Like a lot of other viewers I've been a lifelong fan of the Star Trek franchise... And I've religiously watched every movie and series... Even the ones that weren't that good. Unfortunately, Discovery is a horribly written series and, in my opinion, the worst one produced yet.
First the good... The actors do a good job portraying the characters as they were written. The special effects are top notch and it's visually stunning. I love seeing the new species included in the Star Trek universe, and as a general rule of thumb, I enjoy how they're portrayed. Unfortunately, this is about the only good thing I can say about the show.
Now the bad... My biggest complaint with the show is it's not about the ship and the crew. As it's been on every other version of Star Trek. This show is quite literally about the character Michael Burnham and how everyone in it revolves around her. Now to be clear, my objection to this character has nothing to do with Sonequa Martin-Green. She's a fine dramatic actresses and I enjoyed her character on The Walking Dead. She's simply playing the part as it's written.
It's simply EVERY crisis on the show has Michael Burnham at the center of it, in one way or another. The writers seemed have made a conscious decision to make her the single most important character in the Star Trek universe. The fate of the entire universe has hung by a thread because of her. She'll regularly unilaterally deciding the direction and actions of the ship, and usurping the Captain's authority. There will be a crisis, and she'll simply get some intuitive feeling about it, and suddenly the Discovery is off following what she's said. Which is wrong enough times, someone should tell her to shut up when she starts talking.
And of course, there's the countless times she's used some moral superiority to decide she had the authority to break the chain of command, or go on an unauthorized mission only she knows about. Her character is about as self indigent as they come, and seems to lack any situational awareness. The character Michael Burnham regularly comes up with some emotional rational (Really weird for someone that grew up on Vulcan being trained in logic) to justify going rogue. Next thing you now, she's off creating a crisis the crew of Discovery must save her for. As someone the claims to value the institution of Star Fleet, her self obsession with her own idea of right and wrong is baffling. Even Spock called her "self important" once. Which fits to a T.
Next the Michael Burnham character has some weird balance of absolute certainty and insecurity at the same time. To be honest, it's annoying. Pretty much every crisis has the same formula. At the start of a crisis, she's dictating what the entire crew of Discovery should be doing. Next she's question what the crew is doing and why. And once the crisis has been resolved she gives some long winded speech.
Which brings me to something else that annoys me. The character Michael Burnham is CONSTANTLY giving these weird motivational speeches. For some reason, when she starts talking, everyone shuts up and listens to her. Including the Captain. A large group of the crew will be together in some situation, and she'll be the only one giving some long winded speech. Michael Burnham is always talking, and talking, and talking and giving speech after speech to everyone else.
This brings me to my next complaint. Pretty much every character is good for emotionally puking at least once per episode. Literally, every episode contains a speech from some character (Usually Michael Burnham) about "family", love, loss, acceptance, respect, cooperation, etc. They do this at the weirdest moments in the show too. On more than one occasion, the crew have been furiously working to resolve some life threatening crisis to the ship, and suddenly every character will stop doing what they were doing, to validate their or someone else's feelings. It's so predictable I can tell when someone's going to launch into a uselessly emotionally draining speech. Between the speeches and emotional puking... That's roughly 1/3 of every episode.
I could go on, but my last complaint is about the absolute lack of humor or jocularity. In pretty much every other version of Star Trek to be produced, the writers would find a way to work a little humor into their shows. Which always made past Star Trek shows fun. I understand there's a time & place for humor in a show, but Discovery is almost completely devoid of humor. This version of Star Trek is flat out depressing with how serious all the character's are.
Now how this show has a 7.1 IMDB rating is beyond me... It's horribly written. Other than the occasional mention of the Federation, I can't image any Star Trek fan recognizing Discovery as one that belongs in the Star Trek universe.
First the good... The actors do a good job portraying the characters as they were written. The special effects are top notch and it's visually stunning. I love seeing the new species included in the Star Trek universe, and as a general rule of thumb, I enjoy how they're portrayed. Unfortunately, this is about the only good thing I can say about the show.
Now the bad... My biggest complaint with the show is it's not about the ship and the crew. As it's been on every other version of Star Trek. This show is quite literally about the character Michael Burnham and how everyone in it revolves around her. Now to be clear, my objection to this character has nothing to do with Sonequa Martin-Green. She's a fine dramatic actresses and I enjoyed her character on The Walking Dead. She's simply playing the part as it's written.
It's simply EVERY crisis on the show has Michael Burnham at the center of it, in one way or another. The writers seemed have made a conscious decision to make her the single most important character in the Star Trek universe. The fate of the entire universe has hung by a thread because of her. She'll regularly unilaterally deciding the direction and actions of the ship, and usurping the Captain's authority. There will be a crisis, and she'll simply get some intuitive feeling about it, and suddenly the Discovery is off following what she's said. Which is wrong enough times, someone should tell her to shut up when she starts talking.
And of course, there's the countless times she's used some moral superiority to decide she had the authority to break the chain of command, or go on an unauthorized mission only she knows about. Her character is about as self indigent as they come, and seems to lack any situational awareness. The character Michael Burnham regularly comes up with some emotional rational (Really weird for someone that grew up on Vulcan being trained in logic) to justify going rogue. Next thing you now, she's off creating a crisis the crew of Discovery must save her for. As someone the claims to value the institution of Star Fleet, her self obsession with her own idea of right and wrong is baffling. Even Spock called her "self important" once. Which fits to a T.
Next the Michael Burnham character has some weird balance of absolute certainty and insecurity at the same time. To be honest, it's annoying. Pretty much every crisis has the same formula. At the start of a crisis, she's dictating what the entire crew of Discovery should be doing. Next she's question what the crew is doing and why. And once the crisis has been resolved she gives some long winded speech.
Which brings me to something else that annoys me. The character Michael Burnham is CONSTANTLY giving these weird motivational speeches. For some reason, when she starts talking, everyone shuts up and listens to her. Including the Captain. A large group of the crew will be together in some situation, and she'll be the only one giving some long winded speech. Michael Burnham is always talking, and talking, and talking and giving speech after speech to everyone else.
This brings me to my next complaint. Pretty much every character is good for emotionally puking at least once per episode. Literally, every episode contains a speech from some character (Usually Michael Burnham) about "family", love, loss, acceptance, respect, cooperation, etc. They do this at the weirdest moments in the show too. On more than one occasion, the crew have been furiously working to resolve some life threatening crisis to the ship, and suddenly every character will stop doing what they were doing, to validate their or someone else's feelings. It's so predictable I can tell when someone's going to launch into a uselessly emotionally draining speech. Between the speeches and emotional puking... That's roughly 1/3 of every episode.
I could go on, but my last complaint is about the absolute lack of humor or jocularity. In pretty much every other version of Star Trek to be produced, the writers would find a way to work a little humor into their shows. Which always made past Star Trek shows fun. I understand there's a time & place for humor in a show, but Discovery is almost completely devoid of humor. This version of Star Trek is flat out depressing with how serious all the character's are.
Now how this show has a 7.1 IMDB rating is beyond me... It's horribly written. Other than the occasional mention of the Federation, I can't image any Star Trek fan recognizing Discovery as one that belongs in the Star Trek universe.
Tell Your Friends