i wasn't expecting too much when i entered the theater to watch the golden compass. it was the first time i had read the book before seeing the movie, so i new i kinda figured i'd be disappointed. but i didn't think it would be that bad. first off, the beginning with the narrator telling the story of dust and parallel worlds was terrible, how stupid do they think we are. even people who didn't read that books could have figured it out by the end. we should have discovered it as Lyra did in the book. the movie had a lot mistakes like this, things that were changed from the book. Why? it would have been easier and better if they would have went with the book. they even changed around the order a bit. The worst part about the changes was that the story didn't follow Lyra the entire time, like it was in the book. It didn't feel like an adventure. every couple of minutes it would jump to a completely different scene, nothing could get established. the dialog was lousy. it was too fast, and unrealistic. i noticed that they tried to explain a lot about the story through the dialog from Lyra to other characters, which would be understandable in any other movie, but they didn't take advantage of the fact that Lyra can pretty much think out loud by talking to Pantalaimon. They made everything too obvious in this movie instead of letting people figure things out for themselves. it seemed like it was geared towards little kids. the book had a lot of adult themes that added to the complexity of the story, when they took all of these out it left the story dull. The music was terrible. worse than terrible. they spent 150 mil on this movie and completely neglected the importance of the music? sad. the music wouldn't have saved the movie but it would have definitely helped it. the music in narnia for example, the music was so good that even though i hated the movie i watched it again to see how good the music matched up with the movie. the director ruined the movie. there was a lot of potential too. the casting was awesome. the girl who played Lyra was almost perfect. Lee Scorsby was great. The voice of Pan was awesome, Serafina Pekkala was great. Mrs. Coulter was great. Asriel was great. besides the ugly roger kid, the casting was perfect. I also enjoyed the special effects for the daemons. the cinematography in the first half of the movie is awesome too. it seems a little rushed in the end. or maybe claustrophobic. Svalbard for example. in the book the place sounds huge. in the movie it looks like a small cave or something. the ending was terrible also. no resolution. i doubt they'll make the sequel, but if they do it'll be bad because from the get go so much in the story is gonna change and for people who didn't read the book they aren't going to understand how they should feel about certain characters. i hope the movie doesn't give the books a bad reputation
2 out of 4 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends