"Doctor Who" Planet of the Spiders: Part One (TV Episode 1974) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Fitting send off for Jon Pertwee's Doctor
A_Kind_Of_CineMagic18 November 2014
Review of all 6 episodes:

This may not be the very best of the Pertwee era but it is an excellent story and a fitting finale for the Third incarnation of The Doctor. It is exciting, beautifully scripted by Robert Sloman (+Barry Letts) and well acted with poignant final scenes for Pertwee saying a sad farewell before regenerating into Tom Baker's 4th Doctor.

The story involves Mike Yates, convalescing in a Buddhist retreat and finding some of the others there are seemingly attempting to gain dangerous mental powers. He calls Sarah Jane in to help investigate. Meanwhile The Doctor and the Brigadier are investigating a psychic whose powers are beyond his own understanding and this power combines badly with the crystal from Metebelis 3 which The Doctor shows him after it is returned to him by former companion Jo Grant. This psychic event causes a link to be made by huge, psychically powerful spiders on Metebelis 3 with the men in the Buddhist retreat. A spider joins with the leader of the group Lupton and causes him to steal the crystal.

The first episode has great dialogue and a very interesting set up. The second episode is very entertaining and continues just as strongly with lovely exchanges between Pertwee, Nicholas Courtney and John Levene plus the wonderful Lis Sladen. There is thoughtful drama and great humour. Halfway through the second episode changes pace with a huge, slightly pointless but action packed chase sequence on numerous forms of transport. This is great fun if a little gratuitous. The only real flaw for me in the opening 2 parts is that they have a striking coincidence that the different strands of the story happen to link up - Mike happening to be at the very place that people become psychically linked to Metebelis 3 seeking the Doctor's crystal. But this is a common storytelling feature and not a big criticism at all. The humour, action and drama is great.

The third and fourth episodes continue with the entertaining drama, excellence in script and great acting from the regular cast. They are only held back a little by the humans - '2 legs' - on Metebelis 3 who are a bit disappointing compared to the whole rest of the production which is superb. The spiders are not really ground breaking but are scary, pretty effective for the time and well voiced, making them great monsters.

Episode 5 builds in quality with striking scenes where Pertwee acts intense fear and dread as he confronts the 'Great One' and delightful scenes with the character Kan-Po Rimpoche, The Doctor's former mentor who is brilliantly portrayed and a fascinating addition to the series lore. Episode 6 is superb and brings a tremendous climax to the story as well as a wonderful, moving end for Pertwee's Doctor. There are numerous powerful scenes in this final part and the script is excellent.

Benton, the Brig, Sarah Jane and Mike are all on top form. Best of all, Pertwee is tremendous in his final story and especially his final couple of episodes. The character portrayal with him realising he has let his quest for knowledge cause death and danger is fabulous and more clever and subtle than the efforts to show 'the dark side' of the Doctor by Stephen Moffatt in the modern era.

A great send off for the Third Doctor and an excellent addition to the series as a whole.

My ratings: Parts 1 & 2 - 9/10, Parts 3 & 4 - 8.5/10, Part 5 - 9/10, Part 6 - 10/10. Overall 9/10.

Season 11 was a fantastic season, my second favourite Pertwee season after Season 7 and one of the top 10 seasons ever in my opinion. Terrance Dicks and Barry Letts had done a terrific job running the show throughout the Pertwee era, maintaining consistent high standards. Pertwee himself was a marvelous Doctor who still remains one of the best to many of us.

My Season 11 Average Rating - 8.9/10

My Pertwee era average rating - 8.82/10.
8 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
I quite enjoyed this opening episode.
Sleepin_Dragon26 February 2021
A disgraced Mike Yates is trying to sort himself out at a retreat run by Tibetan monks, where the residents are attempting to communicate with something powerful.

It's a pretty good start, it's not a favourite of mine, but I understand why it's liked by many fans. A typical Letts and Dicks affair, full of gadgets and cloak and dagger stuff.

It's nice to see Mike Yates, after The Dinosaur affair, I thought we'd seen the last of him, but here he is, complete with beautiful MG. I like that we were given closure for Jo, mention of Liz would have been nice at some point too.

The scenes where The Doctor and Brigadier are sitting through the entertainment, waiting for The Professor are very funny.

We get a very important clue about the fate of Doctor number three from Choe Je, I wonder if regular fans spotted it or not.

The reveal..... That wasn't bad, but the title does give away any sort of surprise.

It started well, 7/10.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A fitting swansong
Leofwine_draca3 July 2015
PLANET OF THE SPIDERS is a fitting send-off for Third Doctor Jon Pertwee, with the writers crafting a very best-of serial that manages to throw just about everything into a six-episode running time. Thus we get the Doctor and Sarah Jane up to their usual adventures involving an interplanetary menace in the form of some sentient talking giant spiders (incorporating the usual cheesy but lovable SFX) and all manner of incident and intrigue.

Bessie and the Tardis figure predominantly, and the Brigadier and Sergeant Benson show up for good measure. There's an additional Time Lord thrown into the fray, alongside some Earth-bound black magic shenanigans, magic death rays coming out of people's fingertips (just like the Emperor in RETURN OF THE JEDI), a showdown with a giant foe, and some Venusian karate for good measure. Pertwee is clearly relishing his chance to shine for the last time, and there's a role for Gareth Hunt (THE NEW AVENGERS) hidden behind an Afro and a thick moustache. The Doctor's regeneration is fittingly poignant too. What's not to love?
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Not The Greatest Send Off
Theo Robertson19 August 2010
Warning: Spoilers
Review Of All Six Episodes - Slight Spoilers

If Planet Of The Spiders was produced by Russell T Davies we'd probably get every monster to have appeared in the show along with several returning companions . This wasn't how DOCTOR WHO was produced in the 1970s - it was made by professional makers of television and not children who suddenly woke up and found themselves in the sweet shop . That said one can't help thinking that maybe producer Barry Letts and co could have upped the ante somewhat and made a story that carried a bigger impact to its loyal audience

The story is set up by the Doctor receiving a letter from Jo Grant who is returning the Doctor's wedding gift to her , the blue crystal from Metebalis Three , because the natives on her expedition to the Amazon think it contains dangerous mystical properties . It turns out that while Jo might not want the crystal the ruling species of Metebalis Three do want the crystal returned for their own ends

This slight nod to nostalgia sets up the story but like so many adventures in the era it contains a lack of brevity in the story telling . Often this would be disguised on screen since everything was so enthralling . Here characters seemingly rush around because there's time to be filled before the regeneration in episode six

There's also a distinct lack of a chill factor . Spiders are scary but Letts turned down the original design of spiders for the story because he felt they were too frightening . Sorry Barry isn't that what the children wanted ? If you've got the choice between giant hairy tarantulas or anorexic spindly things as seen here then maybe the audience would prefer a bigger fright . There's also a lack of people getting killed on screen with a couple of notable exceptions which gives the story a rather tame feel

It's not all bad . Richard Franklyn as Mike Yates ( Now dismissed from the army ) is given an important role in the story unlike when he was in uniform and John Dearth makes an effectively understated villain who has clear and very human motivations but at the end of the day like much of the season Planet has a rather jaded feel so Pertwee , Letts and script editor Dicks probably left at the right time paving the way for a new Doctor and production team who took a successful television institution and took it to even better levels
5 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Out-Evolved by the Humble Spider
JamesHitchcock3 March 2016
Warning: Spoilers
It was originally intended to end Season 11 of Doctor Who with a story, provisionally entitled "The Final Game", featuring the character of The Master, whose last appearance in the series this was planned to be. This plan had to be abandoned after Roger Delgado's tragic death in a road accident, and a new story had to be written. By the time "Planet of the Spiders" was broadcast, Jon Pertwee had himself decided to leave the series, so the Third Doctor had to be written out. Planet of the Spiders" was therefore Pertwee's last appearance and the first of Tom Baker, who appears in the regeneration scene at the end. (Pertwee was later to claim that Delgado's death was one of his reasons for leaving the programme; although the two men played deadly enemies in the show they were close friends in real life. Delgado's widow Kismet provided one of the voices for the spiders in this story).

The action takes place partly on Earth and partly on the planet Metebelis Three, the titular "planet of the spiders". Humans have colonised this planet, but are no longer the dominant life-form. Thanks to some mysterious crystals they have been out-evolved by the humble spider. The planet is now dominated by some very large, hyper- intelligent spiders which use the surviving humans as their slaves. (For some reason the spiders prefer to be referred to as "eight-legs", the actual word "spider" itself being regarded as an insult). This storyline obviously owes something to the "Planet of the Apes" film franchise which also dealt with humans being first out-evolved and then enslaved by another life-form.

The Doctor and his assistant Sarah Jane Smith have to liberate the humans of Metebelis Three and also frustrate the spiders' plan to conquer the Earth as well. As the scenes set on Metebelis Three take place at some far-distant date in the future and those set on Earth during the 1970s, this implies that the spiders have the power to travel not just though space but also through time. At other points during the history of "Doctor Who" we are assured that time-travel is a Time Lord monopoly, but internal consistency has not always been a feature of the series. Perhaps this is inevitable given that the "Doctor Who" concept evolved over several decades and that there has never been one single scriptwriter controlling the whole project.

In common with a number of other six-part serials, "Planet of the Spiders" can seem too slow-moving at times, especially in the early episodes set on Earth. The Brigadier and UNIT are featured but they do not have a lot to do. The spiders probably seemed scary at the time, at least to the younger members of the audience, but they have never really become part of the catalogue of the Doctor's most iconic adversaries. The serial does have some good points. Pertwee's Third Doctor and Elisabeth Sladen's Sarah Jane are as reliable as ever and there are some intriguing minor characters, such as Tommy, the simple-minded handyman who is suddenly transformed into an intellectual when exposed to the same blue crystal which has done such wonders for the spiders, and the elderly Buddhist abbot K'anpo Rimpoche, who is supposedly from Tibet but who turns out to be another Time Lord. The introduction of Buddhist philosophy into the serial- the Earth scenes take place in a meditation centre- does not really advance the storyline but it is an intriguing feature, part of a quasi-religious tendency which occasionally manifested itself in "Doctor Who". As I said, however, this serial marked the end of the Pertwee era, and as he was probably my favourite Doctor (just ahead of Tom Baker) I think that it was a pity that he was not given a better send-off.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed