"Perry Mason" The Case of the Baited Hook (TV Episode 1957) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
14 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Watch that closet
mdrr-371872 May 2017
Saw "The Baited Hook" yesterday on MeTV for the first time in almost sixty years. I remember it well. I was just six then, watching this episode of PM with my parents & was caught off guard. When Perry opened the closet door and that body fell out it scared the bejesus out of me. I was haunted for weeks. For a while every episode after that I semi-covered my eyes when they would come to the scene where a dead body was about to be discovered. lol. Very tame today. I'm retired now and love watching these old classic episodes twice a day. They hold up very well. Usually had good scripts, very good acting & love the interplay between Perry and Lt Tragg & Hamilton Burger. Raymond Burr was great. He was born to play Perry Mason.
33 out of 34 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Good story- Good acting = Good show
kfo94941 December 2011
In this episode Perry gets his client released from murder charges without going into the courtroom. Plus is unique since we also get to see inside Perry's apartment.

The story is somewhat simple, a young girl named Carol Stanley (Judith Braun) has a trust fund that is being controlled by the investment company of Tidings & Dawson. It seems that Albert Tydings (George Neise) is using the fund as his personal checking account.

When Mr Dawson (Willard Sage) finds out about this he calls the police. But before the police get on the phone Mr Tidings produces a folder that makes Dawson stop the call.

Carol is living with larger-than-life Abigail E. Leeds (Geraldine Wall) that lets everyone she will not be pushed around. She believes that Tydings is stealing from the trust fund and wants Perry to look into the matter. (Ms Leeds says she took Carol to America from Europe to wait for her parents but the parent never showed up and she put Carol in a foster home- but now the foster parents died and she all that Carol has.)

Before Perry can look into the matter, Mr Tydings is found dead. And it just so happened that Carol had an late appointment with Tydings and found the body. This sets off a series of strange events which instead of helping Carol looks like she was covering up the murder.

Lt Tragg puts a tail on Perry which leads right to where Carol was hiding. And now Perry says he will defend her for the murder.

Before the case goes to court, we have some interesting facts about Carol's birth. Those facts will lead to the true murderer and also leads us to a sad ending to a good show.

This episode is supported by strong acting abilities of the guest-stars. Ms Wall performance makes the entire episode a treat for all the viewers. The rest of the cast also seemed will casted for the parts played.

Good story with lots going on-
33 out of 34 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Unnamed Identities
Hitchcoc18 November 2021
Most of what I would say has already been written. The interesting thing here is that Perry never faces Burger in court. Ray Collins is always around and takes a shine to one of the chief participants. Perry and Paul do all the investigating (along with Della who never gets much credit). Perry puts all the two plus twos together and Paul finds documents to solve the case.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Do I Have a Choice?
darbski1 May 2017
Warning: Spoilers
There will be **SPOILERS** One thing I like is the sometimes banter between Tragg and Mason. In this case, Tragg says to Perry " can I give you some advice"? to which Perry replies "Do I have a choice"? I thought it funny. The story is good, with good characters (who have the usual propensity for foolishness and trying to mislead Perry), a couple of red herrings, and a telephone call that actually shows how life can sometimes be frustrating. There were two one-thousand dollar bills handed to Perry and a ten-thousand dollar bill that was torn in half as a promise for a retainer. These were rare bills, and the ten-thousand was really rare. Typically issued to very large businesses or corporations for serious exchanges of money. Perry remarks that he's never seen one, and tearing one in half is actually defacing U.S. currency and is a felony. I had a little problem with Perry noticing blood, which normally dries to a brick-brown color, on a brick-brown brick, but the scene in which the corpse falls face first out of the closet is absolutely hilarious;I tell you, the "deadpan" look on his face was priceless. I mean, hewas a pompous, thieving ass in life, but he made a great dead guy. Another problem is that when Perry and Della were snooping around Tydings' office, they left fingerprints all over the place, and there was NO BLOOD on the desk or carpet. Curious. Perry's car is a beautiful, 1957 Cadillac Eldorado convertible that he's had in a couple of episodes. It befits his stature in the community. And in the end of the episode, Dells is babying Perry through a bad cold. Again, the conversational banter is played with a familiarity reserved for very good friends, and played perfectly by Ray and Barb. I know what you're thinking, and you're right. I consider these characters and the actors friends. I watched this series when I was a kid with my parents, Now I'm buying the collection from Amazon. Even though I watch it on METV, I still use this as a perfect reference, and sometimes, just because I love the series. I recommend it to all who enjoy great acting, and dialogue ...d
13 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Honor Your Father and Your Mother
live-and-let-live10 February 2022
...Second time watching it. The first time I must've been overly distracted and missed the nuances that sets this episode apart. I've watched all of them available on IMDB, and now on my second time through, this jumped out at me. It is unlike any of the other typically formulated stories.

It left me with a lump in my throat and a tear in my eye.

Lt. Tragg is a real gentleman with the accused.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Sass Appeal
therealjohnhood13 May 2022
Warning: Spoilers
SPOILER ALERT Here's a Perry where the killer is as lovable as she is winning! She's also the star of this show! (One of six guest star roles.) Well played Geraldine Wall, very well played. And just as very well directed Christian Nyby!
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Lots of Tragg / Mason banter
ebertip17 October 2020
On seeing the nature of the Abigail Leeds character, I thought how well Minerva Urecal would have played it. Minerva shows up in the next episode of Mason (1/15). Here, all the investment people are bad guys. One (Tydings) ends up dead. One client, with ties to Abigail, is cheated out of thousands and becomes the defendant. Perry is doing some sketchy things, including escaping on a fire escape. Tragg notes to Perry "I'd hate to lose my favorite sparring partner." Tragg, suspecting Perry has Abigail in Perry's office, does the "oops wrong door" thing, but gets chewed up by Abigail. The non-courtroom resolution has Perry saying "all murders are senseless." In the final minutes, Perry and Della are by the fire at Perry's place and Della says "Anytime you want me to put the heat on Lt Tragg let me know." In this episode, Tragg benefits by tailing Perry. In the next episode, Perry takes advantage of knowing Tragg is tailing him. In the next episode, Perry gets his client acquitted in a jury trial without identifying the murderer in court, a model not usually followed. Many of the early episodes present some legal ethics issues. Perry looks bad here, but Hamilton looks really bad in the next episode. One minor point. This episode involves a $10000 bill (Salmon Chase on obverse). These were more or less out of circulation in 1957. But not impossible. The $10000 gold certificate was not used in publuc circulation but the reserve note was.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A Perry Mason with no chasin'...
AlsExGal27 November 2022
... as in no courtroom battle. William Tallman as D. A. Hamilton Burger doesn't even appear. Maybe he finally got tired of losing to Perry each and every week and decided to open that hunting supply store he'd always dreamed of, or perhaps he hit the open road. But I digress.

Albert Tydings is an investment banker who is cheating client Abigal Leeds. Tydings' partner and Leeds' boyfriend, Robert Dawson, confronts him about the theft. Tydings pulls out a file he has and says if Dawson calls the police he will make the file contents public. Dawson backs down.

When Abigail goes to Tydings' office one night for an appointment she finds him dead. Perry, unaware of any of this, gets two visits. The first is at his home with a mysterious man and woman giving him a retainer for a case that has not happened yet. The other is an appointment with a rather loud forward middle-aged woman who wants Perry to go after Tydings for his embezzlement of Abigail's funds. Abigail is her ward.

Oh, and Tydings' body is ultimately found in his home, not his office. What goes on here? You and Perry Mason will have to find out together.

There is lots of field work here with Perry Mason and Della Street doing almost as much sleuthing as P. I. Paul Drake. But ultimately the case - and even what the case consists of - are revealed and solved in Perry's office, not a courtroom.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
The Case of the Baited Hook
Prismark108 October 2021
Albert Tydings is a financial investor who is embezzling his own clients. Even the company clerk Richard Ellis is helping himself.

Tydings business partner in the firm Robert Dawson tries to stop him but Tydings has something on him.

Carol Stanley plans to see Tydings as she is a disgruntled investor who thinks her money has been siphoned off. She finds him dead and Perry Mason gets an unusual retainer.

This is a case where Perry and Paul Drake do a lot of investigating. Some of it seems to involve a lot of breaking and entering.

Unusually there are no courtroom scenes as Perry has a good idea as to who the murderer might be.

There is a character who rides in like a whirlwind. Abigail Leeds who looks after Carol Stanley. She even manages to leave Tragg lost for words.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Continuity quirk in this episode
thaneb6 September 2023
Della convinces a night janitor to let her into the Tydings/Dawson office so that she can let Perry in and they can both investigate. She tells the janitor she's forgotten her key and is going to do a bit of late work. (She even does a sheet of typing in the office tp be convincing, cute) We see Della and the janitor in the hallway. In the hallway the janitor is not wearing glasses. The viewpoint of the scene then changes to looking through the door from the inside, Della enters and through the door the janitor can be seen, stlil outside in the hall. From that viewpoint he is not wearing glasses.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
By the time you get out of prison the only thing you'll be collecting is an old age pension!l
sol12187 March 2013
Warning: Spoilers
***SPOILERS*** Perry Mason, Raymond Burr, gets a $2,000.00 retainer as well as half of a $10,000.00 bill the other half to be received when he takes on the case. Perry not only doesn't get any of the money but ends up getting a case of the flu instead by solving the murder case that his client Carol Stanley, Judith Braun,is accused of before it even goes to trail. It's Carol's friend Robert Dawson, William Sage, who want's him to handle Carol's case. She's soon to be indited for the killing Dawson's business partner Albert Tydings, George N. Neise, whom she found shot to death at his office. This all spelled bad tidings for Carol in that she and Robert Dawson tried to hide that fact from the police.

The reason why Carol would have murdered Tydings is that he's handling her estate and has siphoned off some $60,000.00 out of it for his own personal,playing the stock market, use. But as we and Perry later learn is that there's a lot more to what Tydings did than just embezzling Carol estate. He's got a number of explosive document about Carol and her past that is far far worse. And it's Carol's adopted mother the battle ax like Abigale Leeds, Geraldine Wall, who want's to make sure that they never see the light of day. We also have another party to all this and that's the special clerk at the Tydings/Dawson firm Richard Ellis, Al Hopson. He's in fact been embezzling Carol's estate together with Tydings without Tydings knowing about it.

***SPOILERS*** We also get this sob story from Abigale Leeds about how a three year old Carol was secretly shipped out of Poland in 1939. 18 years ago, just before the Nazis invaded it with her parents later dying in a Nazi concentration camp. It was Abigale who in fact somehow took Carol under her wing and found a good home for Carol in the USA. With Carol's adopted American parents killed in an auto accident it's now Abigale job to look after her interests. It was Tyding who's handling Carols estate who not only stole 60 G's out of it but was together with special clerk Ellis blackmailed her as well as Abigale to keep secret what her true identity and background really is. which in fact ended up with Tydings murdered and Ellis facing as much as 20 years behind bars.

P.S One of the most mind bugging and strangest scenes in all the "Perry Mason" TV episodes happened when Perry and private investigator Paul Drake, William Hooper, checked out Tydings house seeing if he's there or not. As they open a closet in his home a zombie like Tyding suddenly pops out, like a jack in the Box, and hits the floor stone cold dead! What was so unusual about that scene is that both Perry and Paul Drake acted as if nothing unusual happened and didn't as much as blink. They just stepped over Tydings dead body not even bothering to check if he's dead or not as the two casually walked right out of his house as if nothing happened at all!
12 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Perry is a little short with our Della
cinamac38 April 2024
I thoroughly enjoyed this episode as we get to see Perry, in his well appointed apartment, looking dapper, suave and sophisticated in silk pajamas and robe. However, I must admit that I was somewhat taken aback and disappointed by his uncharacteristic treatment of the quintessential confidential secretary, Della Street. We go from sleepy Della, nestling her sweet head on Perry's massive shoulder and him referring to her as "Good girl"(after she uses her womanly wiles to gain access to the offices of an Investment firm, after hours), to the sharply uttered "Relax Della" and "Hold your horses", just because Della is a little nervous...she is always looking out for Perry and worries about his tendency to sometimes skirt the law! We witness this churlish behavior, again, when they search the home of the Defendant. The show ends with Della tending to a sick Perry, who, although suffering from a severe head cold, is still devastatingly handsome! I guess I'll just chalk up Perry's dark mood to the fact that he wasn't feeling well!
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Without a day in court
bkoganbing6 June 2012
Warning: Spoilers
Some interesting things happen in this Perry Mason episode. He does all his work including some of his own sleuthing with Paul Drake to find the real murderer. He also gets a retainer in a most unusual and melodramatic matter.

You would think that if somebody, just about anyone else called him at home and said I'm coming down with a retainer after waking Raymond Burr out of a sound sleep they'd have been told in no uncertain terms that I've got an office where I do business, make an appointment. But things like this intrigue Perry.

In melodramatic fashion Perry opens the door and greets a mysterious man who hands him two one thousand dollar bills for a retainer accompanied by a veiled woman in black who is the client to be. He also gives Burr a torn half of a ten thousand dollar bill and the other half comes when the woman actually is arrested. With just that half a big bill to start with Burr, Barbara Hale, and William Hopper figure out a lot of the case. And yes a man who was the executor of her trust fund was bilking the veiled woman of a lot of money.

And the Perry Mason paradigm is really stretched when the real murderer is discovered, Burr offers to defend the person in court. That episode we never did see, but it would have been nice to see him go before a jury for once.
9 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Lt. Tragg Meets His Match
pattersonros21 March 2013
Warning: Spoilers
I think the episodes from the first four seasons are the best, including this one.

Albert Tydings is a slimy character (I guess most murder victims in this series are) and there are plenty of people who had motives for killing him: the blackmailer, whom Tydings himself was blackmailing; the client, whom he has fleeced/embezzled $60K; the client's fiancée', who can't expose Tydings for fear that the client's circumstances surrounding her birth would be made public, and the jealous secretary, whom Tydings boldly tells he has a date with a "nice girl" later on.

My title refers to A.E. Leeds, who is acerbic through most of the episode and even manages to leave the usually gruff, Lt. Tragg at a loss for words. When Mrs. Leeds and Lt. Tragg "stroll" arm-in-arm out of Mason's office, the viewers are left with a feeling that everything will turn out okay for everyone.
9 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed