Imma Tataranni sostituto procuratore (TV Series 2019– ) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
10 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Authentic in multiple ways despite the worn out criminal themes underneath
muratmihcioglu10 November 2021
I watched the final episode of the 2nd season last night, and strongly believe this series is getting not worse but even better, promising even more interesting conflicts of mood for the 3rd season.

What Vanessa Scalera (Imma) told in a recent interview was an eye opener for me. She said that in the source material (the series of novels) her character is somewhat more bitter, physically less likely to fulfill the frame but more loud, etc. I think Scalera's personal charm contributed to the self esteem we get to see on screen.

During the 1st season, I could never really understand what we were to expect from her flirt with Calogiuri, given the character was really not likely to go all the way and betray the loving husband. The way the 2nd season ended will force everyone to account for what actually DID happen based on misperceptions Pietro (the husband) has already developed and others (thanks to the blackmailer's pics) will eventually develop.

I enjoyed how music began to contribute more to the overall mood thanks to Pietro's short-lived dream of running a jazz club. His naive ambitions, his neverending support for Imma (despite losing his dreams bacause of her) did really sink in. The characters are now just too 3-dimensional to not care about the personal lives of.

Where the events are set, Matera, is known best for being the shooting location for Mel Gibson's "The Passion", however it has served even before as a unique setting for several other important films, and also for other Italian TV series (like "Sorelle"). In Imma Tataranni, we see Matera less as the "ancient looking town" and more as a normal part of contemporary Italian life, which it is, being also a touristic center.

The friendships / rapport Imma has with those who surround her, the other women in the office, the law enforcement, they all look very entertaining and genuine DESPITE the very generic crimes she fights against as a prosecutor. And this is where the series finds its success: The focus is on the ordinary people who are just getting by, and the bigger, dirtier players (like the mafia) are not allowed to steal from the joy they are able to reflect to the screen.

To sum it up, this series is family-size fun. You may have some difficulty relating to the characters in the early episodes, but S2 will be worth the adaptation process.
18 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
An Italian, sexy, often funny version of Vera.
dklecan3 September 2020
What an actress! Despite her lugubrious face, the Main character has so much emotion in her face that even without doing or saying anything, you can't look away. A virtual tornado, she gets involved with everyone in her life from the cases she represents, to her adoring hubby, cooking-crazy daughter, mother, and in-laws. She is also the whirlwind center of those that work in her office from her boss to her two shy assistants. She attacks her cases like a bulldog. She is the Italian, often funny, sexy version of Vera.
14 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Good mysteries with humor along the way.
pensman12 June 2022
Imma Tataranni is a deputy prosecutor who loves her job, but gets frustrated with her boss and some of her staff. Her husband is a nice guy, but not Mr. Excitement, still Imma loves him. But she isn't above a fantasy romance with a young handsome Marshall. The daughter she shares with her husband knows how to push her buttons. But when it comes to a murder, Imma will find the truth. Many characters speak quite fast and a subtitle might drop off before you read it, but this is a good series worth watching.
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Imma is a breath of fresh air
kvchat122 June 2022
Too many police/detective series are run of the mill and formulaic. Imma is quirky and smart. Her relationships with her family, colleagues and surroundings (the beautiful Italian scenery feels like a vacation) make this series better than average. There are story threads that continue through each episode gives the series depth. Love Imma's style too, she can really put an outfit together.
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Imma is such a character....
gdn020112 July 2020
We love this series, disappointed though that there is only 4 episodes on MHz choice...
7 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Binge watching
vegashrt25 June 2022
I absolutely love these characters especially Imma! Went through season 1 and 2. I am left hanging cannot find season 3! I told my husband I now know some Italian. Arrivederci, Ann Miller.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Promising, but too filled with drama and cliches
jeremy32 June 2022
Warning: Spoilers
The main actress is very entertaining and dynamic. The relationship with her husband and daughter is well developed. I watched the first five episodes. The problem is that by the fifth episode, it was making the same mistake of so many failed detective shows - trying hard to stir up drama to the point that it loses its identity. For example, the young newly appointed Marshall, Cagliaro, remind me of a male version of Brunetti's secretary. He was very sensitive and attentive to other's needs. But then they had to throw in things that did not make him seem nice, and his bosses perceived love affair with him. There were clear attempts to model the show from Don Matteo (the sentimentality, and the music seemed very similar to that of Don Matteo), and she seemed like a female version of Montalbano. In Young Montalbano there is the earthiness and edge. In Montalbano, the glamorousness. In almost all the episodes, the actor who played Mimi on Montalbano appeared. I was confused. Was he the same character, or was he a different character on each episode he appeared on? That was the problem I had with the series. I admit to not watching the last ten minutes of Episode 5, because it was trying to hard to stir up drama to the point of ridiculousness. I did like the main character, but there does not seem to be a clear direction. There is no Catarella, like on Montalbano, to provide comic relief. There is similarly no Marshall, like on Don Matteo, who is so ridiculously funny.
2 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Probably best for an Italian audience
qui_j4 June 2022
This series is typical of a RAI Fiction production. It is very animated, a lot of shouting and gesticulating with hands, and showcases lots of regional Italian foods. The series itself is very confusing and despite the length of each episode, the thread that holds the story in each episode is very weak, often breaking along the way. Because of the gaps and missing pieces, the result is at the end of the episode, viewers are left contemplating how the crime was ever solved. The humor does not translate well, but the series is entertaining if one wishes to learn about other cultures and there's nothing else to watch!
4 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
A miss
laduqesa5 March 2022
This suffered from what is inserted into so many Italian crime series, namely attempts at humour that are off the mark and actually not funny. They are grating and annoying. For goodness sake, is it meant to be hilarious when the new Chief Prosecutor gets into a lift with his soon-to-be deputy Imma and recounts to her, not knowing who she is, that his number two has a reputation as a shrew and an eccentric? Are the scenes at the beach meant to be amusing when she was trying to catch hold of evidence of a crime and was thought, instead, by her husband and mother-in-law to be drowning, thus losing her the evidence?

These episodes are an hour and three quarters long. I wasn't going to waste that much of my life on even one of them. I switched off after about forty five minutes when I realised that this programme wasn't going anywhere I wanted to arrive at.

There are far better things to watch. I shan't be revisiting the world of the Deputy Prosecutor.
4 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Stupid Relationship Plot Not A Crime Series
dmoorejdrf24 April 2023
Warning: Spoilers
This show started out with amazing potential. I thought it was unique in its approach. The talent displayed by the actress playing Imma Tataranni truly was the shows strength. The flirtation with her young assistant was quite amusing. The appeal of the series was the amusing investigative way Imma solved cases. Then the story line changed from the focus of case solving to the ridiculous relationship between Imma and her young assistant. First of all the idea that these two would be attracted to each other is just plain stupid. They have ZERO chemistry as a couple. It's hard to buy the young stud is pitifully in love with Imma. We've taken her imaginary fantasy and turned it into an utterly unbelievable potential reality. As Umma professes her love for her husband she can't stop thinking about the stud. If she loves her husband so much then why be upset when she hears the stud is going to be a father. If I want a soap opera I'll watch Young & The Retless. But I want a crime series not a soap opera.
0 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed