"Alfred Hitchcock Presents" Relative Value (TV Episode 1959) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
7 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
John is a complete jerk...and he gets his in the end!
planktonrules2 April 2021
One of the things I often enjoy in some of the "Alfred Hitchcock Presents" episodes is seeing truly awful people getting theirs by the end of the show...and "Relative Value" is one of these.

John (Denholm Elliot) is a weasel. He's lazy and expects the most out of life...and to pay for his lavish lifestyle, he's taken to forging checks with Cousin Felix's name on them! John figures Felix owes it to him....as he's Felix's only heir and he'll inherit the money after this sickly man dies. But since John is a dirt-bag, he can't wait for Felix to assume room temperature and he decides to speed up the process....with disastrous results! I won't say any more....suffice to say the ending is fitting and enjoyable.

Well written, exciting and a cut above the average, this is one to see.
15 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
"I wouldn't have done it, if I had any alternative!"
classicsoncall20 October 2021
Warning: Spoilers
When John Manbridge (Denholm Elliott) entered cousin Felix Manbridge's home through the window with the intention of doing him in, it looked to me like Felix was already dead. John could have saved himself a lot of trouble if he had only checked. Odd too that clocking Felix on the old noggin didn't result in any type of bruise, cut or bleeding, since that was an iron fireplace poker. This story had a surprisingly satisfactory ending for John Manbridge, who didn't get away with the murder he so meticulously planned out. The only thing is, Constable Longdon (Barry Harvey) seemed awfully nonchalant about having given Manbridge the poisoned glass of whiskey that did in Uncle Felix. I guess he and the Inspector (Tom Conway) felt he had it coming.
9 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
The Plot Doesn't Wash
Hitchcoc27 April 2023
Warning: Spoilers
John is a lowlife and takes advantage of his cousin, who has been very patient with him. Felix knows he will be dying soon and tells John to quit writing checks; he will get the money soon enough. Of course, that's what Macbeth thought. John decides tomorrow is too far away, sneaks in, and hits Felix over the head. He then pretends to be visiting him, getting a police officer to check on the cousin. Of course, no bad deed goes unpunished with Hitchcock at the helm. Stupid people who do evil things need to pay the price. John eventually gets his, but the way the story is plotted brings in things not in evidence before. This should have been tighter and more suspense should have been used.
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Neat Double Twist
dougdoepke7 April 2011
Wastrel John Manbridge has written a couple of bad checks on his cousin Felix's account. Fed up, Felix threatens to turn him in if there's another. Trouble is that John's already written another, so what's he to do.

Really neat double twist distinguishes this otherwise routine entry. Elliot is perfect as the gentleman n'er-do-well,so good at scheming but not so good at betting on the horses. It's an all-British cast, including expatriate Tom Conway, then unfortunately on the alcoholic downgrade. The episode's setting, according to the checks written, is 1930 and I'm not sure why since it makes no obvious difference to the story. Anyway, I thought I had the twist figured, which I did, except they went me two twists better. See how you fare.
20 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Reasonably good value
TheLittleSongbird29 September 2023
"Relative Value" is the first of two 'Alfred Hitchcock Presents' episodes by Paul Almond. The other being "The Ikon of Elijah", which despite being a lot lower rated of the two episodes here was actually to me superior. There were some good episodes not directed by regular 'Alfred Hitchcock Presents' directors, though not all worked or were a mixed bag. Did quite like the premise for "Relative Value", which has also an intriguing title, and have liked the three leads in other things.

Was a little mixed on the episode. As far as Season 4 episodes go, "Relative Value" is neither one of the best or worst. Personally put it somewhere in the middle, finding it a decent, above average episode that could have been a lot better considering the premise and the cast. As far as 'Alfred Hitchcock Presents' goes, there has also been much better and much worse (Season 4 seeing both extremes before and since, particularly before). Mildly recommended but not an essential.

There are a lot of good things here. Denholm Elliott is excellent in the lead role, while Torin Thatcher and Tom Conway (older brother of George Sanders) are equally excellent. Can't fault the chemistry between them, which allows for a good deal of tension later. Almond does direct competently later on, with some nice style.

It looks pretty good, the setting being simple but not overly so and there is a lot of slickness and moodiness in the photography and lighting that enhance. The audio is suitably ominous and the series' theme music is still a classic. Hitchcock's bookending is amusingly ironic as usual, while the episode does become more intriguing and tense later with the highlight being the very well executed, unexpected and different ending and the interesting inclusion of more than one twist. Which are equally plausible and interesting.

However, there are things that are not executed so well. There is a real lack of suspense and surprises in an episode that does feel very routine. The pacing takes a while to come to life and the episode can be too talk heavy and unfortunately the talk is not consistently interesting and can ramble.

While Almond directs competently it is without distinction and never really does anything exceptional or original.

Overall, above average but rather mixed. Recommendation is partial. 6/10.
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Why did he burn the check??
deedrala11 April 2020
Warning: Spoilers
The other reviewer here is incorrect in saying that Felix is John's uncle - they are cousins, as is established in the first few minutes of the show. John is a ne'er-do-well gambler who refuses to work for a living and either borrows money from his cousin or forges checks to steal from him. Nevertheless, Cousin Felix leaves everything to John in his will since he is his only relative. But John is too impatient to get it, so he kills him in an elaborate scheme - unknowingly killing him when he was already dead of suicide.

During the 'murder', he finds an envelope addressed to him with a check inside for the same amount he had tried to borrow from Felix the day before, but was turned down. Then, inexplicably, he burns it in the fireplace......??? It was never explained why he did that and it makes no sense whatsoever, since he was desperate for money and had practically begged his cousin for it the day before.

If only he had waited another day or two, he would've been notified of his cousin's suicide and soon been given all his worldly possessions, but instead ended up dead beside his cousin due to the policeman's unknowingly giving him the same glass of alcohol that contained the poison that Felix had used to commit suicide.

But all that aside, I'd love to know why in the world he burned that check??
11 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Beaten to the punch
sol-kay1 July 2012
Warning: Spoilers
***SPOILERS*** Things are really starting to get desperate for all around leach and no good bum, who hasn't worked a day in his entire life, John Manbridge, Denholm Elliott, when his bets, by check, with his bookie Benny, Walker Buke, begin to bounce and he's about to cut off from betting on credit on the ponies. With John's only hope to keep up his free wheeling and spending lifestyle being his sick Uncle Felix, Torin Thatcher, he devises a plan to help him check into his grave a bit earlier then his doctors, who give Filex less then a year to live, think that he would. Uncle Felix for his part has no use for his irresponsible nephew John but in him being his only living blood relative he has no choice but to leave his money to him after he checks out, by dying, for good.

Like with everything else that he did in his life John screws things up for himself big time in his plan to off Uncle Felix as soon as possible so he can get his greedy hands on his money and run off to his bookie Benny and squander it away at the races. Covering all his bases John gets Uncle Filex alone in his mansion and bops him over the head with a fireplace poker and then tries to make it look like he fell and broke his neck. Getting local constable Longdon, Barry Harvey, to show up at the scene and making like he just discovered Uncle Felix's body everything seemed to have worked out to perfecting for John except just one thing! Uncle Felix had plans in advance to finish the job that John so elaborately planned for him!

***SPOILERS*** John proved to be the loser in this, getting Uncle Felix's money, like he was a loser at the racetrack in him jumping the gun after it was actually shot off! Uncle Felix in fact made it easy for John to get his money in knowing that he hasn't long to live but also left him something to remember him by. And with John now drunk with success in him pulling off the "perfect crime" and getting away with it his way of celebrating this big event in his life ended up becoming his funeral instead.
12 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed