The Arrow Maiden is to become the wife of the Indian, who by his prowess at the games, proves himself the better man. Eagle Eye, thought to be the most expert, is the one rival of Brave Heart, the one whom the girl loves, but Eagle Eye does not win and the Chief awards the girl to Brave Heart, much to their happiness. The tribe's medicine woman, Dove Eye, has aroused the anger of the Chief, so that when Eagle Eye comes to her and asks her to cast a charm over Brave Heart as he sleeps before the tent of his affianced bride the old woman does as he requests, and the next day the weeping girl follows the body of her lover to the grave. Then the Medicine Woman learns of the perfidy of Eagle Eye, for he has had himself made Medicine Man in her stead, and now intends winning the girl. Arrow Maiden seeks the deposed Medicine Woman, who now realizes that she is responsible for the great sorrow that has come to the girl, determines to help Arrow Maiden, and at the same time revenge herself upon Eagle Eye. Meeting the maiden at the burying place of Brave Heart, she by her magic, awakens him from the spell she cast over him. Eagle Eye having followed the Maiden, arrives in time to see the two lovers embrace and is terror-stricken at sight of Brave Heart. This youth gives the evil one but short notice to defend himself before hurling him over the cliffs to the sea beneath. To the amazement of the Chief and tribe, who come to chant the death watch beside the body of Brave Heart, they see him, "risen from the dead," and Arrow Maiden, pledging their love to each other.
—Moving Picture World synopsis