User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
A shaggy-dog story
lor_2 December 2023
The art of the shaggy-dog story is largely lost on me, as I find such stories to be too much of a leg-pull. That's why I haven't become a fan of the current leading practitioners of this sort of storytelling, the Coen Brothers and Wes Anderson.

Here we have Ronald Colman indulging in same in his adaptation of a very old play (1914 to be exact) by the famous fantasy author Lord Dunsany, presented as an episode of Four Star Playhouse. Dressed in white tie garb, Colman is suitably droll and polished as the British gentleman who had a row with his lady friend and apparently stormed out of her flat, only to find himself on the doorstep with his silk hat left behind.

What follows is a comedy of manners, clever but so old-fashioned as to be almost unwatchable. The viewer back in 1952 would be hard-pressed to enjoy such hoary material, but adding another 70-plus years to watch it today is way too much.

The all-male cast acquit their roles quite well, but when the final line of dialogue makes the infinitesimally small point of it all, one cannot help but feel cheated -the general result of a shaggy-dog tale.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
This is a really good series...and I never thought I'd see an episode this bad!
planktonrules24 June 2016
Since "The Lost Silk Hat" was only the third episode of an otherwise fantastic series, I guess I can overlook how bad this one is...but it really, really is stupid. I can see why Ronald Colman was not asked to write further episodes of "Four Star Playhouse"!

The film begins with a fancily dressed Colman leaving some fashionable British home. However, he forgot his hat inside and cannot bring himself to go back because apparently he promised NEVER to return after having a fight with the lady who lives inside. So, he keeps approaching strangers--asking them to sneak inside and retrieve the hat. This make no sense nor do any of the characters he meets--they are just bizarro goofballs. In fact NOTHING about the show makes any sense at all...and it strains all credibility that anyone could behave like these folks. Ill-conceived and not the least bit entertaining. And a waste of a good actor...though it's his fault he was in such a turkey!
2 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
The Lost Silk Hat
Prismark102 May 2023
Co written by Ronald Colman. He plays a distinguished gentleman who has left a London house and then discovers that he has left his silk hat inside.

So he tries valiantly to get passing strangers to go inside and retrieve it. Even offering them money.

One man carrying a ladder is tempted but is then concerned that this stranger is asking him to do something dodgy.

Then the man meets a poet. He enquires just why he cannot go inside the house, maybe he committed murder. The man tells him that he had an argument with his fiance.

He stormed out of the house, vowing never to step foot inside and join the French Foreign Legion.

However while talking to the poet he ends up going inside and making sweet music.

This is a slight comical tale. It only comes alive when Richard Whorf enters the scene as the very forward and presumptuous poet.
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Rocky and Bullwinkle pulled more realism out of their hat.
mark.waltz4 February 2021
Warning: Spoilers
Four Star Playhouse credited star Ronald Colman only made four appearances on the series, and the first of the four is a very strange light-hearted episode that is more feather brained. In white tie and tails Coleman is leaving a fancy home and realizes that he has left his hat inside. Several strangers comes by and he tries to cajole them into going inside to retrieve the hat, and even has a conversation with a terrier dog. Everybody he encounters has a realistic reluctance to go inside, and you begin to wonder if he is actually his old movie character Raffles, a jewel thief. But that would be too easy an explanation, and as dashing as Colman is, this episode is not flattering to his reputation as the suave leading man who began his career in the silent era.

In fact, Colman's acting is quite hammy as if he was attempting to emulate John Barrymore doing Shakespeare. But this isn't Shakespeare. It's a TV anthology series episode set in modern times, and the situation is too bizarre and frivolous to really even be considered a plotline. Jay Novello is equally over the top as one of the men he stops, quite prissy and overly flamboyant, and giving a laughable performance for playing a simple passerby. I'm glad to have seen it though because Colman's voice is still soothing even though his character is an absolute ninny.
0 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed