Let me start by saying to all those that want to hate...GET OVER IT! In other reviews I have reminded those that love to tear down, go get a camera, write something prolific and do it yourself. If you think you can. Now, to the review.
It's very hard for me to throw around the word 'cowboy' and direct it to anything that we see in film (movies or television), but this is fairly close. Life in the 19th century USA was no picnic and Mr. Sheridan seems to have captured the essence of what life might have been like. People struggled just to live but were motivated by something better just beyond the horizon...that horizon being west. So, he takes the Dutton Family west, chasing dreams. Since I have come to appreciate the incredible cast that makes up Yellowstone, I had my doubts he could do the same for 1883. I stand corrected. Tim McGraw and Faith Hill are more than adequate as James and Margaret Dutton, as they are able to play characters off of each other's strengths and weaknesses. They don't have to be stellar performances, but instead, solid performances that lend realism and help ground the series into something that will keep us coming back. And it's obvious that Mr. Sheridan knows his actors and write to that effect. Then there is Sam Elliott. I read some reviews that he plays the same brooding character in everything he's in. For you shortsighted people out there, he does more acting with his eyes than any other actor I know. He didn't need dialogue because his expressions told the story. Not many actors can do that. He does it effortlessly. LaMonica Garrett is another delight in this cast. His Thomas is a man of few words but the insight we see is deep. But the best part of this hour is Isabel May. As Elsa Dutton, Mr. Sheridan has chosen her to be the rock. We are watching this through her eyes as she sees the unfolding and uncertain future ahead of her. Again, someone complained about her narration. Her narration opens the story up for all of us.
In summary, for all intents and purposes, this is a western. It's also about 'cowboys' and I feel comfortable using the word here. It's also about dreams and a hope for the future. A hope for ourselves and those that come after us. It just happens to be the Dutton Family sans Yellowstone, not what is now, but the journey there. It's also television at its best and how this medium can educate us, entertain us...move us.
It's very hard for me to throw around the word 'cowboy' and direct it to anything that we see in film (movies or television), but this is fairly close. Life in the 19th century USA was no picnic and Mr. Sheridan seems to have captured the essence of what life might have been like. People struggled just to live but were motivated by something better just beyond the horizon...that horizon being west. So, he takes the Dutton Family west, chasing dreams. Since I have come to appreciate the incredible cast that makes up Yellowstone, I had my doubts he could do the same for 1883. I stand corrected. Tim McGraw and Faith Hill are more than adequate as James and Margaret Dutton, as they are able to play characters off of each other's strengths and weaknesses. They don't have to be stellar performances, but instead, solid performances that lend realism and help ground the series into something that will keep us coming back. And it's obvious that Mr. Sheridan knows his actors and write to that effect. Then there is Sam Elliott. I read some reviews that he plays the same brooding character in everything he's in. For you shortsighted people out there, he does more acting with his eyes than any other actor I know. He didn't need dialogue because his expressions told the story. Not many actors can do that. He does it effortlessly. LaMonica Garrett is another delight in this cast. His Thomas is a man of few words but the insight we see is deep. But the best part of this hour is Isabel May. As Elsa Dutton, Mr. Sheridan has chosen her to be the rock. We are watching this through her eyes as she sees the unfolding and uncertain future ahead of her. Again, someone complained about her narration. Her narration opens the story up for all of us.
In summary, for all intents and purposes, this is a western. It's also about 'cowboys' and I feel comfortable using the word here. It's also about dreams and a hope for the future. A hope for ourselves and those that come after us. It just happens to be the Dutton Family sans Yellowstone, not what is now, but the journey there. It's also television at its best and how this medium can educate us, entertain us...move us.
Tell Your Friends