Envy (1930) Poster

(1930)

User Reviews

Review this title
7 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
4/10
swinging 30's
SnoopyStyle30 May 2020
Helen and Jimmy are a rich and bored couple. They have invited their happy couple friends George and Rose. It turns out that George and Rose are also unhappy. Helen has the idea to exchange husbands.

This pre-Code short starts with an edgy premise. The game turns out to be less sexy and more talky. Despite the comedic attempts, non of it is actually funny. I don't like these people anyways. It's not only the characters who are bored.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
A Bit Stiff
boblipton30 May 2020
Here's a Vitagraph short in which a pair of young married couples swap..... in the politest sense of course. Each of the husbands try to say romantic things to the other's wife, and that's about the extent of the situation..... nothing, really, compared to sort of behavior that became a scandal in the 1960s.

The performances are a bit stiff and mannered, as if the sound equipment was considered unreliable, or this was a a stage skit that was transferred to the screen without much change in the performances.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A One-dimensional Skit
cabeattie25 July 2003
Consider this a bit of fluff, a skit in a comedy program. One bored couple anticipates a visit from another. To each couple, the other seems to be having more Public Displays of Affection; "the grass is greener." On a lark, they set aside their card game for a "new" game: trading partners and having fun. Nothing more than arms around waists and sweet talk, but each couple sets out to convince the other couple that their new coupling is having more PDA. Interesting for the flapper outfits and 'dos. In the end, they're back where they started, not having learned a thing from the experiment.
10 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
amusing little period piece
skiddoo3 January 2012
Warning: Spoilers
This needs restoring to improve the sound quality but then a lot of old movies need that so I don't take off stars for something that wasn't part of the original film. The directing is like a stage production which makes it seem more silent movie-ish than it really is. This was clearly from a studio with money for beautiful clothes and a lush set for a one-reeler.

I should point out that "making love" then meant being romantic and flirtatious, not having sex. The game wasn't about swapping spouses in the modern sense but of each person believing someone else was having a lot more fun and wanting in on that, envying the good times the others were supposedly having, as well as making the boring spouse jealous and willing to change his or her dull ways. But the woman who proposed the game and set the rules didn't like the way it was going from the start, obviously envisioning platonic joys.

Unfortunately, both couples were alike so mixing it up was futile, which was part of the humor. Amusingly both men had the same limited repertoire on the piano, and we saw that the one would-be Lothario thought he didn't have to say "I love you" to a wife. After that wreck of an evening, they parted with the same totally false conviviality with which they had begun, something not unknown in some social circles today. So the point was, in my view, that these people were useless socialites of no depth or inner resources with more money than brains, which we see in media-created celebs today. And keeping in mind that this was made in the Great Depression, anyone who envies THEM is a fool because this is what passes for the good life for these parasites. They weren't capable of learning any lessons from this but the audience might be--at least let's hope so!

If you don't expect much from this you will probably like it better. I found the final few minutes funny. Nice little twist there.

I'm guessing one-reelers were some sort of test movies for those involved, trying them out on a small scale before letting them do it on the large scale. But I could be wrong.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Painting the Clouds with Sunshine
wes-connors20 October 2014
Bickering and bored, young marrieds Helen (Madge Evans) and Jimmy (Eric Dressler) have invited another couple over for an evening of card-playing. Helen and Jimmy think the Parkers have a much more exciting marriage. After the guests arrive, we discover George (Romney Brent) and Rose believe their marriage is the dull one. To liven things up, the couples change partners. At first, it's exciting - but everyone learns their lesson. The mention of a wife who "makes love" to a lot of men indicates something less than physical sex. Still, we're supposed to fantasize the couples are swapping more than card partners. Since "Envy" is a comedy, the ending goes for the expected punchline. This Vitaphone comedy short is about as exciting as either of the marriages depicted.

*** Envy (12/30) Arthur Hurley ~ Madge Evans, Eric Dressler, Romney Brent
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Why all the hate?
masutz26 February 2023
Really unsure why all the reviews here are so down in this gem of a film that, despite its jaggedly uncomfortable datedness, served to allow some transparency into the general mores that existed in between the two World Wars.

I suggest finding this short movie that I've only just seen on TCM and can find absolutely nowhere else.

I loved that at every moment you watch this film, you can feel that these people understood the absurdity of what they were doing and still wanted to go on doing it.

Very much like this silly life we all lead. So much absurdity yet we all keep pounding on, beating our paths to a pulp.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Pre-Code Short
Michael_Elliott2 May 2009
Envy (1930)

** (out of 4)

A rather forgettable pre-code short has a bored couple growing tired of one another. Both member seems to think they'd have a better time with the friends coming over so they decide to switch and see if it's true or not. The theme of switching spouses is something we didn't see too much of during the early days of cinema but that's the subject here and the history behind that is a lot more entertaining than the actual film. The movie suffers from poor sound quality and rather awful acting, which was something stalking the movies during this early sound era. All four overact something horrid as they are constantly moving their arms and acting out everything they say. This might have been important in the silent era but it just doesn't work in a sound movie. The term "making love" is said quite a few times and the adult subject makes this unique but the end result isn't nearly as good as it should have been. For film buffs only.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed