Battle for the Western Front (2022) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
An Award Winning WWI Indie film by a true Cinematic Virtuoso
Brantford_Mark30 November 2022
Warning: Spoilers
What better way to commemorate Remembrance Day than to attend a preview screening about an important WWI battle? Author, Director and Cinematographer Aaron Huggett brought his film, "The Ace and The Scout" to nearby London, Ontario for a final peek before its eventual release.

Its focus is the 3 day 1918 battle of Orix Trench in Northern France. Canadian Ace Billy Bishop (72 victories) goes on a recruiting tour and convinces a pair of lifelong friends to enlist. They, in turn, end up in the same unit as legendary Anishinaabe sniper Francis Pegahmagabow (300+ confirmed kills). Vastly outnumbered by their German foes, the Canadians have to survive the onslaught for 3 days without food, ammo or reinforcements. An illuminating closeup look at trench warfare.

Afterward, the Director and some cast members took questions from the audience. The history behind the film was meticulously researched. Huggett even traveled to France so he could precisely recreate the site of the battle here in Ontario. Telling stories that otherwise might be lost is a major driver for him. He spent considerable time interviewing the Pegahmagabow family and obtaining their input on the script. In Canada, as in the US, wartime contributions of its indigenous warriors are too often forgotten. The author views "Peggy" as the heart of the film.

I really enjoyed this film. From my perspective, altering just a few aspects of it might have resulted in even better storytelling. Although interwoven throughout, I think the snippets about Billy Bishop are a distraction. As Huggett said, "The Scout" is really the heart of this film. I personally would have liked to have seen more about Pegahmagabow as opposed to Bishop. Additionally, many of the actors appeared to have come from stage rather than cinematic acting backgrounds. Directing them toward more subtle, natural action would have improved the film. An exception is Adam Mezei, who was simply stunning in his portrayal of the sadistic German officer Klaus von Lettow-Vorbeck.

Filmakers who write, direct, produce and act as cinematographer are rare. The aerial sequences and landscape shots were spectacular. Aaron Huggett deserves enormous credit for bringing his vision to the screen on a shoestring budget. Although he declined to be specific, The Ace and The Scout cost just over $1M CAD to make.

The Ace and the Scout has already travelled to film festivals all around the world. Clearly, there's a universality to this film that resonates beyond Canada. It has pulled in a warehouse full of awards from as far away as the UK, Italy, India and Australia. Distribution particulars are being worked out presently. Watch for a public release in 2023.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Very Low Production Value
kenmaz23 April 2024
Warning: Spoilers
I don't know what the budget for this film was, but it was money wasted. I get it that there is supposed to be an amount of suspension of disbelief, but the requirement exceeds reasonable expectations. I've seen better Junior High School productions than this.

Completely overlooking the amateur acting, you would think that the producer would take the time to eliminate all the anachronisms before rolling the cameras. Not with this turkey. You have supposedly senior officers who neither shave nor get haircuts. You have senior NCOs with hair down to their shoulders, sporting shaggy beards. Then there's the recruits with the long hair.

If anyone had paid to see this, I'm sure they would've demanded their money back.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Failed Pegahmagabow
alyciam23 October 2022
Warning: Spoilers
Keenan Keeshig, who portrayed Francis Pegahmagabow, and the actor of the medic character (I couldn't find the actor's name) acted well.

This was painful to watch. Bad acting and weapon inaccuracies aside, the story centers around two white guys who should have been background characters at best. The movie is a hodge podge of Hollywood war movie clichés that didn't go any where and were implausible.

I want more Pegahmagabow. His skills, his struggles, his story, his perspective. According to this movie, his contribution to this important conflict was a series of blink-and-you'll-miss-it scenes.

If you're interested in Billy Bishop, you'll also be disappointed. He appears in the first five minutes, at the end of his career. There are some good, brief dogfights.
4 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A story of Canadian trench warfare
ouldsie5 November 2022
Warning: Spoilers
If you are looking at a story dedicated to a specific individual, this is not a biography. This a story of what soldiers had to endure over a few days in the trenches, low on supplies, and reinforcements, fighting for survival and to protect the line.

As a Canadian history student, I found the attention to the history very well done. The director and actors evoked emotion from the audience throughout the film from using creative cinematography, tight facials, and an emotional musical score.

Overall, very well done, and deserving of the many awards it has already won, and I am sure will continue to win.
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed