User Reviews

Recommendation for Mercy could make you think that the Ontario government actually hanged an innocent 14-year-old guy. There's a chilling scene of the main character, John Robinson, finishing his last meal, being handcuffed and led to the gallows, walking alongside a Anglican priest, arriving to face a hooded hangman, the noose placed round his neck and the trapdoor lever pulled...his "best friend," a teenager who helped convict him, though, is pictured seated on a windowsill watching with cold interest, as the execution proceeds. It was all John's imagination of future events. The movie's production quality is a little amateurish, with an annoying electronic music score threaded throughout most scenes and some shaky camera-action, but it was done on a low budget by a director/producer who want to "get the story out" and somehow help the real victim of a wrongful conviction, Steven Truscott who, in 1959, was a typical nice- kid-RCAF-brat living in one of many postings his father had had during the 1950's around Canada, and who had the misfortune to give a 12-year- old girl a lift on his bicycle for about four miles to Highway 8 so she could see a local farmer's ponies. Steven left her there and lazily pedaled back home, stopping to visit with pals who were swimming in the local river and others who were playing baseball at the schoolyard. The girl who'd hitched a ride on Steve's bicycle, Lynn Harper, was brutally raped and murdered, her body found very near the County Road which she and Steven had traveled to reach the intersection with the Highway. Within 3 months, the boy was tried, convicted and sentenced to hang for the crime, all on some very flimsy circumstantial and manufactured evidence. Local & Provincial Police and a hot-shot prosecutor manipulated their prisoner, his friends and medical evidence in an effort to get a quick conviction and hold onto their jobs in the face of a public outcry and increased fears that a psychotic killer was lose among the local populace. The judge presiding at the trial, in real life, obviously considered himself to be the prosecutor's b*tch, asking pointed questions from the bench that tended to shore up the shaky evidence against Truscott over and over again. Admittedly, 1959 was a time when most people in North American culture tended to trust government authorities, so it was relatively easy to convict a teenager who was woefully ill-prepared to defend himself either psychically or financially. It wasn't until 1976 that Canadian Defence Attorneys won the right of examining all the prosecution's assembled evidence in what is commonly called the "discovery process". Such barriers to justice helped substantially to convicted Truscott and send him to the Huron County jail in Goderich, ON to await his hanging for over five long months. Truscott's death sentence was finally commuted to a life term and he was paroled after ten years in custody. He lived an honorable, responsible life, marrying just once never divorced, raising two children, working hard as a machinist not 40 miles away from where he'd once sat in the death cell at age 14-15. This film portrays a very different background story, putting John Robinson in the role of a boyfriend of the murder victim and doesn't portray the circumstances of his giving the girl who would be murdered a lift on his bicycle very clearly. The music score distracts the viewer from following what the two kids are doing that fateful evening, so we don't get a clear picture of John's innocence. Those unfamiliar with the Truscott story will question throughout whether or not John is guilty of the crime, save his continued insistence on his own innocence and his failure to change the story he tells the police. Confusing elements like too many flashbacks and the introduction of two very pretty 14-year-old girls who look too much alike to keep the story flowing well; one the victim and one is her friend who later on testifies against John in court. The military element is missing in the film, an important element \ which also helped in Truscott's wrongful conviction...the local civilian population distrusted the military families who move in and out of little Clinton, ON with such regularity...and the Truscott jury was made up entirely of local middle-aged civilian men, just the kind of people who would most-deeply mistrust teenage guys and later admitted they all viewed Truscott as guilty from the start. The director rescues us from our confusion somewhat as the actual trial proceeds, bringing to light John's "friends" and their successful manipulation by the police & prosecutor and helps illustrate what false maturity is demanded of impressionable teenagers who get mixed up in the legal system.

First I saw this movie as a teenager in the early 80s. I was so impressed by actor Andrew Skidd and his sensitive kind of playing his difficult part. It took me a long time to find this movie on video tape. Now after about 25 years I watched it again - the movie was worth such a long search. Hard to understand what happened to a boy, a teenager, whose only fault it was to be in love with a young girl and to be the last to see her alive. Well, not really the last, this must have been the real murderer...The accused maintains his innocence. Was it not a crime, what the law did to him? There are so many questions the movie tells us. And there are no answers. That's why this movie has been in my memory for all those years and will be further on. A special movie, always realistically made and played. A jewel!

I wonder what happened to actor Andrew Skidd. Was this his only part in a movie? By the way, the song "Surrender to the sun" of Scott Fagan is also remarkable.

Don't let the film format (16mm) fool you. This is a gritty and somewhat graphic story based on actual events which took place in Canada some 30 years ago. John Robinson is a nice 14 year old kid. He's good looking, a natural athlete and the prime suspect in a rape and murder case. The shoddy police and forensic investigation seals the boy's fate. Child witnesses also sabotage John's hope of being found innocent. The movie follows John's harrowing experience in court but also explores the complexities of teen sexuality. The star is Andrew Skidd whose stand out performance is quite moving. The editing and sound is not up to par but watching it for Skidd alone is worth it. This is a rare film to find but one you won't want to overlook.