter once more is the ultimate goal. With so many corpses left in her wake, an over the top Brenda Vaccaro almost singlehandedly sinks this attempt at a starring vehicle in the wake of her recent Oscar nomination for "Midnight Cowboy," a little bit of her goes a long way with those repeated shouts to "drop dead!" It wouldn't be any surprise if this tanked in the ratings, one of the very few instances of Vincent Price doing an actual TV movie rather than another of his numerous guest shots on popular series.
See also
Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews
