User Reviews

Have most of the characters taken a lesson from Beth on how to be complete sociopaths?? Nearly everyone on the show has become unlikabke . Either they're whining at life's unfairness or just treating each other as inhumanly as possible. The scene with Jimmy in the truck with the cowboys was disgusting. Who'd want to ride with these degenerate creeps?? I know I wouldn't. Is this supposed to toughen Jimmy or make him lose his humanity. The laughable Rip and Beth romance continues. In real life these two psychopaths would have readily killed each other ten times over with all the anger and hostility they discharge every day at others. It'd be like making a Wolverine and a badger cohabitate. The only two good scenes were Kayce's disgust and desperation with Monica and Tate. And the standoff with Dutton ( ala Eastwood's Fistfull of Dollars ) at the end. You need some likable protagonists or your going to eventually start losing your audience,

I hate how shows so quickly skip over the recovery after major attacks. They are all back to normal way too quickly.

A lot of promise with this episode, but I still feel like the show is just pulling along a bit.

Ok, 3 episodes in and I just have to say it. This season is a mess! Did they hire a new editor to splice all the scenes up into disastrous order?

How is Kayce just now addressing his wife and kid after events that happened 2-3 months ago? That scene was fine, but it needed to happen much earlier. The show treated them like they didn't exist after the attack. Kayce would have never waited that long to address this with them or talk to his kid about killing a man.

Same deal with Rip. After the attack, I was so on edge with anticipation to see how pissed he was going to be when he first saw what happened to Beth. Nope. We never even got to see that reunion until she was all healed up way later with just scars left and aside from touching her scarred back, it's never addressed.

And where is the action? All glossed over in the monologue. When Dutton told Kayce they were going to kill all the militia, I thought there would be some more suspense, build up and action, but instead, we got to see it like we hit the fast forward button through it. That could have filled an entire episode and been really cool.

I love this show, but 3 episodes in, I have no real idea where it is headed this season, nor is there any main protagonist I am excited to see the Dutton's square of against. I mean, they just randomly threw in the scene of Rip chucking the rattle snake at Rourke in the first episode, so guess it won't be him (another scene seemingly out of place & just edited in).

So far, this show needs the Zack Snyder cut or something. I think it has good materiel there, but it's been a jumbled together mess.

Starts off with the Montana livestock agents executing a bunch of random militia (?) people. What's the death toll at in this small part of Montana the last 2 years? 150? 200? Then the Dutton trio gets a chance to shine. Beth smacks a kid in public then smashes a ladies phone. Kacey leaves a man in a cage to die. John tortures and kills another guy. Who cares right? No one will investigate.

This show has some strong dialogue moments but the action and plot is just all over the place. It's starting to turn into sons of anarchy, and not in a good way.

This show. I don't know why it or Taylor Sheridan get the acclaim that they do.

Oh look, for some reason, the livestock agent is deeply involved in the take down of a bunch of, what are they being called, militia? In acts of retribution. One would think Montana would be empty of guns for hire at this point. But there seems to be an endless supply of cannon fodder, without so much as an eye blink over one family being able to use law enforcement for legally sanctioned vendettas.

And were we supposed to be cheering for Kayce as he violated multiple civil rights of that ranch owner? Yet another sad tale of woe from a downtrodden local rancher complaining that due process is too slow or expensive or won't come to the "right" conclusion, so yet another Dutton solution of beating the sissy Californian (it's ALWAYS a Californian) transplant who is using the land wrong into submission.

Meanwhile, oops, four episodes in, and Sheridan forgot about Monica and Tate. I guess they've been in his bedroom for 3 months, with him hiding under the bed? Just yank him out and yell at him to eat his dinner. Problem solved! At this point, I honestly thought they brought in Carter to replace him as resident kid in peril, and we'd never see him again.

Speaking of Carter, did Beth and Cole adopt him? Are they fostering him? You'd think there would be some child protective services involved. But I've already put more thought into this than Sheridan did. But hey, time for another cardboard cutout meek person temporarily trying to stand up to Beth in the form of a mom yelling child abuse and filming her. Yet another broken phone later and IDK, I think at this point I'm rooting for Carter to murder Beth and Cole in their sleep to come full circle on Cole.