5 months ago, Artis met Jess, a blonde beauty, online. Artis and Jess each were in relationships, but believed they'd found true love. Artis is finally ready to meet Jess in person. But is Jess everything that she says she is?
For six years, Pamela has spent thousands and has been kicked out of her home, all in pursuit of her sweet Fernando from Venezuela; but when "Catfish" comes calling, it seems that Fernando might be closer than anyone expected.
William falls hard for Carmella, but after spending hours on the phone, sharing the most intimate details together, Carmella won't meet up or even videochat; Nev and Kamie help William figure out what secrets Carmella is hiding.
Matt's smitten with TikToker Elise, but Nev and guest host Devyn Simone see red flags on the horizon. When asked to meet, Elise says she's worried about upsetting Nev. Who is this mystery girl and what's her connection to Nev?
Flavour, a musician, has been sweet-talking Kimberly, a mother of 3, on Instagram, and she's fallen in love; however, since Kimberly has been scammed in the past, her daughter calls "Catfish" for help when Flavour starts asking for gifts.
Kaycee, a single mum of two, couldn't resist Mike's charms when she met him online. But his odd disappearances concern Nev and Kamie, who help Kaycee uncover shocking secrets that question everything she ever knew about Mike.
Lauren met Derek on MySpace nearly 8 years ago! Since then she's relied on him for everything and knows that Derek is the man of her dreams. The only problem is, they've never met in real life or even video chatted.
Carmen is concerned about her cousin Antwane's 3-year romance with a man named Tony. Antwane lives a virtually pre-digital age existence making Tony's true identity difficult to reveal. Is Tony really who he says he is?