"The Sweeney" Thou Shalt Not Kill! (TV Episode 1975) Poster

(TV Series)

(1975)

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
A Rather Simplified Episode With A Political Subtext
Theo Robertson29 August 2010
Ranald Graham is something of an auteur when it come to writing for THE SWEENEY . His episodes aren't usually ones that are simplistic tales of the Flying Squad catching slags doing a blag - they're often of political importance . Supersnout sees some West German detectives find out how their opposite numbers in Britain operate , though it's slightly let down by failed attempts at humour . Nightmare is one of the most violent pieces of television ever made in Britain featuring a drugs cache and the IRA . Graham also scripted THE SWEENEY film from 1977 and that was more akin to a political thriller with the characters from the shoe clumsily shoe horned in . Perhaps these aren't criticisms but it's noticeable how different some of the writing style is from episodes by other writers . One can' help thinking Graham would have been more at home in Hollywood writing thrillers

This episode Thou Shalt Not Kill is easily seen as being inspired by The 1972 Olympic Massacre in Munich . A bank is raided and the armed robbers realising they're trapped take some hostages and it's left up to DCI Frank Haskins to try and resolve the situation . There is a slight problem with the episode and that is that things are painted a bit too simplistic . The episode ends with Jack Regan whining that if Haskins had only listened to hi advice the outcome would have been very different . But would it have ? We all know that hindsight is the best sight of all and perhaps the episode doesn't focus enough on dilemma Hskins faces

It's also interesting how cold cruel and callous the robbers Wands and Morris are . They're not the old style mythical " we don't hurt women and kids guv " type of criminal - they're portrayed as out and out psychos very much in keeping with the character of the show , but it's revealed they've been treated rather leniently b the authorities in the past and this compassion from the state as had no effect upon them . It makes for an interesting political subtext and one that might be deemed as unacceptable for television nowadays though the problem I had has nothing to do with the politics , rather in the simplistic way they're presented . It could have been the best episode ever from the show but it isn't despite it being very good
5 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Where is Monk
paulccarroll-6593715 January 2023
Warning: Spoilers
Its interesting how different hostage standoffs are now from back in the 1970s. No SWAT team in riot gear, just a bunch of cops in suits and ties with snub nose revolvers, which would have had very short range of fire. A pretty interesting episode, but what happened to Monk. Hes last seen cradling his partner in crime, and crying that He was killed. Then we dont see Him captured, or getting away, or taking His own life. Hes just gone, as Regan arrives with His gun out. Was part of this episode edited for some technical or political reason. I read that this episode had been delayed in being broadcast because of a bank robbery that happened just before it originally was scheduled to be shown. It left a fairly big plot hole just as credits rolled. Just wondering.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Thou Shalt Not Kill
Prismark1014 December 2020
This is a very taut and muscular episode featuring a pair of nasty sociopathic villains.

Flying Squad has a tip off about a bank robbery. They arrive just as the raid takes place. Some of the robbers get out.

Two stay behind. Wands and Monks and they have two females and the bank manager has hostages.

Surrounded by the police. Haskins has two marksmen on the robbers but he deems it too risky to order them to shoot.

The robbers are ruthless and cold blooded. Wands is calculating and clever. He even takes time to charm a pretty female lecturer who is one of the hostages.

Director Douglas Camfield shoots some good action scenes when the police arrive to take on the robbers.

Writer Ranald Graham catches a sense of the an escalating violence in society. Wands makes it clear to the bank manager that he is not going to get out of this alive.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
One of the best Sweeney episodes
edvanmeyer4 May 2016
Warning: Spoilers
It is fair to say that the Sweeney redefined the Police drama genre in the UK in the early 1970's.

The episode 'Thou shalt not kill' is pure Steak through and through. Taut writing, quality acting and gritty drama are packed into each part of this episode which is broken into 4 sectors to allow for commercial breaks.

Each part packs more quality drama and action than most full length episodes of even modern Police dramas. Having been in front line policing, I can say it has elements of realism that are believable and this elite squad faces some very nasty characters.

The dithering of the Chief Inspector Haskins character has obvious consequences in this episode,John Thaw's Jack Regan character rips into his superior (Haskins) for this apparent judgment call that ultimately could have affected the outcome had Haskins not bottled it.

The suspense is carried right to the end and this is a very well written episode. The Sweeney was probably the best Police action drama of the 70's if not of all time. Few Police drama series come anywhere near matching the quality of drama, writing and action.
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Really nice
Leofwine_draca24 March 2021
Warning: Spoilers
A really nice episode to close the series. This one's an extended set-piece in which Regan and chums have to go up against a couple of hostage-takers, one of whom is played by the great Ronald Lacey. It all ends in a car chase and violence so is as exciting as they come.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed