Meditation Park (2017) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Elderly woman discovers independence and dignity.
maurice_yacowar19 March 2018
Warning: Spoilers
The title gives pause. No reference is made to a "Meditation Park." That could be the greenery through which the Chinese women run their aerobic jog and where Maria watches and is confronted by her husband Bing's mistress. But in a cafe scene the women discuss a higher reality, the spiritual world before which our mundane existence is just an illusion. That scene roots the title. The film presents several scenes of daily life advancing into such a higher reality. They usually depict a situation of earnest conflict giving way to a spirit of community, harmony, higher understanding. The most obvious involves neighbour Gabriel. At first he is disruptive and selfish, undermining the Chinese women by stealing their parking clients and undercutting their rates. When Maria helps him escape the cops (and a $5k fine, Canadian but still...) she shows him the error of his ways and converts enemy to friend. Their bond deepens when his invalid wife dies. At the end he's jogging with the Chinese leaders through that park. The fair-like block party is an image of the neighbourhood transcending its differences to discover an overriding new harmony. The soundless disco is a double metaphor. When the characters dance to a seemingly unheard music they embody the life attuned to a higher reality. Their separate earphones confirm they are separated individuals but bonded by an unseen harmony. The makes this temporary amusement park a kind of meditation park. So, too, the film's two most moving and revealing scenes: intimate exchanges between separated women. In the first Maria's banished son's fiancee drops in for an unexpected visit. The women thaw the ice their men have left stiff between them. In the second Maria is visited in the park by her husband's mistress, who apologizes for having lured him away and explains the loneliness and despair that drove her into that adultery. Maria forgives her - and even asks her to take him back, to make him and her own life less miserable. The girl properly declines. Here as in the family reunion at the unseen wedding, an antagonism yields to a new harmony. Bing has himself undergone a process of revelation. He has banished his son in anger at his loss of face when the son missed the community dinner. When his mistress dumps him, Bing explodes in drunken rage. He despairs at the loss of his romantic future. He numbly offers his wife the escape he planned with his mistress. But in ordering Maria to miss their son's marriage Bing tries to reaffirm his autocratic authority. But she has discovered independence, through higher values than his domestic tyranny. The father may not have gone to his son's wedding, but when he stands alone and humbled before the wall of family photos and he feels the pain at his daughter's revolt against his dominance the film leaves the promise of possibly his discovery of values higher than his own vanity too. This is a superb little film. It's striking for the way its family of mixed marriages reveals a post-racist community. Race is not an issue here, though the clash of petty egos persists. The characters are all finely detailed, flawed but sympathetic, glamour less and real. Director Shum brilliantly realizes their socio-economic milieu in the finely-detailed sets. But the heart of the film is those two scenes between the women - and a powerful, insightful heart it is.
11 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A quietly important film
Le_Nausea30 March 2019
I hope more films like this are made. Not just because it gave voice to an isolating situation that many immigrant women have lived, but because it was just so surprisingly cute, poignant and funny! I truly loved the gaze of this old chinese lady and the way she continued finding herself, despite such betrayal by a man whom she had given her entire life too. I sometimes enjoy watching the banalities of life tbh. If you're a millennial like me then maybe you're Grandma was little bit of her, if you're older maybe she's your own mother (hopefully you take care of her just as well as her children too - some v heartwarming moments there). I have read + actively observed that some husbands oft have entirely different standards for their daughters than for their wives. This film is a message, a reminder that its never too late to find oneself (outside of who you are to others).
12 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Delightful and real
inspirelake6 August 2023
This is a clever little gem that shows real people doing life with all its baggage and shiny bits rubbed off but it has a gorgeous upbeat feel, some real laugh out loud moments and lovely actors.

All immigrant experiences come hand in hand with pain and change and this shows them up with how people come to review their experiences and the choices they make to cover old wounds, dragging those who they love behind them. Highly recommend this for the special moments, the revealing moments, the changes that people have to make and the changes they can't avoid. "I was a maths teacher in my own country but when I came here I slaughtered chickens for 12 hours a day... the smell, the blood... and you ask me if I worried about you children? I did that for us all to have a better life." Pretty much sums up in total the immigrants 'dream.' Yes, things can improve but the costs remain to be counted somewhere. But do enjoy, it is otherwise a beautifully crafted film of humour, love and laughter.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Looking back at the immigrant experience.
chong_an14 March 2018
There are stories about new immigrants, but this is a story maybe 40 years later, when the family has expanded to 3 generations, and relationships have gotten complicated. There is still. however, the conflict between old-world values and new-world ones. This is a satisfying look at one possible family situation. Bing has sacrificed his life to his family, immigrating from Hong Kong to Canada, and initially taking any job available. His wife Maria is stuck between home, the Chinatown market, and the recreation centre, given her limited English, inability to drive, and Bing's pride. After the family celebration of Bing's 65th birthday, he runs off, and next morning Maria finds women's underwear in his pants pocket. This leads Maria to finally try to build her independence, earn some money, and track down the "other woman". There are subplots that involve their daughter, son, and neighbors. The subplots show how controlling Bing tries to be, and how much he needs to save face, even if he has behavior that cannot be exposed. There are some minor problems, like Maria learning to ride a bike, and occasionally with the subtitles simplifying what is said. A reasonable amount of the dialogue is in Cantonese, with a little Mandarin thrown in. The acting by the principals is good, the setting is natural, and the technical aspects serve the story without drawing attention.
12 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Sweet, heart warming, yet gut wrenching
jesamazinghawley7 April 2018
I loved it. It was beautifully told, had humor and drama, and the acting was excellent. Definitely a movie to watch if you love good actors!
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
One of the best.
maverickcowboy31 August 2021
This was one of the best movies I have seen in quite some time. Old world values plus new generations and conflicts between the two. Loved the relationships between the 4 women as well as the neighbour. This one was a fresh breath of air. Being 94 minutes, it is well worth the watch.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed