"Four Star Playhouse" My Wife Geraldine (TV Episode 1952) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
We all make up the "perfect" spouse, but he takes it too far.
mark.waltz4 February 2021
Warning: Spoilers
Just who is Charles Boyer trying to "gaslight" in this premiere episode of the Four Star Playhouse, and why? He claims to have a spouse, describing her perfectly to potential boss Porter Hall, landlady Una Merkel and salesgirl Noreen Nash, but no one ever sees her, even if she's an invisible rabbit taking a shower so husband Boyer can forge her signature on the lease. It's obvious that Boyer bought some women's clothes just to continue to fool Merkel when she stops by.

Told through flashback as Boyer confesses the truth to Merkel, it seems that Boyer's lies seem to begin to fool him into thinking that Geraldine, the wife, really exists. While it is apparent that he needs to have a spouse to get the job he wants, eventually, the mystery becomes a bit bizarre. In spite of some questionable plot decisions for the story, this is enjoyable for the performances and some subtle comedy. The guest stars, all familiar faces from many classic films, add a real touch of class, and an ironic twist provides the exposure the story needed.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The Bittersweet World of Imagination
haniaelrawy7 March 2019
This episode of 'Four Star Playhouse' series is one of Charles Boyer's masterpieces on the small screen. He displays the character of Mr. Graham, a lonely man living with an imaginary wife. He invents the lie to get a job, but gradually, he begins to withdraw into his illusions. I like the character of Rose (Una Merkel) the landlady because she is so kind and understanding. There is also a wonderful comic touch in some situations adding a cheerful atmosphere to the episode.

This first class drama is remarkably written by Lawrence B. Marcus and brilliantly directed by Robert Florey. The idea may seem odd and unusual but Boyer's inimitable performance, with the deep passion in his eyes and his resonant voice, amazingly turns the whole story into something quite touching, credible and convincing.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
At first it was an innocent lie...
planktonrules23 February 2014
"My Wife Geraldine" is a very well acted episode of "Four Star Playhouse" that stars Charles Boyer. I did enjoy the show quite a bit but I also found the ending a bit disappointing.

The show begins with Mr. Graham telling his landlady (Una Merkle) about his 'wife'. It seems he was out of work and having trouble finding a job. However, Mr. Martin (Porter Hall) is happy to give him a job but also seems interested in hiring only happily married men. So, Graham made up a wife and went to great lengths to make it look like he had one. This worked for a while, but when folks insisted on meeting her, it got crazy. Since he didn't have one, folks started thinking maybe he'd done something to her! How he works it out is for you to discover...or not.

I generally liked this show. The three main actors were all quite good. The ending, however, seemed sappy and made you wonder if Mr. Graham was just nuts! Disappointing when seen as a whole.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Boyer shines; story stinks
lor_26 November 2023
The title of this premiere episode of "Four Star Playhouse" suggested to me a skit by Flip Wilson (involving his iconic drag character Geraldine), but instead we have Charles Boyer giving a charming, heartfelt performance in support of a lousy story. Why he would choose this stinker to launch a tv series (or it be chosen by his three illustrious fellow stars/producers Ida Lupino, Dick Powell and David Niven as lead-off show) remains a mystery.

Larry Marcus's story and screenplay are strictly one-note, with any hint of suspense (or interesting content) ruined by giving away the whole matter in the first minute or two, then hitting the flashback function in pure Spoiler! Fashion. To get a job, Boyer has to pretend he is married, but the ruse of a nonexistent wife obviously (and quickly) catches up with him and gets him in trouble. Marcus' ending gives Boyer a chance to emote, but makes no sense from a storytelling standpoint, merely proving that it's just a shaggy-dog story without even the usual build-up of mystery such tales (see: the Coen Brothers and Wes Anderson, current specialists in the genre) can engender before the final letdown.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed