Reviews

4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
The Bob Perspective
9 October 2004
Warning: Spoilers
I went to this film thinking I was going to see a fairly straightforward (for an Eastern film) revenge thriller, with a healthy side-order of blood. Boy, was I in for a surprise.

The film starts on a relatively high note - even though the Ryu's sister needs a transplant, and even after Ryu get his kidney stolen and they kidnap Park's kid, the film's style remains light. However, it slowly (and I mean slowly; this film is /very/ drawn out) blossoms into a complex web of vengeance, as the body count rises.

Having said that, there is not much gore - what there is, however, is concentrated and refined, so it cuts into your nerves. I was beginning to despair of seeing some actual violence until the baseball bat scene (which i *loved*) - don't get me wrong, i'm not a gore nut, but the film is quite, i don't know....minimalist. The violence is well-orchestrated, and used to maximum effect.

The ending scene with Ryu and Park in the river is one of those increasingly rare moments of genius - its not spectacular, or climactic, but it just fits excellently with the mood of the film, and says all that needs to be said. Having said that, I did feel Park's death was a let-down - not especially bad, but story wise, just not up to par with the rest of the film (though the direction was still spot on).

The only oddity i found was the water still being on the floor when the police guy comes round to Park's house....i presumed the scene with his daughter was a dream =S

*CONCLUSION*

In short, this is an excellent (and very personal) film, but could benefit from an increased pace - it felt like much longer than the two hours of its running time, and partway through I was having doubts about its quality. However, the storyline is nicely formed, and easy to follow, and the characters, while not being the most openly emotional, still have a roughness which makes them believable.

Stunning acting from Ha-kyun Shin and Kang-ho Song, and if the rumors of Oldboy being even better are true, then this director is definitely one to watch.
15 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Control (2003)
The British Perspective
9 October 2004
Warning: Spoilers
Kontroll is a character-driven film; the (often surreal) storyline is little more than a carriage for the portrayal of the skewed lives and minds of Bulcsú, a ticket inspector on an undisclosed underground railway system (filmed in Budapest, but as the clip at the start of the film emphasises, no connection should be made), his colleagues, bosses, and a sample of passengers.

It is a tale of redemption - as I see it, the hooded man is Bulcsú's fear, or the Evil; Belá's daughter is his salvation, or the Good. The tunnel sequence shows Good making Bulcsú find and confront his fear; in the end, he does and leaves the station to enter the outside world. It also gives an interesting look at the psyche of a ticket inspector (I assume the psychiatrist montage is based on research).

*SPOILER ALERT* (if you haven't seen this film yet, skip to *CONCLUSION*

The first part of the film highlights the rivalry between Bulcsú and his team, and the "best" team in that system (led by Gonzó). It also introduces the mysterious hooded figure, who pushes people seemingly at random in front of trains. The entire film seems "real" - the characters are 3D, and their interaction does not greatly further the plot; this is particularly evident in the first 10 or 20 minutes.

It then heads into darker territory; the incident with Laci, Bulcsú's first interaction with the hooded guy, and the f*cked up tunnel thing. The change is most dramatic in the scene where the runner (whom i thought was called Bootsie, but doesn't seem to be in the credits) is killed - one of my favourite scenes in the film.

In the end, Bulcsú overcomes his fear of the hooded man, and eventually his fear of the outside world, and everybody's happy (well, Bulcsú is at least =P )

*CONCLUSION*

The film is different, and plays with the viewers' emotions - the startling switch between comedy and thriller, everyday and surreal - and does it well.

This is definitely a film to watch, and bodes well for Hungary's future in film-making.

~pr0ph37~
13 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
The Bob Perspective
9 October 2004
After seeing the nicely dramatic trailers for this film, I was fired up for a nice slice of gritty vengeance action/thriller. I left the cinema disappointed.

The storyline isn't bad, but the executions of each of the guilty parties seems devoid of meaning - there was much more scope for showing Richard's mind being twisted, and for protracting the killings, making them personal - ultimately intimate and meaningful - instead of just an inevitable conclusion. Also, I saw the end coming a mile off.

*CONCLUSION*

From what I'd heard of the director's talents, I expected more from this film, and it sadly didn't deliver. Nice idea, shame about the execution.

~pr0ph37~
2 out of 24 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Code 46 (2003)
8/10
Why this film is 'real'
30 September 2004
I loved this film! It was (to my cinematographically uncultured palate, at least) different, and the characters seemed quite unconventional. Rather than just hollow acting, I found Tim Robbins' character to be a mental curve ball, which completely altered the way the film played out. It hinted at the socialisation and culture prevalent at the time.

I also enjoyed the (much-disputed) foreign terms slipped into the conversation - they weren't too frequent, and added a dimension - that there had been purely aesthetic as well as techno/political changes. As English becomes more dominant and other languages in the minority (and therefore more culturally significant), it is likely that foreign terms will be leaked, from the age-old Caucasian tradition of borrowing culture if nothing else.

I also loved the fact that the cityscapes were all filmed to imply the future, rather than CG'd or whatever.

The storyline was innovative, and there were many dead-ends which fleshed out the story and made it less linear. Unlike some, I easily followed the storyline, and I'm rather confused that some people felt that it didn't seem to touch on Code 46 itself much.

Interesting concepts, combined with a sense of triviality surrounding much of the technology, helped to create a more textured world, and while nothing was really explained, the evidence was there for you to draw your own conclusions. If you like thinking, definitely watch this film.

~pr0ph37~
59 out of 82 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed