I had read the book (The Orchid Thief by Susan Orlean, which I recommend highly) and was very disappointed in the movie.
Adaptation seemed self-indulgent and lazy to me. Instead of telling the story of The Orchid Thief, played wonderfully by Chris Cooper, and the tale of the New Yorker writer (played by the always great Meryl Streep) who does an book about him (and who does not become enamored of him in the book - more sloppy screenwriting to find a quick story angle), we get Major Hollywood Angst about the screenwriter who has writer's block. The movie focuses too much on over-the-top acting by Nicholas Cage, which seems the norm for him these days. The cutsie-pie cedits given to Charlie and Donald Kaufman (the latter being fictional) are the cherries on this sundae of Hollywood excess.
Adaptation reminded me of another ballyhooed 2002 movie, The Hours. Both were self-conscious and screamed, "This is art!" No sale here.
Adaptation: 4/10
(SPOILER: Big surprise - the ending in the movie is not the book's ending. The Orchid Thief is alive and well.)
Adaptation seemed self-indulgent and lazy to me. Instead of telling the story of The Orchid Thief, played wonderfully by Chris Cooper, and the tale of the New Yorker writer (played by the always great Meryl Streep) who does an book about him (and who does not become enamored of him in the book - more sloppy screenwriting to find a quick story angle), we get Major Hollywood Angst about the screenwriter who has writer's block. The movie focuses too much on over-the-top acting by Nicholas Cage, which seems the norm for him these days. The cutsie-pie cedits given to Charlie and Donald Kaufman (the latter being fictional) are the cherries on this sundae of Hollywood excess.
Adaptation reminded me of another ballyhooed 2002 movie, The Hours. Both were self-conscious and screamed, "This is art!" No sale here.
Adaptation: 4/10
(SPOILER: Big surprise - the ending in the movie is not the book's ending. The Orchid Thief is alive and well.)
Tell Your Friends