- Olivia Benson: You know, we've heard this sex-games-gone-wrong story a hundred times before. You buying it?
- Amanda Rollins: Well, Botox and cupcakes? Sounds tempting.
- Dominic Carisi: [seeing Dr. Barron's townhouse] There must be a lot of beautiful people in this city.
- Odafin Tutuola: Couldn't pay me to inject poison in my face.
- Ava Parcell: So what are they saying?
- Olivia Benson: Well, they're claiming that the three-way was consensual.
- Ava Parcell: Consensual? No.
- Amanda Rollins: They also said that you gave them the drugs.
- Ava Parcell: I told you that I don't do drugs, so, no, I didn't drug them. Do you believe them?
- Olivia Benson: We're just trying to figure out what happened. All right, there were three people in that room and two of them are saying that you're lying.
- Ava Parcell: I'm not lying.
- Amanda Rollins: Okay, well, Sadie also said that you'd had a three-way in college. Maybe you wanted to try it again?
- Ava Parcell: Even if I wanted to try it again, I did not want this. Oh, my God. You don't believe me? I did not want this. They raped me!
- Olivia Benson: Okay.
- Ava Parcell: Okay, what? What are you going to do? Are you going to arrest them?
- Olivia Benson: We are going to build a case and we're going to start by getting a search warrant for their apartment.
- Olivia Benson: [about Heath and Sadie] They got an answer for everything.
- Dominic Carisi: So did Ted Bundy, until he didn't.
- Ava Parcell: My phone has been ringing off the hook. They're making me out to be the bad guy. The... the prude.
- Olivia Benson: You're not a prude because you didn't want to be assaulted. Listen to me. You just put that out of your head. That's... that's false.
- Ava Parcell: I'm being vilified on TV, online. They're saying that I am doing this for a payoff.
- Olivia Benson: Okay, just... just... let's... let's take a breath.
- Ava Parcell: You know, let's just drop the whole thing. I don't want to press charges. I'm done.
- [walks away]
- Olivia Benson: Ava, they're going to keep going. There's going to be more girls, more victims.
- Ava Parcell: Let them testify.
- [storms off]
- Olivia Benson: [to Sadie] Ceci, you were 14. You should have been out shopping for prom dresses or... or gossiping with your friends about Rob Kurtz.
- Sadie Parker: I said stop!
- Olivia Benson: He's in L.A., by the way. He's a lawyer there. Heath Barron stole all of that from you. It's time for you to stop protecting him.
- Sadie Parker: You've never been in love, have you?
- Olivia Benson: But does he love you?
- Sadie Parker: That's a stupid question. I'm everything to him.
- Olivia Benson: Then why does he keep inviting other women into your bed?
- Olivia Benson: [to Sadie\Ceci about Heath murdering another woman] Maybe it was an accident. Maybe he didn't mean to kill her, but whatever it was, when he got bored with her, you became his fantasy girl. And then when he got bored with you, he molded you into what he saw as perfection.
- Sadie Parker: No, no! He loves me.
- Olivia Benson: No, he loves the idea of you. The perfect beauty. But beauty fades, Ceci. Even the perfect beauty that he created. That's why he brings other women home to your bed. Because he's searching for something that can never, ever really exist.
- Sadie Parker: Have you ever made love to a woman? Oh, I... I know you want to. You want someone who understands you. Your needs, your fantasies, your body. Someone with gentle lips and a curious and generous tongue searching your mouth while a man takes you hard, rough...
- Amanda Rollins: [cuts her off] No, that's okay.
- Hal Taylor: [to Olivia] Seven years ago on Ceci's birthday, Ruthie and I had a fake funeral. Father John said it would give us some kind of closure. There's no such thing as closure. What the hey? Maybe it's a good thing Ruthie's gone.
- Sadie Parker: What is it with you people? Do you hate sex or are you just scared of it? We enjoy what's natural, what's beautiful. You get your jollies by turning it all into something sick and criminal.
- Olivia Benson: Truth be told, I couldn't care less what you and Heath do in your private life, as long as nobody else gets hurt.
- Dr. Heath Barron: [to Rollins] Look, women are fragile beings. They're tortured by the what-ifs. What if I didn't have that damn mole? What if my lips were a little plumper? What if my breasts were a little firmer? I'm sure you know what I'm talking about, Detective. I'm sure you've spent more than one sleepless night wondering, "What if my body doesn't return to where it was?"
- Amanda Rollins: We don't need to talk about me.
- Dr. Heath Barron: Why not? You're a woman. You have fantasies. I make those fantasies real. I do not kill little girls.
- Amanda Rollins: You don't care about your patient's fantasies. You care about your own. But that's the thing about fantasies. They're not going to be about flesh and blood. They're never going to be real.
- Ava Parcell: My god, your friends are so damn good-looking.
- Trina: Yeah, get on out there. Cuffing season is in full swing, you know?
- Ava Parcell: I mean, just because it's cold and people are lonely doesn't mean that they're desperate to cuff up with some rando.
- [checking out a hot guy]
- Ava Parcell: Although, wow, he could make me ignore my better angels.
- Dominic Carisi: Hey, lieu, I finally got something on that SOB. I found an encrypted file on the doc's computer. TARU enhanced it. It's, uh... it's particularly vivid. The ending's no surprise.
- Olivia Benson: She can't be more than fourteen or fifteen.
- Dominic Carisi: I don't think the feds are gonna prosecute for possession of one video, but look at this.
- [enlarging the picture]
- Dominic Carisi: Medical books.
- Olivia Benson: You think that Barron made this video?
- Dominic Carisi: Yeah. I sent that girl's image to NCMEC. Now, they matched it through facial recognition. Her name is Ceci Taylor. She went missing from Brooklyn fourteen years ago. That is one year before Heath Barron graduated Stony Point Med.
- Olivia Benson: That's two hours north of the city.
- Dominic Carisi: Now, if we can just prove that he shot this video there...
- Olivia Benson: Go, go.
- Olivia Benson: So, do you tape all of your threesomes?
- Sadie Parker: I like to watch.
- Amanda Rollins: You do more than watch, Sadie.
- Sadie Parker: [Benson plays a video] That's Jenny Abrams.
- Amanda Rollins: And she looks like she's in quite a bit of distress.
- Sadie Parker: Oh, she was orgasming. It was a big one. They say if you put photos side by side of people in pain and people orgasming, it's hard to tell the difference.
- Sadie Parker: [when she and Heath are being arrested] What? So three-ways are illegal now? I thought this was New York, not Texas.
- Dr. Heath Barron: The tyranny of the parochial, babe. It's everywhere.
- Dr. Heath Barron: You wouldn't mind that, would you, Detective? Two women, both melting under your touch, every erotic sense in your body churning and churning until they all explode simultaneously in total mental and physical ecstasy?
- Trina: [accepting a bottle of wine] Oh, I love Italian reds.
- Dr. Heath Barron: Everything the French brag about, but cheaper.
- Odafin Tutuola: He's got some weed over here, but he's got a prescription for this, too.
- Dominic Carisi: [finding a bondage ball-gag] Hey, whatever happened to bottles of champagne and candles?
- Odafin Tutuola: You don't really want me to answer that, do you?
- Olivia Benson: Okay, Ava is clearly unconscious. That's rape one.
- Dominic Carisi: We found dozens more, all labeled with girls' first names and dates.
- Amanda Rollins: Going back ten years.
- Odafin Tutuola: Lots of dilated pupils.
- Olivia Benson: And Ava's the first to complain?
- Amanda Rollins: We could be looking at a lot of victims here.
- Olivia Benson: Well, let's start with one. Pick up Sadie and Barron for the rape of Ava Parcell.
- Olivia Benson: Mr. Taylor.
- Hal Taylor: I came as soon as I could. Is she okay?
- Olivia Benson: She's a little rattled, but I'm sure that this will help. This way.
- [leading him back to the holding cells]
- Olivia Benson: Hey, can we open it up?
- Sadie Parker: [crying] Hi.
- Hal Taylor: Ceci?
- Sadie Parker: Daddy, I'm sorry.
- Hal Taylor: [hugging] Oh, baby. Oh, baby ohh. Oh, baby.
- Sadie Parker: I'm so sorry.
- Hal Taylor: Oh, it's okay. It's okay.
- Dr. Heath Barron: Sadie and I have been together forever. We're like an old married couple. She jokes, "Add sugar to maintain freshness." She's a baker. That's why.
- Olivia Benson: And Ava was the sweetener?
- Olivia Benson: So the victim was found wandering the streets ringing doorbells?
- Dominic Carisi: Ava Parcell, she's 30 years old. Tox screen showed MDMA, Clonanzepam, and BAC was .15.
- Olivia Benson: Rape kit?
- Dominic Carisi: Minor trauma. She had bruising in the thighs, semen in the throat and her mouth. The lab is running DNA right now.
- Olivia Benson: Oh, my god, with that level of intoxication, let's hope she knows what planet she's on.
- Odafin Tutuola: Damn, it's like a pharmacy in here. Codeine, Oxy, Xanax, Ambien. All prescribed to her by him.
- Dominic Carisi: Perks of living with a doctor; nothing illegal.
- Odafin Tutuola: Yeah, but you don't stash your non-prescription drugs in your medicine cabinet.
- Ilana Benjamin: You arrested my client because a party girl enlisted him and his girlfriend for a threesome? What am I missing?
- Odafin Tutuola: The video we have of our witness. She's passed out on your client's bed, incapable of consent.
- Dominic Carisi: Yeah, you and your girlfriend got quite a collection of sex tapes, Heath.
- Dr. Heath Barron: If watching sex is now illegal, you're gonna have to arrest 90% of the country.
- Odafin Tutuola: Well, that's a good point, but some of your victims were too high to consent.
- Dominic Carisi: [showing him an image on his tablet] That woman is unconscious.
- Dominic Carisi: He covered the body in lye to stop the smell.
- Olivia Benson: Something a med student would know.
- Odafin Tutuola: Well, he's not just a perv anymore. He's a perv murderer.
- Olivia Benson: Guys, let's... let's not get out ahead of our skis.
- Dominic Carisi: Let's not get ahead of our skis? Lieutenant, no disrespect, but we got a little girl on video. We got a little girl's bones. From where I'm standing, two plus two equals four.
- Amanda Rollins: And sometimes it doesn't. The M.E. ran the DNA from the bones in the bag against a sample from a hairbush that her father gave us. It doesn't match up.
- Dominic Carisi: The body in the bag is not Ceci Taylor?
- Amanda Rollins: Not if you believe science.
- Odafin Tutuola: Maybe that new video of Ceci will convince Ava to testify.
- Olivia Benson: That video was very convincing. Maybe it'll convince someone else.
- Ava Parcell: She's so sad.
- Dominic Carisi: They were both searching for something that didn't exist.
- Ava Parcell: I'll testify.
- Dominic Carisi: Good. It's the right thing.
- Amanda Rollins: Her name is Ceci Taylor. She was fourteen when you recorded this, so that makes you a pedophile, Doc.
- Dr. Heath Barron: You think that's me? Oh, for god's sakes. Somebody e-mailed it to me.
- Amanda Rollins: And you kept it.
- Dr. Heath Barron: It was years ago. I forgot about it. I have... I have no idea who made that.
- Amanda Rollins: That's weird, because it was recorded when and where you lived during med school. The odds are pretty good that, uh, that you're telling a little white one here.
- Ilana Benjamin: "Pretty good" doesn't cut it in a criminal trial, Detective.
- Dr. Heath Barron: I'm sorry, how do you know where I lived during medical school?
- Amanda Rollins: I'm glad you asked me that. Your old classmate, Louise, took my colleagues there. Yeah, did you know Louise teaches at your alma mater now?
- Dr. Heath Barron: You spoke to Louise?
- Amanda Rollins: Yeah. Looks like somebody might still be carrying a torch.
- Dr. Heath Barron: Please, that's ridiculous.
- Amanda Rollins: That's one possibility. The other possibility is that you've been looking for Ms. Louise ever since she walked out of your five-course Italian feast fourteen years ago.
- Odafin Tutuola: The dean told me you were in Heath Barron's class in med school, Professor.
- Louise Halperin: Louise is fine. My little Heath Bar. That's what I called him. It was a long time ago.
- Dominic Carisi: So you two were close?
- Louise Halperin: Sure. How do I put this? He wanted to be a lot closer.
- Dominic Carisi: But you didn't want that.
- Louise Halperin: I was dating a guy with dirt under his fingernails. Contractor.
- Odafin Tutuola: How did Heath handle rejection?
- Louise Halperin: Let me count the ways. Flowers, candy. Once I went to his place to study. He had a five-course meal laid out, including some chichi bottle of Italian red. Cost more than my rent.
- Dominic Carisi: Do you remember where his place was?
- Louise Halperin: It's out near the lake. I live out that way if you want to follow.