"Wagon Train" The Colter Craven Story (TV Episode 1960) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Ward Bond Hosts His Friends
bkoganbing1 August 2006
The week that Ward Bond died TV Guide was to feature an article about this Wagon Train episode. Bond got his mentor John Ford to direct this episode of Wagon Train which concerned an alcoholic doctor played by Carleton Young traveling on the Wagon Train.

This must have been a proud day for Bond. John Wayne, John Ford, and Ward Bond had been like the three musketeers ever since Ford spotted both these guys working as prop men and gave them their start in films.

For Bond however he was the odd man out. Either he and Wayne worked on a Ford film together or they worked on a film with another director, but with Wayne the star and Bond one of the supporting cast.

But due to Wagon Train, Bond was now THE STAR and Wayne and Ford worked for him. Wayne has an unbilled unseen cameo as General William T. Sherman during a flashback sequence during the Civil War. I still remember you see Wayne in silhouette in the background, but his voice is unmistakable.

Wayne is billed under his real name of Marion Michael Morrison in the cast and the cast of the episode itself reads like a John Ford movie.

It would have been one of the best received Wagon Train episodes in any event, but Bond's death made it a classic.

I wish I had saved that TV Guide with the rollicking story about Ford and Wayne working for Bond on the Wagon Train set and the heartfelt obituary for Bond in the same issue. In the obituary it was explained that they wanted to run the cover story as well as the obituary side by side, such was the place that Ward Bond as Major Seth Adams had in the affections of the American public.
50 out of 53 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A tormented doctor joins the wagon train
padutchland-122 April 2010
Ward Bond as Wagon Train master Seth Adams finds a wagon on the prairie, with a broken wheel and axle. He accepts the two occupants into the wagon train, an alcoholic doctor and his wife. The doctor (Carleton Young) is tormented by memories of his inability to save lives during the slaughter of the Civil War. Consequently, he finds himself unable to perform surgeon duties and turns to the bottle. His long suffering wife (Anna Lee) stays by his side hoping for him to come back to his former self. During the trip, the doctor does a wonderful job setting the broken leg of a little boy on the wagon train. Crossing desert conditions, the wagon train stops by an outpost to get water. It is run by John Carradine and his two sons, one being Ken Curtis (acting curiously like his later part in Gunsmoke). Carradine in his wonderfully characteristic bad guy ability, wants the wagon train to pay very high amounts for barrels of water, but Ward Bond refuses and they make for the distant river without it. Carradine and sons hope to see them discard heavy items they can pick up to make them richer. The test comes for the doctor when a pregnant woman needs a cesarean operation. He is the only one that can do it but his hands just won't work due to his preoccupation with his Civil War failures. This is where it gets interesting as Seth Adams tells him the story of U.S. Grant (Paul Birch) and his drinking during the war and how he pulled himself together. There is a long flashback scene where many of the John Ford company appear. In fact, this episode was directed by John Ford. John Wayne appears in darkened background as General Sherman but you could tell it was him with that walk and voice. His name credit was Michael Morris a form of his real name. Also seen were Hank Worden (old Mose in The Searchers) and Jack Pennick (Sgt. Major in She Wore A Yellow Ribbon), and Willis Bouchey (Col Secord in The Horse Soldiers). That's the general idea, but I won't spoil the ending. Let's just say it was a wonderfully done episode of Wagon Train with many familiar faces.
20 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
John Ford at the helm, Johns Wayne and Carradine also present
kevinolzak27 January 2019
Warning: Spoilers
John Carradine had appeared in a first season episode of Ward Bond's WAGON TRAIN "The Dora Gray Story," and on Nov 23 1960 made a second in "The Colter Craven Story," one of the show's highlights due to its director being Oscar-winner John Ford, his 1950 "Wagon Master" inspiring the series (delivering 72 minutes of film in six shooting days, 15 of which was not used), and a special guest cameo from none other than John Wayne himself, billed as 'Michael Morris' in the role of General William Tecumseh Sherman, whom he would play again two years later in "How the West Was Won." Popular series star Ward Bond, surrounded by old friends at his career peak, sadly passed away prior to its broadcast, though the show itself survived for another four years with John McIntire his replacement. The part of Colter Craven was played by Ford regular Carleton Young, whose most famous role involved uttering the eternal line from "The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance": 'when the legend becomes fact, print the legend.' Craven is unfortunately more in tune with the bottle than with his patients, which is perfectly fine with Frank McGrath's Charlie Wooster, but on one occasion shows off his bedside manner by setting the broken leg of a young boy. A more serious matter rears up when an imminent birth puts the lives of both mother and child in danger, Craven unwilling to trust his unsteady hands with a surgeon's knife. At this point, Ward Bond's Major Seth Adams reminisces about his wartime experience alongside Ulysses Simpson Grant (Paul Birch), who overcame his own alcoholic tendencies to win the war between the states. We only see John Wayne's General Sherman in silhouette, identified by his unmistakable voice, as Grant promotes Adams to Major on the spot (Ford later claimed he was surprised by Wayne's presence on the set). John Carradine appears in one early scene, as wealthy landowner Park Cleatus, greedily daring to charge the parched wagon train $25 a barrel to use his well, so Adams has to settle for each animal being watered for 20 cents a head. Other Ford regulars include Ken Curtis ("The Last Hurrah," "The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance") as Carradine's son, Willis Bouchey as Grant's father, and Jack Pennick strutting his stuff in uniform for General Grant. John himself remained absent for the rest of WAGON TRAIN's run, though son David made one of his first TV appearances in 1963's "The Eli Bancroft Story."
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The John Ford Stock Company
hogwrassler30 August 2021
This is the favorite episode of many Wagon Train fans. I have seen it several times and am watching it right now MeTV. John Ford directed this one and The Duke himself, John Wayne, appears at the end in darkened silhouette, as General Sherman. He is billed as Michael Morris. Robert Horton isn't in it at all, except for being mentioned. Gill,Hawks handles the scouting duties. Major Adams doesn't wear his usual outfit, but is instead seen in the one he wore in Wagonmaster (1950j. Maybe Ford used some footage from that film in the episode.

The story concerns an alcoholic doctor and wife joining the train after their wagon breaks down. The doctor, Colter Craven, has lost his confidence and the Major has to convince him to treat a woman experiencing a very difficult childbirth. He does so by relating the story of how his old friend, Sam Grant, overcame problems with alcohol to become president of the United States. That's all done in flashback.

Most of the John Ford stock company appears in The Colter Craven Story. Anna Lee, Carlton Young, Willis Bouchey, John Carradine, Jack Pennick, Ken Curtis, Chuck Hayward, and Hank Worden (uncredited) are all on hand. Paul Birch handles the role of Ulysses S. Grant perfectly. He stands out in a truly outstanding cast.

This is one of the best western TV series episodes ever made. Be sure to watch it whenever you can.
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Like A Movie
virtual-9388830 August 2021
Until our cable service offered one of the channels that shows mid-century Westerns regularly, I couldn't tell the difference between "Rawhide" and "Wagon Train". I thought they both shared the same catchy theme song. Several months in and I have become a total fan of the genre. "Wagon Train" stands out as one of the best story telling, most talent packed shows of the bunch. "The Colter Craven Story" is among the best of the best. Directed by John Ford, this episode is as multi faceted and complicated as any 2 hour movie. Play "spot the guest stars" and "Festus" Ken Curtis appears in the first 10 minutes. The episode's title character is played by Carleton Young, a John Carradine-esque actor until the real Carradine shows up later. John Wayne appears in the last 10. A brilliant episode from start to finish. I can see why it's a fan favorite and it will always be one of mine. Edit: I am honestly shocked that this episode's writer Tony Paulson doesn't have more credits to his name. Such a talented story teller must have done more.
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Another Piece of the Origin Story
spiritof6731 August 2021
One very interesting fact here: Willis Bouchey, Anna Lee, Ken Curtis and Carleton Young who all appear in this episode were all also in the 1959 John Ford film "The Horse Soldiers". That's got to be some weird coincidence.

Without giving away any spoilers, this is a critical-for-fans piece of the Wagon Train story line. A lot happens here that reflects on later episodes. And a lot about the philosophy of the major gets aired as well. All this and an historic figure appears. Watch it.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed