I'll grant that this was probably a brilliant adaptation of a Flannery O'Connor book, like everyone here has said. But I didn't read the book OR any other O'Connor work. I didn't know that a film made from a book required you to read the book first.
It certainly helps sometimes, as with 2001: A Space Odyssey. But whenever I have commented on a movie being faithful to a book, I have been told by more serious film buffs that a movie made from a book should stand on its own. And if it only reaches those who read the book first, that it has failed to truly deliver.
I suppose it's a great movie because I didn't understand it. Sure, the idea of a rabid, humorless zealot preaching for the Church of Truth Without Christ is hilarious. We expect someone "without Christ" to be venal and corrupt, but this guy is far truer to his version of faith than the other preachers are to a "real" religion.
But I didn't like or care about anyone here. What war did Hazel Motes fight in? There's no real sense of period here. And why can't he get a real job with his Army experience? And what the heck was that Enoch character all about?
If Motes was supposed to be a "Christ figure," he failed for me. It may be holy to accept the sufferings God sends your way, but suffering at your own hand shouldn't count. I wouldn't care to know him in real life, much less follow him.
I guess I'll have to read the book now....
It certainly helps sometimes, as with 2001: A Space Odyssey. But whenever I have commented on a movie being faithful to a book, I have been told by more serious film buffs that a movie made from a book should stand on its own. And if it only reaches those who read the book first, that it has failed to truly deliver.
I suppose it's a great movie because I didn't understand it. Sure, the idea of a rabid, humorless zealot preaching for the Church of Truth Without Christ is hilarious. We expect someone "without Christ" to be venal and corrupt, but this guy is far truer to his version of faith than the other preachers are to a "real" religion.
But I didn't like or care about anyone here. What war did Hazel Motes fight in? There's no real sense of period here. And why can't he get a real job with his Army experience? And what the heck was that Enoch character all about?
If Motes was supposed to be a "Christ figure," he failed for me. It may be holy to accept the sufferings God sends your way, but suffering at your own hand shouldn't count. I wouldn't care to know him in real life, much less follow him.
I guess I'll have to read the book now....
Tell Your Friends