User Reviews

Big set up for the final episode for 11A.

Entertaining as usual and still a lot of questions still to be answered about the commonwealth, next episode should be the best one.

Episode 11.07 titled "Promises Broken" is a direct follow-up to episode 11.05 and 11.06, the Reapers storyline and the Commonwealth storyline is continued in a major way. Episode seven follows Maggie and Elijah as they learn a new survival tactic from Negan; Eugene's group clears walkers to pay their fines; Yumiko interviews for an upper-class job; Daryl learns more about Leah and the Reapers; Gabriel encounters a man of God. I think the editing and pacing was perfect in this episode, so was the writing, Julia Ruchman whom penned the script of 11.07 did a great job. Overseen by Angela Kang, I'm really finding the overall writing to be excellent in this season. From the individual character arcs to the grander storylines.

Sharat Raju directed this week's episode and he has previously directed two episodes of Fear TWD, his direction and vision was overall quite great but not the best the season have given us. But a memorable one, Raju truly knows how to make it an immersive experience. The cinematography is truly breathtaking and incredible, the way it was shot with the sets, wow. Art and production design is brilliant. Though Sharat Raju wasn't the best director this season, he knows how to make an episode with a grand vision and I hope he'll direct more episodes. The close ups in dialogue is something I like and sadly isn't used that often, but should be used much more often. The musical score continues to amaze me, it's one of many things on the technical side of things that the show is doing a phenomenal job at.

There were a ton of great performances in this episode, from each storyline. Lauren Cohan's performance as Maggie Greene and Jeffrey Dean Morgan as Negan were among the best, I have said it before and I'll say it again that the work they're doing is truly brilliant and it's the writing that makes it so good. It was nice to see more of Josh Hamilton as Lance Hornsby and Lynn Collins as Leah Shaw, two interesting characters with good performances. Two other brilliant performances in this episode are Norman Reedus as Daryl Dixon and Josh McDermitt as Eugene Porter.

"Promises Broken" has lots of things that fans of The Walking Dead will like, but also some throwbacks to season 10 and the previous seasons. Episode seven is also faithful to the graphic novel regarding the introduction of Sebastian Milton which is the son to Pamela Milton, the governor of the Commonwealth. Sebastian Milton is played by Teo Rapp-Olsson and he's doing a great job at capturing the personality of Sebastian Milton. We are one step closer at meeting Pamela Milton. I'm really enjoying the Commonwealth storyline in how they're dragging it out as it felt a bit rushed in the graphic novel, the Reaper storyline was all about build up and making up a plan and I'm behind it 100% as it's smart but also how it fits into Negan as a character and how far he have come. "Promises Broken" aren't as action heavy as the previous episodes as it's a build up for the mid season finale and I think it was a great episode.

I would've loved to see Pamela Miltons son try some of that spoiled brat bs on Rick or Daryl... they probably would've done worse than Eugene did to him lol.

This episode is going to lead into an amazing mid season finale and I wouldn't be surprised if we lose a main character, or even if the commonwealth shows up to Alexandria.

TWD is Back!!!!!!

Season 11 of the walking dead keeps bringing us amazing episodes!

This looks like a very good build up to the final episode of this year. The 8th episode will decide the quality of this one right here.

An episode that takes place on three fronts, with deep dialogues and important decisions. Even the "less hottest" episodes this season are in excellent quality.

This season blows my mind. People who give this a 1 star, go and watch my little pony it's clearly more your thing. Leave reviewing TWD to the true fans.

Glad that multiple arcs were featured in the episode however it still was very slow. Some interesting dialogue and conversations occurred but I spent the entire episode waiting for something amazing to happen. This episode serves as a build up of tension to EP8 which it does rather effectively. It's set up the arc for the commonwealth quite nicely with issues of class which was teased in episode 2. Still very excited to watch each week but not a massive fan of the reapers story arc which serves as nothing but plot filler. However the reapers arc has provided an interesting dynamic between Negan and Maggie which is entertaining to watch.

Wow, the show has become as slow and decaying as its subject matter.

Eugene, please stick a blade through the skull of this show and put us all out of the misery of what the show has become.

This is supposed to be the grand finale season, but rather go out in a blaze of glory, its being allowed to rot till it can no longer muster the strength to walk.

Anyone giving this episode or season 10/10 must be watching television for the first time.

This episode was extraordinary!! Enjoyed every bit of it. Especially the Negan Maggie scenes. The Commonwealth reveal was awesome too. This episode just lets you know how big and spectacular the next one will be!

Sebastian is so cool i want see him more.

Show getting better.

This episode give you a idea its close to the end And everything is perfect on this episode.

At the Commonwealth, Eugene, Ezekiel, Princess, and Stephanie are sentenced to community service clearing walkers from buildings. Eugene and Stephanie save Sebastian Milton, the son of Governor Pamela Milton, from walkers, but when Sebastian is ungrateful Eugene punches him, getting himself imprisoned. Lance offers Eugene freedom and help for his community if he gives up Alexandria's location. Meanwhile, the Reapers are growing frustrated due to being unable to find Maggie's group. Daryl and Leah find a family in the woods, and Leah refuses to kill them despite Pope's orders to do so. Negan forces Maggie to promise to stop plotting to kill him in exchange for his help against the Reapers, and she reluctantly agrees. Negan fashions a Whisperer mask for Maggie and trains her to command walkers so they can gather a horde to attack Meridian with. During preparation, Negan admits to Maggie he should have killed Rick's entire group during their initial confrontation to convince her of his honesty.

"Promises Broken" serves as a compelling follow-up to the tension-filled narratives established in earlier episodes of "The Walking Dead's" final season. This episode intricately weaves together the themes of survival, loyalty, and the moral compromises that characters must navigate in the post-apocalyptic world. It stands out for its ability to balance character development with the overarching plot, pushing forward the season's narrative while delving into the psychological underpinnings of its key players.

The episode predominantly focuses on the fragile alliances and the lengths to which characters will go to protect their people and ideals. The dynamics between Maggie and Negan take center stage, offering viewers a deep dive into their complex relationship. Their uneasy alliance, driven by a mutual goal but fraught with underlying tension and past grievances, highlights the evolving nature of character interactions in the face of survival. The nuanced performances by Lauren Cohan and Jeffrey Dean Morgan add layers of depth to their characters, portraying a tenuous balance between cooperation and the specter of betrayal.

Another significant aspect of "Promises Broken" is the exploration of the Commonwealth storyline. This arc offers a stark contrast to the survivalist narrative, presenting a semblance of pre-apocalypse civilization that is both alluring and inherently flawed. The episode deftly critiques the notion of order and governance in a post-apocalyptic society, suggesting that the facade of safety and prosperity may come at the cost of freedom and individuality. The subplot involving Eugene's mission within the Commonwealth adds a layer of intrigue and suspense, setting the stage for future conflicts.

"Promises Broken" also excels in its visual storytelling, using the desolate yet hauntingly beautiful landscape to underscore the isolation and desperation of the characters' circumstances. The cinematography and direction effectively complement the episode's tone, balancing moments of quiet introspection with bursts of intense action.

In conclusion, "Promises Broken" is a testament to "The Walking Dead's" enduring ability to blend character-driven drama with socio-political commentary. The episode not only advances the plot but also challenges its characters and viewers to ponder the cost of survival and the meaning of community in a world reclaimed by the dead. As the series inches closer to its finale, "Promises Broken" skillfully sets the stage for the culmination of its characters' journeys, promising a finale that is both emotionally resonant and thought-provoking.

I have persisted, but I just can't do it any more! Promises Broken jumped the shark for me with that ridiculous scene with Milton's son making out as walkers approach. Thanks for the memories.

"Promises Broken" effectively sets up for the first part's conclusion. The return of the Whisperer's tactic was a great involvement to the story, and Maggie and Negan's rivalry continues to be compelling. Josh Hamilton's performance as Lance was great, as well as for Sebastian who's part was played effectively well. The pacing of certain scenes felt somewhat rushed, but the pace was engaging nonetheless.

OVERALL - [8.5/10]