Fail State (2017) Poster

(2017)

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Definately worth watching
boydpeters8 January 2019
As a non US person it was good to see this didn't descend into partisan politics- impartial. Snouts in the trough, nothing new but lays it out clearly. I was sad for the people with the sham degrees but they also bare a degree of responsibility for not researching that these sham qualifications are not recognised by any employers or legitimate education providers. Community colleges seem a good option, appears there are insufficient places in them. I would like to see the longer term benefit to Texas for their initiative. We watched as a family- with the kids. Lots of pausing and conversing. Good film, well done all
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
An important call to action
kleenexcow20 October 2018
I remember when I was a kid in the 90's, watching daytime TV during the summer and noticing that every commercial seemed to be for ITT Tech. Even as a kid, I thought it seemed super scammy to target so heavily people at home watching daytime TV. Beyond that, though, this was a subject I didn't know a lot about, and the documentary does an excellent job in making it easy to follow the process that led to the rise of for-profit colleges and exactly why that they do is so predatory. There were several "wow" moments where you just rock back, amazed at how boldly these companies rip off people who are already at a disadvantage and how hardly anyone, especially among elected lawmakers (on both side of the aisle) who receive gigantic campaign contributions from these companies, seems willing to stop them. It isn't all hopeless, though. The documentary also highlights how good community colleges are in actually doing the things for-profits claim to do, and opened my eyes to how much supporting them is one of the most effective, helpful things we can do to support higher education in this county. This is a really great, insightful documentary that exposes truths about a terrible industry. I highly recommend it and am grateful to the filmmakers for doing this work and the people featured in the documentary for sharing their knowledge and experiences.
16 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Harsh reality?
ImNotFromEarth24 February 2019
Thanks for finally making a video that documents these atrocities, making it easier for most people, who just don't have time to do their own homework, to put everything together. These industries and government organizations are screwing everyone, and have been getting away with it for decades, right under the public's noses, while the endless complaints just continue to be ignored, especially by the VA and the DOE. There are two facebook support groups, one for Art Institute, one for ITT tech- if you've had this problem with any for profit school, you should join both, since the information found in either will be relevant.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Long overdue feature length expose into the systemic corruption of the US higher education system
PopcornChickens31 December 2018
Our education system has been continually betraying taxpayers and students by taking away their protections and protecting the industry predators. This film does an excellent job at recounting the history of how the greed of private interests worked to undermine the once noble pursuit of going to college.

Watch this film, share this film. It is imperative that we not only find relief for the generation of students affected by this fraudulent debt, but also put an end to the debt incurred by future students.

Our grandparents did not have student debt, so why are we ok with 44 million students and taxpayers now living under 1.5 trillion of it? This money is not going into the betterment of the system- it is going to the fat cats on wall street and corrupt loan companies. So why defend it? We need to understand the causes that led to this and realize that we can undo the damage if we act now.

Many top economists agree that cancelling all student debt in the country would be vastly more beneficial to the economy than allowing it to continue to persist and burden those living with it. Search online for "The Macroeconomic effects of student debt cancellation" by the levy institute to learn more. We can fix this- but first we have to understand how it was made and how it should not even exist in the first place. It was a result of the government and accreditors failing to protect students because they were themselves making money off of the corruption.
8 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Evil Backstory of Student Loans
AziziOthmanMY20 December 2018
Education is a must in today's world unfortunately some organizations treat you like garbage and getting paid at the same time. This documentary brings you to the dark world of student loans showcasing the people who prey on the weak and the poor.
6 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A wasted opportunity ruined by partisanship
tetrahex22 December 2018
Its the usual narrative, a fixation on the private sector schools fleecing people with fraudulent credentials, which is a real problem, but fails to get down to the more fundamental problem which is far less convenient to the political agenda of the documentary makers, that this problem extends to all schools. In the push to universalize higher education the assumption was made that you could make successful people through access to university, failing to realize that many of the people who went to university in the past would have been successful regardless, they were a different breed. And so with the dumbing down of higher education you have the manufacturing of credentials and departments like with "gender studies" It wouldn't matter if these degrees didn't come with debt, they were worthless to begin with. Add the debt issue and you have created a self perpetuating machine of credential-ism through debt.

And not only that, you have created a system of manufacturing activists. This extended high school system created a self reinforcing filter for compliance, as the most compliant students would jump through all the hoops to succeed in the system, and having succeeded in the system, they would perpetuate this system of obedience to authority.

This system creates a perverse trust in academia when the microcosm of society they run themselves is the most dysfunctional around. Administrators and professors gorge themselves on the future generations debt. No one ever asked if this level of education was truly necessary, possible or even sustainable. The fertility rate of "educated" women kind of says it all, either this is dysgenics in action, or its evolution as the obedience are weeded out, so it maybe self correcting in the end, but the collateral damage to civilization is too great to let it play out that way.

The solution is harsh but it is the only way to finally solve the problem, student debt should not be guaranteed, and loans should end, only then will colleges charge customers only what they can actually afford. The documentary makers so fond of their mad Maxine Waters clips would rather push to fuel the self destructive system by providing ever wider access, and even more unlimited funds.

This documentary dishonestly conflates the post war boom which was only possible through the destruction of all our competitors by war combined with the residual christian work ethic and family values we still had at the time with simple access to higher education. It turns a multi factorial issue into a simplistic uni-factorial problem where education becomes the magic bean solution, and that misguided notion is exactly what has created this monstrous machine of student debt and credentialism.

Go look up the "women's studies" departments salaries and department cost at your local college, and try to justify it, you can't, they only exist to manufacture their own justification for existing, and the financial damage is almost minimal compared to what that ripple of indoctrination does when it interacts with the rest of society, usually manifesting in just alternate forms of extortionate parasitism.

Spending its time blaming republicans, the documentary completely misses the point that the entire higher educational system is archaic. Most professors reciting the same lectures like automatons, they don't ask if a single exceptional professor in some video format would do better, for instance on YouTube where many examples already exist. This documentary is in service of a system which is highly inefficient and doesn't scale, asking all the wrong questions. The most basic one being that if students are this easily fooled into false programs, why would you imagine they were fit for a conventional degree program. These are people who would have been better suited to practical job training/vocational programs, which were pushed by the wayside by democrats who pushed the unrealistic dream that "everyone could be an astronaut". The scam goes much further than this documentary will acknowledge, because it implicates those they are ideologically in league with, and opens them to dealing with unquestioned presuppositions they would rather continue go unquestioned.
15 out of 30 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed