"My Three Sons" Brother, Ernie (TV Episode 1965) Poster

(TV Series)

(1965)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Ernie becomes Steve's new "third" son
FlushingCaps6 November 2020
Warning: Spoilers
Caught this again on ME-TV today. This was really the second of a two-parter that allowed this series to not need to change its name when eldest son Mike got married and moved away. They had planned this for a while, having Ernie become a neighborhood friend of Chip's who lived with foster parents, making his first appearance on Halloween in 1963, two years before this episode aired in September 1965.

Viewers were aware that the actor, Barry Livingston was the real-life younger brother of Stanley Livingston, who of course, portrayed Chip on this series. Barry had, for his age, considerable acting experience, including a guest role on The Dick Van Dyke Show, and 16 episodes as a neighbor to the Nelsons on Ozzie and Harriet.

This episode focuses on the Douglas clan battling the red tape of bureaucracy as Steve is told he cannot adopt Ernie because there is no mother-figure in the house. I guess I won't spoil too much by saying that they worked it out with a "legal fiction" whereby Uncle Charley was decreed to be "the lady of the house" after a caseworker observed how he was always there, handled the cooking, cleaning, and even the sewing for the boys, and also much of the discipline. So Steve was able to adopt Ernie.

There was a subplot where Robbie is trying hard to encourage a romance between Miss Coulter, the case worker (played by Vera Miles) and his dad. Look for Jack Webb's favorite Dragnet female guest star, Virginia Gregg as the social worker helping with the adoption case.

The rest of the episode focused on the young boys trying to get their two dogs to not fight. Ernie's dog was afraid of the bigger Tramp, and took to snarling at him most of the time. As a result, within hours of the return from the court where they were told they were now "brothers" Ernie and Chip were quarreling. Realistically quarreling. There were no hyper-dramatic "I wish you weren't my brother" type lines. They were just arguing about whose dog was at fault. Of course, those difficulties were put to rest when they returned from a supper out and found the two dogs sleeping side-by-side.

This was only the third episode in color, and the third to air on CBS after the move from ABC. Even though the series stayed on the air for another 7 seasons, Mike and Sally, Steve's oldest son and his new wife never came back for a visit and were virtually never mentioned again. I think there should have been at least one Christmas special with the eldest son and wife-and kids(?) coming for a visit.

As with many episodes in this series, the funniest lines came from Uncle Charley-here when he was loudly complaining to the boys about various ways they were making his life complicated, not knowing Steve and the social workers were meeting in the next room. I guess because showing the adoption seems to huge in this series, I feel happy to give it an 8-it had a really serious, positive event taking place and a fair number of laughs.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
ALL EYES ON ERNIE, THE COMEBACK KID.
tcchelsey21 October 2023
We all wanted a step brother like Ernie, because he was such a cool kid. This episode continues the adoption saga, and whether he will FINALLY be a part of the Douglas family.

You know its coming, right?

But there's still a lot of red tape, and negotations thereof between case worker Vera Miles and Steve. I actually thought she would stick around the series as Steve's love interest, but it didn't go that way, and that's a shame because Vera Miles and Fred MacMurray complimented each other. This again brings up the fact the writers were toying with the idea of eventually getting Steve a steady gal pal, or a wife. MY THREE SONS, you have to admit, was also a mini soap opera at times.

Best scene is the hearing before a judge, who also asks Uncle Charlie some questions, since there is no real lady of the house. Charlie mentions bedtime stories --such as MOBY DICK?

"He's a whale!" he tells the judge, who does the proverbial double take times two.

Steve officially signs on the dotted line... and Ernie joins the gang! This was perhaps one of the fondest family episodes, next to Robbie and Katie's eventual marriage. Also Uncle Charlie isn't scowling and complaining as much, who really takes a liking to Ernie.

Stanley Livingston was the real-life brother of Barry Livingston (Chip), but they really didn't look much alike! That was always the stumbling block. Stanley, who would appear in over 200 episodes of the series, was somewhat of a tv veteran by the time he joined MY THREE SONS. Prior to this series, he was also on the OZZIE AND HARRIET SHOW and made two appearances on Lucille Ball's tv show. Let's face it. If you're on any show with Lucy, you're going places.

A fun episode with some very good acting. SEASON 6, EPISODE 3, remastered dvd box set.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed