"Silent Witness" And Then I Fell in Love: Part 2 (TV Episode 2012) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Terrifyingly real.
Sleepin_Dragon14 October 2018
And then I fell in love is to date, the toughest story to watch in Silent Witness's history, watching this second part I felt sick, angry, upset, it really churned up emotions that I felt when I saw the news break about the Rotherham grooming scandal. There is a terrifying reality running through both episodes.

The show has dealt with many harrowing cases and scenarios, but this one gets under the skin like no other, dark from beginning to end. I must praise the performances of the whole cast, Elyes Gabel in particular I thought was terrific throughout, he played his part tremendously well, a bit of a shame that Emma Amos and Sanjeev Bhaskar had relatively small parts, both were great though.

Some scenes are very upsetting to watch, making this an episode I won't watch repeatedly. Fortunately there are some lighter scenes, Harry's disturbed sleep at Nikki's flat at least provided some relief.

It's terrific, but very near the knuckle. 9/10
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A disturbing case that was all too believable
Tweekums24 August 2012
Warning: Spoilers
This story would have been disturbing at the best of times but it felt all too real knowing that its broadcast was delayed by several months because a similar case was going through the courts at the time. The episode opens with Nikki witnessing an accident; a teenage girl was hit by a car. She manages to save the girl but can't understand why she is terrified of the Asian paramedic. It isn't long before the team are investigating two apparently unconnected deaths; a heavily tattooed man and a body found in a suitcase that came from the local airport, which they assume could have come from anywhere in the world. After visiting Shannon, the injured girl, in the hospital Nikki's keys and wallet go missing; it was of no surprise that she turns up at Nikki's house that evening; what is a surprise is that she is suffering from the same illness that killed the tattooed man. While all this is going on we see a group of Asian men grooming under-aged white school girls; telling them that they love them and that they are special but really holding them in contempt; all the time they intend to drug them and sell them for those wanting to pay for sex. With nobody wanting to talk the team will have a hard time proving what happened and as the police inspector investigating the case says; it is a minefield due to the 'cultural sensitivities' and the police fear of being accused of racial bias if they go after people of Pakistani origins.

While I hadn't read details of the real case of Asian men grooming white teenagers it was impossible not to think that what we are seeing on the screen might be similar. This made it much more disturbing than most cases dealt with in the series; it was shot in a way that made it believable; never looking glamorous and sometimes slightly blurred to emphasise the victims' drugged state. The acting was solid, both from the regular cast and the guest stars; this made the men and the young girls they preyed on seem real. They are quite a few moments that are particularly upsetting so it isn't an episode to be 'enjoyed' even if it was a story well told. Having watched it I can see why it was postponed; it was brave of the BBC to make it in the first place given the racial elements.
9 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Gruesome
Hitchcoc18 April 2019
As we move on to the second part of this episode, we continue to see this horror of horrors, strikingly handsome young Pakistani man, kill, maim, assault, enslave and destroy the lives of vulnerable teenagers. He plays on their weaknesses and surrounds himself with a stable of lackeys who fear him. The pathologists get involved but the girls won't help finger them when they manage to escape. The title is a summation of what is at the center. Finding love wherever it can be found.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed