Derrick and Toby disappear from their conflicted lives and land together in a strange place, where they meet long-time resident Nathaniel. Shortly afterward, their absences are discovered by Derrick's wife Raya and Toby's mother Molly.
Derrick's nemesis Teo meets the cryptic Petra, Molly encounters an eerie sighting, and Toby, Derrick and Nathaniel get acquainted until things take a terrifying turn.
Investigations continue while Molly tries an unconventional way to locate Toby, who is at odds with Nathaniel after realizing his true intentions are unknown. Mimi's sleepover at Anna's house ends in a bizarre experience.
Molly and Raya pick up the pieces while investigators look for answers, and Valerie worries about her daughter Anna after her condition puts her in danger. Meanwhile, Petra's supernatural act draws Raya into Teo's hostile, dangerous world.
Molly continues her spiritual investigation in search of Toby while things get complicated for investigators. Toby and Nathaniel reach a very dangerous area with the premise of helping Toby, and Nathaniel reveals his dubious plan.