Penance (TV Mini Series 2012) Poster

(2012)

User Reviews

Review this title
7 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Another Impressive Effort By Kiyoshi
ebossert20 April 2012
Well, we finally get to see something from Kiyoshi Kurosawa. Here's an introduction from the J-Film-Pow-Wow website:

"It was only a few days ago that I was looking at my DVD shelf and my eyes stopped on Kiyoshi Kurosawa's "Tokyo Sonata" (2008). I remember when that film had its North American premiere at the Toronto International Film Festival and critics were hailing it as one of Kurosawa's masterpieces. Then . . . nothing. Kurosawa continued to teach at Tokyo's University of the Arts' Film School, but no new projects from him came to light. Well, that's about to change, although maybe not for us here in North America, at least not yet. Let me explain.

According to Tokyograph Kurosawa has directed a series based on the work of novelist Kanae Minato. Minato's name doesn't ring a bell? It should. Tetsuya Nakashima's "Confessions" was based on Minato's 2008 novel of the same name. Due to the success of that adaptation Kurosawa was brought in by the folks at WOWOW to not only direct but also write the screenplay for a screen adaptation of Mintao's 2009 novel "Shokuzai." "Shokuzai" tells a story eerily similar to "Confessions" in which a mother blames four students for not being able to identify the murderer of her daughter 15 years before. The story is also eerie enough to put in the hands of Kurosawa, that man who brought us such landmark J-Horror films as "Cure" and "Pulse." The biggest problem for Kurosawa fans is that WOWOW will be broadcasting "Shokuzai" on Japanese TV in January. There is no word at all if the film will see a DVD release anytime in North America, but given that Kurosawa's 2000 film "Séance" was a made-for-TV project there is hope that we'll eventually get to see "Shokuzai."

My Review In One Breath: Kiyoshi Kurosawa returns in top form with this television mini-series (5 episodes, 50-75 minutes each). 15 years after a little girl is raped and murdered, her mother and four of her childhood friends deal with the emotional consequences. Each episode focuses on one character at a time, which gives the actresses ample screen time to make their contributions. And let me tell you, there is some serious acting talent on display here: Kyoko Koizumi ("Tokyo Sonata"), Yu Aoi ("Don't Laugh At My Romance"), Eiko Koike ("2LDK"), Sakura Ando ("Love Exposure"), and Chizuru Ikewaki ("Oishi Man") all have significant roles. As expected from this director, the camera-work is outstanding, there is heavy emphasis on psychology, and subtle character mannerisms are expertly utilized to create suspicion and uncertainty.

There are three other things to keep in mind regarding "Shokuzai." 1. This series fits comfortably within the "drama" genre, not the "horror" genre. 2. The characters are developed very well. 3. This not a tale of revenge. The mother of the victim refuses to forgive the girls (now grown up) for not being able to identify the murderer, but she does not seek vengeance. The plot basically shows how the women were psychologically affected by the traumatic incident in their childhood.

Strongly recommended for fans of Kiyoshi.
20 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
(Sur)realism
markovicdejan7216 September 2012
"Shokuzai", in my opinion, deserves 8/10, as a TV series, but if we consider these episodes as separated units, because they are more or less accomplished little films, I'll give them lower values. I think, besides first episode titled "French Doll" anyone else of next four episodes wouldn't be Kiyoshi Kurosawa's favorite for individual distribution as a movie. Simply, with this TV series Kiyoshi didn't achieve quality of his previous TV projects - "Seance" and "House of Bugs".

Don't get me wrong. This Kiyoshi's work also is, without any doubts, surgically precisely shot and directed, well-written and well-acted, but he didn't build up it's own reality, virtual reality, which every artwork have to contain in order to persuade the audience, that this screen's reality is more "reliable" than real world. Artistic reality doesn't imply mere reflection of our everyday lives, which is, sometimes, exciting and upsetting, but otherwise prosaic. In fact, it implies surrealism, vividness, using symbols, metaphors, allegory, phantasmagory, everything we could have found in the best Kiyoshi's movies, such as "Pulse", "Charisma", "Loft", "Cure", "Bright Future" etc.

K.Kurosawa is one of my favorite directors, therefore my expectations were too high, although this project obviously wasn't conceived as an artwork but mass consumption TV product. In the end, I hope that his next projects will be made for theatre, not for TV.
12 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
The first three chapters would've been enough
asabilal13 August 2013
After watching the masterpiece 'Tokyo Sonata', I was expecting a lot from this TV series directed by Kiyoshi Kurosawa. After watching 'Shokuzai', I think I was maybe expecting way too much.

I had the chance to see Shokuzai in theaters here in Belgium. For that occasion, they split the series in two parts: the first three chapters (240 min) and the last two (110 min). The first three chapters ('The French Doll', 'The Bear...' and 'The PTM...') were very good. I haven't even felt the need to take a look at my watch so 'absorbed' I was by the story. If I hadn't seen the rest of it, I'd give it 9 out of 10. But in the last two chapters, Kiyoshi Kurosawa lost me, and many other people in the audience.

The last two chapters focus on Emili's murder, and even though it's the main plot of the series, it was its less interesting part.
4 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Kanae did it again!!!!
TBnTN10 November 2019
Warning: Spoilers
I didn't see THAT COMING!! No one wants to look over their shoulder their entire life but, maybe, if you change the course of a life, they should! No strange stranger-danger here, just a bitter old lover and loser! I love Kanae but these kids must be touched in a negative way after getting into the minds of these characters. Fantastic actors all around; from toddlers to mindless, well-meaning adults! Waiting for the next...
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Exposing the Weirdness of Tokyo Culture
thalassafischer8 November 2023
Warning: Spoilers
Penance starts out fairly tame, with five young girls, and one being seduced by an older man to her death. The mother is understandably angry and upset and blames the other girls who are as old as ten for not helping to find the murderer. She inappropriately places some kind of curse on these little kids, but let's face it, it's no worse than some angry religious Karen in a rich neighborhood in the American South.

However, the kids grow up, and that's where the insanity really starts. Sae reacts to her friends' murder by becoming anorexic and refusing to become a woman. A disturbed but wealthy incel follows her from childhood through a Japanese matchmaking service (yes, this is where the weirdness truly begins) and she reluctantly agrees to marry him. There's a moment where the viewer believes for a second that the Japanese tradition of matching young people through marriages might be a good idea. Sae declares happily she never imagined this kind of financial security and commitment for herself which is why she always had avoided dating and didn't want to be a woman. For a split second we think Sae is making the right decision by choosing the nerdy successful guy who will give her a beautiful house with a promise of lifelong commitment.

But then this freak admits he was the French doll theif from her childhood and he tracked her down because she had a "girl's body" and he basically wants to marry her so he can control her, keep her at home, and only jerk off to her wearing doll dresses as a perpetual virgin. It's VERY CREEPY. Everything you've heard about men watching anime marrying blow up dolls. A complete expose of Tokyo creeper culture. Anyway, so Sae ends up BEATING HIM TO DEATH WITH A LAMP (wouldn't you?)

That was her "penance".

The second woman is a very strict, almost evil, teacher. And this again is supposed to be a commentary on Japanese people pushing their children too hard to be perfect and overachieve. But somehow nothing will ever be as weird as the first episode.
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Derailed by classic Japanese writing amateurism
westonportman23 November 2012
Warning: Spoilers
"Shokuzai" first appears to have everything a Kurosawa fan would hope for, yet fails miserably to hold any lasting emotional or intellectual value due to extremely poor and formulaic writing.

As a study in film making, I would rate it at least 8/10 for something so low budget. The camera shots bring me back to the early Kurosawa days, slow and contemplative so much as to make any fan rejoice. Kurosawa's usage of sound and odd atmospheric background tracks are another stand out trademark of his that no fan will fail to appreciate in "Shokuzai". The first couple of episodes are such a treat in this sense that it's easy to miss what blunders the story suffers at first.

The core problem with "Shokuzai" is with it's writing, where character actions and convictions are vastly unconvincing, and the problems they suffer are so obviously curable it makes you nearly scream. "Shokuzai" treats childish and illogically perceived problems as absolute truths with no answer, then expects the viewer to feel sorry for it's characters who we are supposed helpless victims.

The characters fail to use any kind of logic, and the entire script bleeds of missed conversational opportunities. Worse is the repeated idea of one's "shokuzai" or "atonement" that every character is obsessed with, so much that one is locked up in a mental ward while another commits murder. Whether or not the book does a better job of showing us why this "shokuzai" is such an important part of these girl's lives is unknown to me, but these episodes take something that seems almost trivial, and tries to make it out as the main plot device.

Indeed, the problems that the characters face in "Shokuzai" would never be relevant on TV or in a novel outside of Japan. However, the idea that all Japanese enjoy this kind of story telling, or that the issues the characters suffer from are always real problems in Japan is simply untrue.

Creating characters who are overcome by grand ideas, repeating illogical one liners, and plagued by overly conceptual thinking is pretentious and boring. It is never well received, and never critically acclaimed even in Japan. As even Kurosawa's earlier films suggest, there is a home for logic and free thinking in Japan, transcendent of stereotyping and cultural boundaries, "Shokuzai" however, is not it. Here we have a series that is a massive step backwards in story telling, handled "well" by a director who is capable of much more.
12 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Incomprehensible mess
inuimari25 October 2014
I'm a huge Kiyoshi Kurosawa fan. I find that he and my other favorite director, John Carpenter, really know how to use well space and eerie tone to maximize the dread and atmosphere. This is clearly a low budget drama series and Kurosawa does what he can with the budget (and ample space!). There are definitely key scenes and overarching sense of dread that Kurosawa fans have grown accustomed to. I have no problem with the direction but the plot...!

I've read the book and really loved it. I was curious to see how the book got adapted into the film and let me tell you, it seriously doesn't make any sense! Of course, when adapting a novel, there will be many changes made to make it work on the screen. However, the changes they made are incomprehensible, especially the second story. The conclusion to that story was simply unnecessary and seeing characters take abuse for no reason makes viewers feel annoyed. The plot leaves out so many details that were in the book that it seriously doesn't make any sense whatsoever. For example, the first story doesn't even bother why they had French dolls decorated in the house. Therefore, it was bizarre when the protagonist of that story suddenly says that they had a French doll displayed in the house. The ending came out of nowhere and didn't make sense; it doesn't not fit with the theme of "penance". The series doesn't really do a great job explaining how much the even that took place 15 years ago affected these girls. Asako's character was changed greatly to the point that it wouldn't fit the big revelation. I guess it won't be much of a spoiler since things changed but the book does make it clear that Asako is a selfish thoughtless woman and the entire event happened because of her. I felt a great catharsis when Yuka tells off Asako but that was lost in this series. The fact that Asako stopped being the selfish nightmare in this adaptation really made the final revelation not work and also shows how much the screenwriters didn't understand the original source.
4 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed