A Voyage Around a Star (1906) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Imitation is the Most Profitable Form of Flattery
boblipton22 January 2009
Gaston Velle was Pathe's House Director for doing movies in the style of Georges Melies. This effort clearly shows the influence -- if that is not too weak a word -- of such pieces as 'Voyage a travers l'impossible' and, indeed, the lead character is made up and equipped like the umbrella-bearing crew member of 'Voyage Dans La Lune.' But, while this film lacks the vivacity and indeed, the beauty of Melies' pieces -- including the articulated vehicles that Melies used -- it is far more a cinematic movie than Melies. The effects are not achieved through stage magicianry, including raising and lowering people through trap doors in the floor, but solely by cuts and double exposures.

I don't feel the effects are as striking or even as amusing as Melies' work, but they were not pure imitations and eventually, Melies would be left behind.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
"Bubbles, Granddad!"
JoeytheBrit30 October 2009
Clearly influenced by - or, perhaps more accurately, copying - the work of Georges Melies, this film made by Gaston Velle is quite amusing, even though it is clearly copying Le voyage dans la lune, which Melies made four years earlier.

In this film we see a white-haired old astronomer surveying the night sky through his telescope. He is so enamoured by the things he sees that he decides he must take a closer look and enlists the aid of a servant. The relationship between these two is quite comical, and probably the most distinctive part of the film. Together, the two men create a giant soap bubble around the old astronomer and he floats gently up into the night sky where he meets a bevy of star maidens. The ending of the film is unexpectedly violent for such an old film.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Simplistic fantasy with some nice images but not up to the quality of Méliès work
jamesrupert20148 February 2020
An astronomer spots a lovely beckoning woman on a crescent moon, then a cranky-looking Saturn looking out from a hatch in the ringed-planet, then another lovely star-maid. With the help of his much abused assistant, he encases himself in a giant soap bubble and floats into the heavens, where he cavorts with the celestial woman. His effrontery angers the bearded God he had seen earlier, who casts him from the star, and when his umbrella fails to hold him up, he falls to his death, impaled on a weather vane. The film is a short, silly fantasy and not up to the quality (in either imagination or execution) of director Gaston Velle's contemporary Georges Méliès (although the sets are quite nice). The astronomer's relatively gruesome death is reminiscent the end of Dracula in Hammer's 'Dracula Has Risen from the Grave' (1968).
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed