Alter Ego (2002) Poster

(2002)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Reasonably entertaining small scale Japan ghost horror flick
lemon_magic12 February 2019
Warning: Spoilers
This movie has its moments, but maybe not enough of them to justify your time.

The Amazon Prime synopsis (fashion models doing a photo shoot in an abandoned school who are beset by supernatural forces) made me think that this was actually another, better known Japanese horror film reviewed favorably in "DVD Delirium 2", but 5 minutes into it, I realized that it was a different movie altogether.

But that's OK.

The movie has a very small cast - three young schoolgirls, a female chaperone, a male photographer, and two male representatives of the fashion photography industry (oh, and a walk-on role by a yellow journalist in the prologue and epilogue). All the actors are decent-to-pretty good, even the girls. (I was lucky to see this the Japanese language version with subtitles, so their performances weren't compromised by a bad or indifferent dub.) But the characters are cardboard, so it's hard to care a lot about their fates, and the lack of outside interaction makes for a fairly sterile and unexciting environment.

On second thought, that might be what the director was trying for - a sterile, airless, self-contained environment that allows nothing in or out- not unlike a mirror. There's certainly enough professionalism on display that I wouldn't discredit the notion that this extra depth was intended as part of the movie's "feel". But it didn't make for a better movie for whatever reasons.

The driving motor for the screenplay is that one of the young girls makes an angry wish into a pair of mirrors and somehow unleashes a curse that brings the group's doppelgangers to life, and each doppelganger is a nemesis that proceeds to kill its real life counterpart.

This isn't a bad idea, it just isn't very fresh; the set up is kind of flat and the execution is just OK. It lets the director do some of the standard "malevolent, inexplicable, and unstoppable girl ghost with jump cuts and crawling" tropes that the Japanese do so well (which makes sense, since this director later did the originals of "The Grudge", "The Ring", etc). If you like that sort of thing, you'll get a fair amount of it here. That might be all you want, and if so, go to it; you'll be happy.

The movie is quite short, barely more than an hour, and manages several creepy moments on what appears to be a very small budget (most of the special effects are effective, but not especially impressive.) So I say...Not bad. 6 (just barely) out of 10.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
An Oddity
silvio-mitsubishi29 June 2022
A Japanese horror, perhaps elevated by the fact the producer later directed Ju-On and others in the Grudge franchise.

A closed location - an abandoned school - makes for creepy atmospherics, and the tension grows but perhaps a little too slowly. Adults are sleazy, and teens not quite as compliant as they first appear. Two of the male characters are unpleasantly lascivious, and the other adults are complicit to some extent. Deaths follow a pleasingly moral arc, despite the questionable subject - exploitation of teen actor / models, and the cynical use of earlier 'Lolita' shots.

Special effects are weak, but disturbing anyway in the way Troma visuals often were. The script is not Shakespeare, as predicted by the obvious low budget, but the version I saw on Amazon Prime had the most appalling subtitling - Amazon's fault, not the film's, but lines were out of order and frequently appeared before characters spoke, so the actual words we could read a girl saying were accompanied by images of a man moving his lips.

Japanese horror films have a recognisable style, and this is no different. A logic perhaps more familiar to native audiences, but some engagingly disturbing imagery. The whole story is framed by a journalist collaring a character in the street a year later, which sets up a satisfying final twist. Not a huge time investment, worth a go if you enjoyed Ringu or Ju-On.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Endearingly...well...awful
sorinapha23 November 2015
Warning: Spoilers
This is just...not a good movie. I saw Shimizu-san's name attached to this project, I found it on Shudder entirely by accident, and I got excited, but this movie looked from the very first frame like it was filmed by a high schooler-- and it only got worse from there, but in a strangely enjoyable way? Like, this movie was a train wreck in every conceivable way, but it was so damn funny! I know I don't sound very scholarly at the moment, and my intention with taking up IMDb was to become a better viewer and therefore writer of films, so I feel like this review is a staunch failure on my part. But I just don't know what to say about this film other than it really looks like the special effects were made with Photo Booth.

However, in spite of objectively being one of the worst films I have ever seen, it's strangely endearing-- though I'm confused as to why Shimizu-san was attached to this project? I know his recent films haven't been exactly good by most people's standards, but this makes The Shock Labyrinth look like a Scorsese.

Anyway, bottom line-- watch it and laugh. It's only an hour and three minutes long and it's terrible.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed