Louis Malle's version of Poe's William Wilson is the under-rated short film of this feature. Perhaps the most faithful to the original short story of a doppelgänger haunting critical points of a man's life, Malle's take goes even further by emphasizing the sexual nature of Wilson's cruelty. The power struggle between Bardot and Delon as they raise the stakes during cards is definitely memorable. The sadistic end result result may be viewed as distasteful or misogynist by some feminist critics, however one can make an argument that the film takes a more Freudian reading of the short story with Wilson's super-ego getting the upper hand by thwarting his darker opposite (half) on these key occasions of his life. A Freudian reading renders the ending more sensible as well, as it is Wilson himself who pays the ultimate price.
Fellini's brilliant gem is densely packed with visual and audible witticisms. He takes on the very nature of international film co-productions (thereby self-reflexively poking fun at the feature itself) by presenting a struggling British actor out of his element in Rome. Every shot is packed with flamboyant imagery familiar to Fellini fans from the airport paparazzi to the insane awards ceremony. The hilariously ludicrous concept of a Christian western evoking both Piero della Francesca and Fred Zimmerman is just one of the farcical barbs Fellini fires out early on in the piece. The brilliant choice of presenting the devil not as some hideous creature - but as a little girl is an early example of post-modern horror to be further explored by Polanski and Roeg in later years. The film shifts tone when Terence Stamp races off in his Ferrari but that does not detract from the film at all. Long after Nino Rota's haunting score cues over the final credits it will linger in your head. This segment is 95% Fellini (arguably even more) and 5% Poe- but it's a tribute to the great director that he makes it work so well. There is so much to take in here, it absolutely invites multiple viewings.
One final note; If you view this on DVD be sure to watch Fellini's film with the English audio tracks and subtitles on instead of just the French audio. That way you won't miss as much in translation during the dense dialogue segments. You'll also hear Terence Stamp's original voice (plus some ADR) instead of the french over-dub.
Fellini's brilliant gem is densely packed with visual and audible witticisms. He takes on the very nature of international film co-productions (thereby self-reflexively poking fun at the feature itself) by presenting a struggling British actor out of his element in Rome. Every shot is packed with flamboyant imagery familiar to Fellini fans from the airport paparazzi to the insane awards ceremony. The hilariously ludicrous concept of a Christian western evoking both Piero della Francesca and Fred Zimmerman is just one of the farcical barbs Fellini fires out early on in the piece. The brilliant choice of presenting the devil not as some hideous creature - but as a little girl is an early example of post-modern horror to be further explored by Polanski and Roeg in later years. The film shifts tone when Terence Stamp races off in his Ferrari but that does not detract from the film at all. Long after Nino Rota's haunting score cues over the final credits it will linger in your head. This segment is 95% Fellini (arguably even more) and 5% Poe- but it's a tribute to the great director that he makes it work so well. There is so much to take in here, it absolutely invites multiple viewings.
One final note; If you view this on DVD be sure to watch Fellini's film with the English audio tracks and subtitles on instead of just the French audio. That way you won't miss as much in translation during the dense dialogue segments. You'll also hear Terence Stamp's original voice (plus some ADR) instead of the french over-dub.
Tell Your Friends