"The Virginian" Experiment at New Life (TV Episode 1970) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
New Life
bkoganbing19 May 2018
This episode of The Virginian has James Drury wandering far afield looking for missing Shiloh cattle. He comes across his strays and far too many to have just wandered off in the cattle pen of a commune type settlement.

In the 19th century there were experiments in this kind of living where private property was limited if not abolished. Heading the group informally is widow Vera Miles, widow of the founder.

Strong man in the commune however is Ralph Meeker who is in charge of the cattle. He's a man who's seen this as a place to exploit to his advantage. He proposes common marriage and he wants Miles for himself and her daughter Sue Lyon to his bottom feeding sidekicks.

Lyon however loves an outsider Michael McGreevey who is the son of a farmer Lyle Bettger who is for once playing a normal person, not a psychotic villain.

James Drury proves to be their salvation and in addition to getting his cattle back uncovers a lot of nasty secrets.

Miles gets acting honors in this as a principled woman who is frightened by what she sees as a perversion of her late husband's teachings. With barely any dialog she and Lyons do wonders with facial expressions conveying the terror of facing off Meeker and his accomplices.

Fans of all the cast members will approve.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Communal Chaos Warning: Spoilers
When Shiloh cattle stray into the herd of a commune called New Life the Virginian approaches the council to organize the removal of the cattle.

The New Life council approves the moving of the cattle but after the Virginian leaves there is another vote to bring in a law that leaves a bad taste in the mind of the wife of the founding father of New Life.

With her daughter Belinda's happiness at stake, along with the honour and memory of her husband's wishes, Amelia Ballard is forced to reconsider her future and that of her daughter in the light of unsavoury developments and seek assistance from the Virginian.

However their plan to escape the situation is met with resistance that is as dangerous as the men who seem to have taken over the commune.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
It'll Never Work
CaptWinkie4 September 2023
Starts out a great story, then everything pivots on an escape attempt. The Virginian is caught in a crossfire, the bad guy takes careful aim, shoots and the Virginian goes down-oh no- he's out cold and presumed dead. Miraculously, he wakes up without a scratch but everything he had with him during the escape is robbed from him, including his horse--but not his gun. He walks back to a known house for help (Lyle Bettger, way underused but good to see) -thankfully some coffee is all it takes to revive him before he's on the way back to collect what was taken. The Virginian uses a distraction, retakes all he wants, bad guys discover the ruse and one of them admits they should have killed him when they had the chance--alluding to the crossfire and the expectation that the Virginian would awaken and go home. Oh brother.

Other than that, it's a good story with action, a great supporting cast and outstanding guest stars.

Vera Miles is one of the loveliest women in the business- a quiet yet timeless beauty- she's still alive at the time of this writing, more than fifty years after filming.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed