"Relic Hunter" Under the Ice (TV Episode 2002) Poster

(TV Series)

(2002)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Keep it on ice
unbrokenmetal14 December 2014
A helicopter takes Nigel and Sydney to a station near the Arctic Circle. A frozen body was found, a man who died centuries ago, and they are to investigate who he was. „Makes the Scottish coastline feel Mediterranean by comparison", Nigel complains when they arrive at 50 degrees below zero, but what really makes their blood freeze is that the station was demolished by something or someone, and nobody is left to welcome them. Something terrible must have happened...

For broadcast in Germany, the episode 'Under the Ice' was retitled into 'The Mummy', so I was prepared for a boring episode about an Egyptian mummy that rises from the dead to do the same old routine, you know: walk around in the middle of the night and scare people. Fortunately, 'Under the Ice' turned out to have a fresh – no pun intended – idea, leading to a story that could have filled 90 minutes of a movie as well. Maybe it's reminding the audience a bit of „The Thing", but for afternoon TV, of course it contains no serious violence. Instead of temples and jungles, 'Under the Ice' shows a different surrounding, that is some good variety in the middle of the season.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Couldn't get into this one
xbatgirl-300292 May 2023
Warning: Spoilers
This is my least favorite episodes of the season so far. It's so insanely, completely derivative, both the story and the characters. It's probably been done a hundred times. X Files, Stargate, The Librarians. Even shows like Firefly if you make the Arctic Station into a stranded spaceship. Or how about a research outpost that people lost touch with, as on Star Trek or again Serenity.

All the actors did what they could with the script though perhaps nothing outstanding, and that includes the leads. Michael Anthony Rawlins easily made the strongest showing and at least gave his character some personality. The others are forgettable. Though I really mostly blame the director, and script, because I've seen all but the guy playing Harley in other shows and I know they're much better than this. Frankly, I was shocked to later find out that this bore fest was written by Damian Kindler. Although, he was involved in some of the exact shows I was thinking of where they also did versions of this plot. So it makes sense.

The set and lighting pretty much looks exactly like the sets used on all those other shows. The most ridiculous moment was when Sydney goes out in -50° weather wearing pretty much the same outfit she wears on their college campus and she just gets a little chilly. The show lost me completely after that. Again, it's totally derivative for the hero to get stuck out in the cold/in space during this trope, yet the way this was done was way worse than usual.

Even the usual mystery surrounding an ancient artifact that needs decoding or protecting was absent. Instead, most of the show was people walking around alone in dark hallways, saying "what was that noise?" or "how are we ever going to be saved without a radio?" They even fell into the cliché of killing off the Black character early on.

Often, when a show does a super clichéd story like this, there might be a little clever moment or two thrown in, maybe some character revelations and bonding, perhaps there's a season long story arc that moves forward a bit, something that makes it all acceptable entertainment in the end. You don't get any of that here. Then ending itself is quite underwhelming. Very much a phoned in filler episode.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed