User Reviews

Yeah, the last episodes had been slow, but this is for the big bad things that are going to happen. I'm so excited! We finally saw something of how the whisperers live.

Not everyone or perhaps better stated not anyone but Aaron, is happy with Michone's leadership at Alexandria.

Michone Trump's democracy is actually playing out like an autocracy with her vetoing any idea she doesn't agree with in the name of national security.

Is Rosista's 2 timing going to lead to some strange threesome+baby with Eugene on the outside making relationship matrixs and stretchy pants? Odds are one of her suitors die fairly soon.

Beta's strong physical presence as Alpha's right hand man adds a more threatening dynamic to the Whispers as a whole. Beta would make a good Michael Myers or Jason Voorhees.

The Whispers day to day lifestyle seems more realistic than the junk peoples did. How to make a Whisper mask 101, interesting. How to use a Godfather garrote to the point of decapitation, brutal. Challenging Alpha's leadership, bad idea. At least the dude got to hold his girlfriend's head one last time, touching.

Negan laying the groundwork for his seemingly inevitable freedom is interesting to watch unfold. Fascinating to observe Judith advocate on his behalf. I was just waiting for her to tell Michonne "Your not my Mom !"

Dog retrieves Daryl's arrows from dead Walkers, nice.

It won't be a real fair until the Whispers show up.

Henry's luck was in between West Side Story's knife fight and Romeo and Juliet. (Query: Would Alpha actually allow Lydia to kill Henry or would she have stopped the execution at the last second therefore simply testing her daughters resolve as Alpha said herself having Henry as a hostage is leverage)

Daryl's Walker mask actually looked cleaner than his face and hair usually does.

Interesting parallel of Michone's constitution which gives her the final say and Alpha's law of allowing anyone the right to challenge her leadership only to be summarily executed with the help of Beta.

Lydia had the best line of the night- "Guess Henry is dumber than I thought."

So this was another awesome episode, this season has been amazing. So of course we still have this massive rift between Alexandria and the rest of communities. We still don't know what caused it, but we know it has to do with the X scars on Michonne and Daryl's backs. But it seems the people are not happy being isolated and like Father G has said who will we look to if we need help. So i am looking forward to seeing what caused this massive rift and the scars.

So we got some more Negan and Michonne, since he went back to his cell. He is listening in to what is going on and can tell Michonne is losing her grasp, judith listening in. I do like how judith is kinda becoming a moral compass in a way, defending negan saying he has changed just like how michonne has changed.

Beta is a badass and very creepy, we saw the whole challenging alpha from some other whisperers......which did not turn out to well for them. Alpha just beheading the woman with a wire was brutal.

Then of course the ending where alpha was going to make lydia kill henry. Alpha just had this icy cold stare just before the walkers attacked the whisperer camp that daryl brought in.

Alpha is just one brutal violent villain since i would maybe say the governor. Since the governor after walker penny got killed by michonne he just lost it. He killed all his men after they ran from the battle. I don't think she really cares about the other whisperers, we know she made another whisperer just leave her baby on the ground to be eaten. She probably does not even care about her daughter, just got her out of there to find out what info she gathered.

So this episode was really good, so many things to look forward to. The Fair is coming, pike are coming and Beta and Daryl fighting should be really good.

I know the time jump and all changed a lot but did it wipe out the ability to make more bullets?? The three camps ought to be armed to the teeth, but instead they are using knives, sticks, and bow and arrows (oh yeah and a sling shot!).

This Whisperers threat would be over very quickly if they broke out the side arms.

Not a bad episode, the "challenge" was entertaining while it lasted, but I just can't get into the Alpha character. She is just not hooking me in as a villain like The Governor or Negan did.

In this episode we had two nuclei: Alexandria and Whisperers.

in alexandria, we see that michonne puts his decisions in safety and is questioned by the council about the fair in the kingdom, and negan, who shows himself changed by saying correctly, proposes to be michonne's advisor, but she does not accept. as dull as it may be, we also had the love triangle and quartet between Rosita, Siddiq, Father Gabriel and Eugene who confesses to being in love with Rosita

Already the positive point of the episode is centered in the camp of the whispers, we know a little about his life and the alpha. the actress samantha morthon continues to act incredibly like alpha that with its strong leadership shows itself more perverse or relentless with its own daughter (lydia) in a moment of tension where it is forced to kill its partner Henry and if the girl does not, the mother would send the beta kill the two, making the alpha even more cruel. But it all ends when zombies invade the camp that are brought to him by daryl and connie who risked their lives by taking the child, daryl in the episode is so stupid that I do not know how he managed to catch the zombies there, being this is not so easy, then even more as a lot, unless Amc has set the scenario quickly in the script ...

In conclusion, '' Guardians '' is an episode that shows the viewer how the animal life is and unbelievable of the whispers in the zombie apocalispe and how cruel is alpha and his right arm Beta, that on the other hand in alexandria we have a worrying situation regarding the expected and dangerous fair that is to come.

vote: 7.0/10

Last week's review was censored, so they only published my sanitized 4th review. The original was a dozy, but you could guess what I wrote.

So, Dumb O'Henry goes after Lyd, and Dar, Dog and Deaf Girl follow. O'Henry is a cheap plot device. We see the Whisps roaming around like Walkers. Real silly stuff. If you're not laughing, please check your pulse, you may have already turned. Very bad. People turning into zombies in a show, or dressing like one in a show is one thing, but the audience turning into zombies, that is unforgivable. Do the producers of this show even know that they are contributing to by dumbing down of our society with this nonsense? Maybe. But they sure know they are making a buck. So, why should they care.

These Whisps in zombie makeup, Hipster Extras in Halloween Masks, are roaming around. They capture poor low IQ O'Henry, and we get to see a rebellion and execution. For the record Alph has the stupidest southern accent I've ever heard. It's unreal. Nobody ever spoke like this, and nobody ever will again. Alph orders Lyd to kill O'Henry. Dar orchestrates a zombie attack by impersonating a Whisp and saves O'Henry and Lyd. Give O'Henry another chance to screw up. O'Henry is a liability.

Alexandria, we have not 3, but ménage à quatre with Rosy, Gab, Sad, and Eug. What a mess. Rosy is with Gab, but pregnant with Sad's baby, and Eug is madly in love with Rosy. What will Rosy do? What will we do?

We have politics, with Mic veto power over not going to the Fair with the Kingdom. Did anybody even bother to let the Kingdom know about the Whisps? At least Hillside told Alexandria about Rosy and Eug. We have Neeg back in the slammer offering his services to Mic. Mic refuses. We have Jud Little Wonder Woman with the Coral/Rick hat talking smack to Mic about Neeg. Super Soap.

The only way to enjoy this is as a comedy. Just add laugh tracks.