The movie is fun and goofy. For that I give it a solid 8 stars.
But at the end of it all, it leaves the viewer unsatisfied. The main plot line of the movie that didn't have any pay off was the character played by Phil Joel. The movie was a modern parable about the prodigal son. Here was Phil Joel in the circus, shoveling elephant dung, and missed dearly by his parents. He even realizes after reading the "Gideon's Guide" (I wonder why they didn't call it the Bible in the movie) that he was just like the prodigal son.
There was a glimmer of character development for him.
But instead of reuninting him with his parents and fleshing out that entire plot line and character arc, it gets dropped right after he comes to that meeting and testifies how that story reached him, and the rest of the movie is just plain silliness about how bad of a circus performance the boys present to the public. We see no further development of his character after that point.
I don't mind the band trying to save the circus plot line, or Phil Joel's story line. But neither really have any compelling pay off. The band lost their "shirts" in the end but then what is the motivation for the clown to give his prize money to the widow of the original cirucus owner? Did he give it all? A tithe of it? Did he give any money to the band? How well did he do out of that windfall of cash?
The movie is good silly fun over all. I still enjoy it after all these years. But it could have been a lot better. I think it needed an extra 15-20 minutes to play out some of those dangling plot lines.
But at the end of it all, it leaves the viewer unsatisfied. The main plot line of the movie that didn't have any pay off was the character played by Phil Joel. The movie was a modern parable about the prodigal son. Here was Phil Joel in the circus, shoveling elephant dung, and missed dearly by his parents. He even realizes after reading the "Gideon's Guide" (I wonder why they didn't call it the Bible in the movie) that he was just like the prodigal son.
There was a glimmer of character development for him.
But instead of reuninting him with his parents and fleshing out that entire plot line and character arc, it gets dropped right after he comes to that meeting and testifies how that story reached him, and the rest of the movie is just plain silliness about how bad of a circus performance the boys present to the public. We see no further development of his character after that point.
I don't mind the band trying to save the circus plot line, or Phil Joel's story line. But neither really have any compelling pay off. The band lost their "shirts" in the end but then what is the motivation for the clown to give his prize money to the widow of the original cirucus owner? Did he give it all? A tithe of it? Did he give any money to the band? How well did he do out of that windfall of cash?
The movie is good silly fun over all. I still enjoy it after all these years. But it could have been a lot better. I think it needed an extra 15-20 minutes to play out some of those dangling plot lines.
Tell Your Friends