(TV Series)

(1953)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
Paging: Rod Serling
lor_1 April 2024
David Niven is the perfectly enigmatic star of this suspenseful one-act play on Four Star Playhouse. It's far from perfect, but still engrossing.

Premise is simple: five passengers on a subway train heading from Brooklyn to Manhattan's 14th Street Stop are alone together late night and respond to the news that a murderer is being sought -the crime taking place near where they got on.

The rather pretentious script deals with how all of them become suspicious of each other and except for Chrstine Larson, the four men all give off vibes of being the guilty party.

The verbal sparring is quite interesting, though the character played by Rhys Williams, a bum living in the subway who pontificates in the manner of monologist Brother Theodore, is a bit much. The solution of the show's mystery is quite satisfying, and a cryptic element is included at the end.

I doubt if Rod Serling was influenced by this obscure TV episode, but many of his social dramas are quite similar in theme and treatment.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
The same sort of thing has been done better...but it's not terrible
planktonrules25 January 2016
A plot involving people panicking and the darkness of human nature have been done several other times--and very well. I like these sorts of stories and "The Monsters are Due on Maple Street" ("The Twilight Zone") and "12 Angry Men" are both great examples of humanity and its dark side. "Night Ride" is a decent look at human nature....but nothing more.

When the episode begins, you see a man scramble onto a subway car-- with police apparently in pursuit. He tells the four others aboard this late night car that a maniac murderer is loose. Soon, the five all start suspecting each other and chaos erupts.

As I already said, this one isn't bad but it suffers for two reasons. First, the pacing is poor. It goes from normal to crazy way too fast. Second, if anyone was the killer, why didn't everyone think it was the guy who jumped on the car last? He did appear to be chased by cops, he knew all about the killer and acted rather guilty. Not among the best written of the "Four Star Playhouse" episodes.
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
This is the most still subway ride I've ever seen.
mark.waltz5 February 2021
Warning: Spoilers
Obviously someone recorded the sounds of the subway in the middle of the night but left off the shaking and jolts that would have made it far more realistic than it is. An express train that won't stop for twelve minutes features five people who suspect each other of being a maniacal killer, and all they can do is wait. No one can get in, and no one can get out, and having seen cops with guns chasing someone into the station (who by chance enters the car before the doors close), they aren't quite sure that he's the guilty party. "Ah civilization. What sins are committed in thy name", one of the passengers philosophizes, and that sets the tone for one of the oddest episodes of the series.

The sole woman on the train now wishes she had taken a cab, and a rather gruff man keeps spouting absurd philosophies about society that makes this become unintentionally funny. The presence of David Niven as the top billed star is questionable because he simply part of the ensemble, and gets equal amounts of dialogue as to everybody else.

Everybody overacts here, making this laughably bad, especially when the train stops in the middle of a tunnel and the lights flicker on and off, resulting in the discovery that an ax in the emergency equipment area is missing. It's obvious that the writer thought they were way too clever with all of the psychological mumbo jumbo they wrote, and the overly dramatic music doesn't help. This is fun to watch as an example of that famous "I Love Lucy" writing outcome: "Don't let this happen to you."
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed