(TV Series)

(1981)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Decent but not your typical "Quincy"
planktonrules14 May 2013
It's ironic I saw this episode of "Quincy" only a week or so after I saw an old "Mannix" episode with a similar theme. Both involve the Catholic church bringing in both as experts to try to prove or disprove the existence of a so-called miracle. In the case of Mannix, it really didn't make a lot of sense bringing him in but at least Quincy's expertise as a coroner could have been useful in this task! As I mentioned above, Quincy (along with Sam) is brought in as part of a team to a Mexican village to determine the validity of claims that some remains found belong to a beloved saint. From Quincy's point of view, this is something that must accomplished ASAP, as some people are neglecting to get legitimate medical treatment in hopes of a miracle. Also, with all these folks converging on this tiny town, a public health crisis is looming. Naturally, the other team members understand his concerns but don't want to rush the process as they want to do it right. In the midst of this chore, Quincy takes time out to be angry--and the object of this anger is on irresponsible newspaper reporters making outrageous claims to sell papers.

While I would prefer the older style episodes where Quincy investigates murders and other crimes, this one is a decent departure. Well written and enjoyable my only complaint is the addition to the cliché of the cute, sick kid--this has been done too many times in the past and I hate to see a child being reduced to just a plot device.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Complete nonsense and foolishness
rayoflite2414 November 2015
By Their Faith begins with Quincy (Jack Klugman) and Sam (Robert Ito) being called in to Dr. Asten's (John S. Ragin) office where an Archbishop (Rene Enriquez) of the Catholic Church asks for their assistance in determining if the remains of a body found in a Mexican town were those of a saint. Quincy and Sam make the trip to the primitive area and join a team of archaeologists and pathologists from around the country who are analyzing the remains. The possibility of this being a sacred burial ground has attracted large groups of people seeking miracle cures for their ailments, and the young woman, Jacinta Gonsales (Eugenia Wright), who discovered the remains believes she has been given healing powers to help them. Quincy becomes very concerned over the dire situation of these people not seeking out traditional medical treatment in hopes of divine intervention and implores his colleagues to wrap up the investigation as quickly as possible.

Let me start out by saying that there is no shortage of stupidity in this episode which made me thoroughly dislike it. First off, we have a church leader in Mexico traveling all the way to LA to ask in person that two of the best people in the coroner lab go down there for an unspecified amount of time to participate in an archaeological investigation where there is already several qualified professionals working on it. At any other time, Dr. Asten would be freaking out at the prospect of this bemoaning how the busy LA coroner lab would not be able to function without Quincy and Sam for an extended period of time, but not here as he cheerfully sends them on their way. I found this to be so out of character and ridiculous, especially after we've seen Asten flip out in so many prior episodes when Quincy goes AWOL for a few hours.

Then we have some well-intentioned but naive girl thinking that she has been granted divine powers in healing people because she found some remains which have not even been confirmed yet as those of a saint. This along with throngs of critically ill people foregoing medical treatment and flocking to this site to be cured by her just put this plot in the territory of absurd for me. The parents of the young boy should have been brought up on charges of child neglect for bringing him to that site instead of taking him to a hospital for treatment of his leukemia. I also found the character of the sensationalistic reporter to be extremely poorly written as he does a complete 180 from an unethical hack to a benevolent, altruistic humanitarian in less that 30 minutes of air time. Complete nonsense all around!

This is among the worst episodes of the series that I've seen from a credibility standpoint and I do not recommend it unless you are a tried and true Quincy fan that wants to see it all.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
"I thought you were a blood sucking leech but was I wrong, your a lot lower than that." Religious themed Quincy episode.
poolandrews12 July 2008
Warning: Spoilers
Quincy M.E.: By Their Faith starts as Asten (John S. Ragin) sends medical examiner Quincy (Jack Klugman) & laboratory assistant Sam Fujiama (Robert Ito) to San Remos in Mexico by request of Archbishop Vallejo (René Enríquez) in order to help authenticate one way or the other ancient remains that have been found there. A local village girl named Jacinta Gonsales (Eugenia Wright) found some bones in a cave which she believes belonged to famous 16th century Spanish missionary Fei Deigo, Jacinta claims that she now has the power to miraculously cure disease, sickness & ailments. With religious people flocking to her from all corners of the globe seeking a 'miracle cure' Quincy fears that with no proper medical attention at the site many will die or even worse spread deadly disease throughout the region...

Episode 7 from season 6 this Quincy story was directed by Ron Satlof & this is maybe the only religious themed episode of Quincy that was made. For obvious reasons absolute hard scientific fact of the sort a scientist like Quincy would deal in & superstitious religion which comes down to belief which you can't see under a microscope or bottle in a test tube contradict each other & are at opposite ends of the story telling scale which is probably why the production team kept the two separate for the majority of the show & even here in By Their Faith the focus of the story is more on the disease those looking to be miraculously cured bring with them & the race against time to get them proper medical help. By Their Faith nails it's colours to it's mast, miracle cures do not work although those who offer them sincerely believe that they have the power to heal & that media hysteria is to blame. Like a good few episodes from season five By Their Faith takes place entirely outside the traditional Los Angeles laboratory setting apart from Asten's office at the very start, here it's a small Mexican village which is actually never seen & resembles a dusty field as much as anything else. There's no murder here, there's no mystery & while it's nice to get varied story lines By Their Faith isn't one of my favourite episodes as there's not much here to really get excited about & the traditional Quincy elements that make the show so enjoyable for me are largely absent here.

This episode also touches upon the effect of irresponsible journalism & not reporting the facts. The start of the episode sees Quincy get covered in mud in a comedy moment while there are a few continuity issues regarding Quincy's sweat patterns on his shirt, they disappear & change size all the time between shots. Even this is meant to be set in a Mexican village the budget didn't stretch to build one so we get a dusty clearing in a wood, I wouldn't even go as far as to call it a field! The acting is alright if unremarkable.

By Their Faith is an alright episode of Quincy, it's not one of the best from the series but it's not one of the worst either. I am always disappointed not to see a murder or a mystery so this was never going to be one of my favourites.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed