Hold 'er Sheriff follows the adventures of a Sheriffs daughter Marge Martin (Marjorie Beebe) who falls in love with a handsome man (Jimmy Murray). He jokes with her and her father that he's going to rob a bank. Then the sheriff's safe gets robbed, and Jimmy disappears and becomes the main suspect. Marge's father (George Pierce) is not pleased with Marge, and Marge is bitterly disappointed with Jimmy. She resolves to capture him, and sets off on her horse, guns at the ready. But Jimmy is not all that he seems, and Marge bites off a lot more than she can chew. A comedy of mistaken identities, and a vehicle for Marjorie Beebe to ride the range, do some sharpshooting, and dress up as a moustachioed bandit.