Reviews

2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
2/10
Once again, a poor movie version of an original BBC series
16 May 2010
Warning: Spoilers
I do not see how anybody could make much sense of this movie if they hadn't already seen the original BBC series, Edge of Darkness, back in the 1980's. Then again, if you had seen that series, you would be finding this movie a complete disappointment.

The plot line is quite different and obviously compressed to fit in to a tighter movie-length time line. The original series totalled about 5 hours. And it was worth every minute.

The movie leaves a number of questions unanswered, which the original series would make completely clear. Jedburgh, a critical character in the 1980's version, was a pointless addition - his part never being fully developed. The complexity of Emma's involvement with an Earth-Justice-type group was distorted and trivialized. The motivation for radioactive material storage and production was vague and not convincing. Craven's love interest from the 1980's version, failed to materialize, and yet was an important factor in his eventual actions.

As with many other movies created from original British series', this one was a complete failure. If you want to compare, the original series is available on Netflix.
5 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Touching Home (2008)
10/10
A Very Worthwhile and Well Made Movie
13 April 2010
A very worthwhile movie.

I was fortunate to be given a chance to see this film before its general release. By now, many of you will have heard the story about twin brothers with an alcoholic and homeless father, about how the brothers made a movie about their story etc. It might sound a little like a strawberry pie kind of scenario. No spoilers here - but you should not let past experiences influence your future opinions.

The acting in the movie takes a little while to warm-up. I do not know if the entire movie was shot in sequence (unlikely) but I found that as the movie progressed, particularly after the 30 minute mark, all the players seemed to interact more comfortably and naturally together. In other words, in the first 30 minutes, I was in the theater to watch a movie - after that time, I was completely wrapped up in the story.

The brothers did an amazing job of ignoring all those who told them that they could not do what they did. They should be considered a genuine inspiration for all film students and existing film makers who seem to find it oh so easy to complain rather than facing a situation, and dealing with it the best way they can.

Ed Harris - well, what can I say? Being from England, I have skepticism woven in to my DNA. Some people go to Disney World to see Mickey Mouse. I see an hourly wage earner in a plastic uniform. But Ed's performance was, really, incredible. Seriously, really incredible. For fans of Ed Harris, you will not be disappointed. For those who, for some reason, dislike Ed Harris, if this movie does not make you a fan, there is something wrong with you.

The casting of Ishiah Benben was also inspired. A beautifully played piece - I am sure we will see a lot more of this talented actor in the near future.

The movie locations are beautifully shot, camera work fits together very well (although some too obvious filtering was a minor distraction), and the editing and soundtrack pull it all together.

Go and see this movie - not just to support two young men who have already done more than many will do in a lifetime, but also to experience a very well executed production.

And congratulations to the sponsors of the movie, and the California Film Institute for seeing the potential, and making this production a reality.
7 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed