I went to this film thinking I was going to see a fairly straightforward (for an Eastern film) revenge thriller, with a healthy side-order of blood. Boy, was I in for a surprise.
The film starts on a relatively high note - even though the Ryu's sister needs a transplant, and even after Ryu get his kidney stolen and they kidnap Park's kid, the film's style remains light. However, it slowly (and I mean slowly; this film is /very/ drawn out) blossoms into a complex web of vengeance, as the body count rises.
Having said that, there is not much gore - what there is, however, is concentrated and refined, so it cuts into your nerves. I was beginning to despair of seeing some actual violence until the baseball bat scene (which i *loved*) - don't get me wrong, i'm not a gore nut, but the film is quite, i don't know....minimalist. The violence is well-orchestrated, and used to maximum effect.
The ending scene with Ryu and Park in the river is one of those increasingly rare moments of genius - its not spectacular, or climactic, but it just fits excellently with the mood of the film, and says all that needs to be said. Having said that, I did feel Park's death was a let-down - not especially bad, but story wise, just not up to par with the rest of the film (though the direction was still spot on).
The only oddity i found was the water still being on the floor when the police guy comes round to Park's house....i presumed the scene with his daughter was a dream =S
*CONCLUSION*
In short, this is an excellent (and very personal) film, but could benefit from an increased pace - it felt like much longer than the two hours of its running time, and partway through I was having doubts about its quality. However, the storyline is nicely formed, and easy to follow, and the characters, while not being the most openly emotional, still have a roughness which makes them believable.
Stunning acting from Ha-kyun Shin and Kang-ho Song, and if the rumors of Oldboy being even better are true, then this director is definitely one to watch.
The film starts on a relatively high note - even though the Ryu's sister needs a transplant, and even after Ryu get his kidney stolen and they kidnap Park's kid, the film's style remains light. However, it slowly (and I mean slowly; this film is /very/ drawn out) blossoms into a complex web of vengeance, as the body count rises.
Having said that, there is not much gore - what there is, however, is concentrated and refined, so it cuts into your nerves. I was beginning to despair of seeing some actual violence until the baseball bat scene (which i *loved*) - don't get me wrong, i'm not a gore nut, but the film is quite, i don't know....minimalist. The violence is well-orchestrated, and used to maximum effect.
The ending scene with Ryu and Park in the river is one of those increasingly rare moments of genius - its not spectacular, or climactic, but it just fits excellently with the mood of the film, and says all that needs to be said. Having said that, I did feel Park's death was a let-down - not especially bad, but story wise, just not up to par with the rest of the film (though the direction was still spot on).
The only oddity i found was the water still being on the floor when the police guy comes round to Park's house....i presumed the scene with his daughter was a dream =S
*CONCLUSION*
In short, this is an excellent (and very personal) film, but could benefit from an increased pace - it felt like much longer than the two hours of its running time, and partway through I was having doubts about its quality. However, the storyline is nicely formed, and easy to follow, and the characters, while not being the most openly emotional, still have a roughness which makes them believable.
Stunning acting from Ha-kyun Shin and Kang-ho Song, and if the rumors of Oldboy being even better are true, then this director is definitely one to watch.
Tell Your Friends