User Reviews

This was a rather calm episode with more politics and negotiations than immediate dangers of zombies attacking or two groups fighting each other, and I quite enjoyed it.

First of all, I really liked all the scenes with Eugene and I think he's grown so much on me as a character since when we first saw his rather pathetic azz in season 5.

I already know some people are gonna say "oh boohoo incel Eugene got rejected again and now we gotta now watch him cry." But those scenes were surprisingly quite emotional for me, because that guy has seriously been through a lot and when he thought he actually find something good, the world kicked him down again and he realized it was all a lie. So I can feel him and I'm really liking the chemistry they're building between him and Max. It might not seem that at first, but I think we're getting there.

Then we have Pamela and Hornsby visiting Hilltop and put on a show so Maggie could accept their offer but Maggie is smarter than that.

So I kinda didn't like Maggie when she first came to Hilltop and was just an azz to Rick and the rest and then she left for like 2 seasons and now that she's back again, I don't really know how to feel about her. I'm neutral about her right now but I liked her in this episode. Obviously, it seems that what she's doing is gonna impact her community negatively, but it's obvious that she made the right choice for the long run.

And Hornsby is definitely a fascinating character that gets more and more interesting each episode, and the actor is doing a really good job. You're never quite sure what his intentions are, or if he's just a good man trying to help people or just a power-hungry politician trying to overthrow the leader. Which the second one is is the most probable and obvious one, but I hope there's more to it than just a guy like the Governor. For now, they're not revealing much about Hornsby and Pamela's intentions, so I hope the writers have some interesting things up their sleeve and they're not just delaying it just to reach the 16 and 24 episodes AMC ordered them to do.

So far it seems like the speculations about the "Six months later" scene were right and Hornsby is gonna attempt a coup against Pamela. Which is nice I guess, and not a bad story line, but I think I need more of a nuanced plot with more surprising twists since they're being shy about revealing what Hornsby really wants and what his secret group is all about.

I think I agree with the other review that said they're dedicating too much screen time to Daryl and Aaron should get some of those instead of him. I think Aaron has been a really underappreciated character in this series and should get more screen time like he did last season. This is The Walking Dead, there are so many characters with potential that are just getting dusted on the shelf. I think they should've somehow made Aaron fill the role of Rick whenever he was gone. Daryl is definitely a great character but he doesn't have to be the main focus every episode. I think since Rick was gone, they decided that Daryl should be the center of the story (which he's really not here in this episode, nor was in the last one, but Aaron should've gotten more screen time this episode) and some times they don't know what to do with him.

All in all, a very interesting episode that builds and sets in motion lots of interesting conflicts and story lines and we have to wait and see the outcome.

Episode 11.12 titled "The Lucky Ones" is entirely focused on the Commonwealth storyline. The premise for episode 12 reads: Aaron and Maggie meet Governor Pamela Milton as she tours Alexandria, Oceanside and Hilltop; Ezekiel finds himself lucky during a routine checkup; Eugene processes Max's story. I think the editing and pacing was perfect in this episode, with some great transitions. Vivian Tse penned the script for 11.12, the overall writing is great. Overseen by Angela Kang, the writing for this episode is consistent of the previous episodes in Part 2. The episode uses the big budget wisely, making it brilliant both technically and the acting and so on, the camera work are brilliant and it's visually a great episode, an overall impressive production.

Tawnia McKiernan directed 11.12 "The Lucky Ones" and the direction is really fine, I loved some of the shots and there are so many great scenes in this episode. If you have read the graphic novel you'll or not, this episode is for everyone. But how Tawnia and the cinematographer shoots the nature in this episode, stunning is all, extremely beautiful shots. The cinematography is once again breathtaking and incredible, the way it was shot and so on, just brilliant. The sets were detailed and perfect, and so are the art and production design. Superb sound design and a musical score both gripping and dramatic. It's one of many things on the technical side of things that the show succeeds perfectly with.

As this was a direct follow-up to the previous episode which ended with Eugene finally learning the truth of the real Stephanie which turned out to be Max and the direction Angela Kang goes with their storyline is finally incredible, Max being the sister of Mercer was a nice twist, whilst Pamela getting the tour of Alexandria, Oceanside and Hilltop. Having almost the entire cast in the episode was a nice sight, and everyone has something important to do which Part 2 have really nailed. The best performances were Josh Hamilton as Lance Hornsby, Norman Reedus as Daryl Dixon, Lauren Cohan as Maggie Greene and Laila Robins as Pamela Milton. But the thing with this episode isn't how mind blowing and epic it was, there are lots of scenes when people are only talking and conversing, which in my opinion is needed in an episode like this. There's still plenty of zombie killing and it looks fantastic. I wouldn't say this was a slow paced episode, I honestly wish it was longer than 45 minutes as it felt a bit rushed but that's my opinion, it was at a fine length.

"The Lucky Ones" has lots of things that fans of The Walking Dead will like. Angela Kang is truly giving the Commonwealth arc a lot of depth and I'm liking it a lot, Part 2 continues to be amazing and "The Lucky Ones" brings the anticipated issue from the graphic novel to the screen and I think it's better because of how well thought and personal they have made it in regards of a big universe like a tiny bit of dialogue Pamela Milton has with Daryl in how she knew Deanna Monroe. Things like that made me happy. I think the dialogue was some of the season's best, with each bit of dialogue being meaningful, it's also huge thanks to the actors who deliver the lines, simply brilliant from a writing point of view. "The Lucky Ones" are an nostalgic trip for old and new fans, with its dialogue and character interactions that will easily make you smile and feel for the characters. This episode did the material justice to me as it gave us plenty of character development, story building and our characters getting closer to where they were in the flashforward we saw.

This was a very fun episode to watch. Seeing the communities (even Oceanside!) again is great and Pamela and Lance's banter about them is cool to see (including the nice Deana callback that adds to the world-building).

Maggie and Pamela arguing about leadership and how communities should be was such a highlight. The show has become so political that you can pause the episodes and have full-on debates about who is right. This is exactly what a Commonwealth arc should have!

The other plots weren't as strong. Ezekiel refusing to cheat the surgery list is very in character, but I'm glad he's going through with it.

Eugene bailing on Max felt weird and I just don't care too much about their relationship. Still, both actors are putting on great performances and the reunion was sweet.

But all in all, they are setting up for some great stuff. Between Lance's mysterious plan and Mercer's warning to Daryl... I can't wait to see more of the corruption of the Commonwealth.

Looking back on it as a whole, in a universe where the dead have come alive, I will still say the most unrealistic thing about this show was probably the romantic pairing of Eugene and Max. As. If.

As a side note to that impossible romance, did we need 2 of the very last episodes of this series to almost exclusively be about Eugene? There are 12 episodes left, grand total, maybe some progress beyond Eugene's love life should be made.

Oh, Maggie briefly shows up, to turn down the thing we know she'll later do. Why the holdup? Why the endless dragging with this series?

It's. The. Last. Season. Wrap. This. Garbage. Up.

The woman introduces herself to Eugene as Max Mercer, who was using her mother's name as a code name. Even though she wanted to meet Eugene, once her brother Mercer caught wind of it, he covered it up when Lance also was alerted to her breach in communication protocol, and forced herself to remain quiet upon seeing Eugene with Shira. Eugene storms away due to being too hurt, but eventually goes to reconcile with Max and the pair expresses lingering interest in each other. Meanwhile, Pamela takes a tour of the Coalition's settlements and is unimpressed to hear Alexandria has fallen more than once. After meeting with Oceanside, Pamela goes to Hilltop where she debates Maggie over their different leadership styles and forms of government. Maggie is suspicious of the Commonwealth and refuses to accept aid from them, to the frustration of several Hilltop residents who decide to go join the Commonwealth. Lance is also frustrated by Maggie's decision but insists to Aaron he will persevere, seeking to build up his power to get out from under Pamela. Meanwhile, Ezekiel is admitted for surgery to remove his tumor, having been moved up the line for treatment by Lance as a favor to Carol.

"The Lucky Ones" stands as a profound and reflective episode in the eleventh season of "The Walking Dead," delving into themes of fortune, sacrifice, and the stark disparities within the Commonwealth. This episode shifts the narrative focus, juxtaposing the relative safety and prosperity of the Commonwealth's elite with the ongoing struggles of those on its periphery. Through this lens, "The Lucky Ones" offers a poignant commentary on social inequality and the arbitrary nature of survival in a post-apocalyptic world.

At the heart of this episode are the personal stories of characters who are forced to confront their pasts and the choices that have led them to the present. It's a narrative filled with emotional depth, as characters reckon with the realization that what separates them from those deemed less fortunate is often nothing more than circumstance or chance. The storytelling is nuanced, weaving together individual arcs that highlight the resilience of the human spirit and the complex motivations driving each character. These personal journeys are underscored by powerful performances that bring vulnerability and strength to the fore, emphasizing the humanity of each character amidst the chaos of their world.

"The Lucky Ones" also excels in its exploration of the moral ambiguities of leadership and the responsibilities that come with power. It questions the cost of security and the sacrifices made in the name of progress, challenging both the characters and the audience to consider the ethical implications of their actions. The episode skillfully balances these heavier themes with moments of hope and solidarity, showcasing the small victories and connections that sustain the characters through their darkest hours.

Visually, the episode is striking, utilizing the stark contrasts between the opulence of the Commonwealth and the desolation of the world outside to further highlight the thematic concerns of inequality and privilege. The direction and cinematography work in tandem to create a sense of tension and foreboding, even in moments of calm, hinting at the underlying conflicts that threaten to erupt.

In conclusion, "The Lucky Ones" is a compelling addition to "The Walking Dead's" final season, rich in thematic complexity and emotional resonance. It challenges viewers to reflect on the notions of luck, privilege, and the inherent value of all lives in a world ravaged by loss and despair. Through its thought-provoking narrative and strong character development, this episode reinforces the series' enduring exploration of what it means to be human in the face of unimaginable adversity.

This is not a 9. I'm doing this to counter balance people hating on any episode that doesn't have every single character they want in it, or has even five minutes of talking.

However, its a solid 7.5, a good episode with good pacing, direction (apart from audio) and some cool walker action.

We are in the final stretch of this show's story, we've moved beyond shuffling around in empty streets for food now, if you want more of that - there are other shows which are still in the early days of the apocalypse.

I think this episode is pretty good because its slowly giving us reasons to both trust and not trust many characters, and we can see whats coming - I like that.

Eugene and Max are alright, Ezekiel isn't holding grudges for 8 episodes like some other seasons with other characters, we're moving forward but still addressing things instead of overlooking them.

Gov. Pamela Milton travels with Hornsby, Mercer Darryl and an entourage to Alexandria, Hilltop and Oceanside, to confirm the agreement with Alexandria and propose a deal with the other communities. Commonwealth is helping Aaron to rebuild Alexandria and expects to help the other two too. The leader of Oceanside, Rachel, tells Pamela that whatever Maggie agrees, she will concur. Therefore, Pamela talks to Maggie while walking through the woods, trying to convince her. But Maggie declines the offer, and Dianne and other Hilltop's dwellers leave Maggie and travel to live in Commonwealth. Eugene visits Max and tells that he is sorry for his rudeness.

"The Lucky Ones" is another deceptive episode of "The Walking Dead". Hornsby seems to have his personal agenda, but Pamela Milton seems to be a smart woman. The reason why Maggie does not accept her offer seems to be because absolute power corrupts, and she is no exception. Pamela sounds reasonable with her dreams to rebuild America, but Maggie never explains what she wants for her son Herschel. My vote is six.

Title (Brazil): "Sorte" ("Lucky")

It may not be for everyone, but the show has never been in a more intriguing place. Most of the remaining main cast are being written smartly in both narrative and dialogue. Commonwealth has given the show a whole new purpose, and its leaders have potential to be among the best antagonists. Compare it to three seasons ago, a show that was on its deathbed. Kang has revitalized the series through time jumps and structure to be at its peak when it concludes. That's if they can follow through on what they've been building towards.

This is more of a filler/set up episode but i still enjoyed it and seeing all the characters. Lance seems interesting enough as well as pamela and im excited to see where they take the story this season. I do wish we saw more of oceanside and honestly the whole max and eugene situation feels like unnecessary drama.

Even in the Final Season, Its All The Same, Right ?

Meet A New Community, Befriend them and life with them

Big Mysteries about the Community and the People, and the Main Charakteres like Maggie or Daryl want to find the Truth .........

But Still i Watch it and enjoy it, but i wished that for the Final Season, that there would be an huge Twist to how to tell the Story or how to End it.

I am starting to believe that the staff is writing positive reviews to keep the show barely afloat until it dies for good.

Every walker showing up is not being introduced just to pass the time until the episode ends. There is absolutely nothing added to the plot by walkers anymore.

"Interesting narrative" "Never been in a more intriguing place" "Building the story"

What narrative? What story? Everything is all over the place. The characters have been incredibly dumbed down and nothing makes sense.

Only once in my life I had this feeling. And it's the feeling from the last season of Game of Thrones. It's happening again folks.

And don't get me started with the lady at the end explaining the episode. If you need to explain the episode then the episode is baaaaad.

Also, she explains it like a 3rd grader writing a composition about his summer vacation.

I found myself reading the ingredients to my nutter butters while watching this episode. It was more exciting than the pointless drivel that is twd. I can't believe how corny this show has gotten.

"i nEeD tO cOuNTeRbAlAnCE tHe 1-StAr rEViewS"