I must admit, I did not pay to watch this film, so I cannot ask for my money back. However, I have still wasted two hours of my life and for that I am upset. Why did I hate it so much? Because it's full of clichés, yes, but that's not all. The film is just a vehicle to spread Eastwoods' ultra right wing political ideas. For him (and the soulless screenwriter), we are better off dead than dependent on others. The segment in which Hillary Swank's family makes a big fuss because she wants to buy them a home which would cause them to lose their welfare says it all. This is propaganda and it makes me really sick. Other than that, the film has no artistic value, is full of clichés, has a predictable storyline and banal dialogue.
Reviews
3 Reviews
We Still Kill the Old Way
(1967)
Uconventional detective story under the scorching Sicilian sun
29 March 2011
"A Ciascuno il suo" is based on the homonymous book by Leonardo Sciascia, and just like many of the author's books is an unconventional detective story aimed at unveiling the hypocrisy and immorality of Sicilian society. The story begins with a man showing his friends a few threat letters. A few days later he gets shot together with one of his friends, a chemist. The murder is filed under "honour crime" (delitto d'onore) a murder committed out of passion and jealousy, and a peasant is convicted for it. Gian Maria Volonté is an awkward school professor who believes in the peasant's innocence, and decides to investigate the crime. His infatuation with the beautiful wife of the victim also plays a part in his decision to solve the mystery. As the story unveils, he will discover unpleasant truths, but will continue with the investigation despite all dangers. Volonté is as formidable as always, changing his accent and posture to fit the part. But the real protagonist is the Sicilian landscape in all its harsh brightness. The cinematography is such that we can almost feel the wind, the sun and the dryness of the air. When I first watched this film I wondered whether anyone who was not Sicilian or familiar with Sciascia's writing would understand all its complexity, but Elio Petri does a masterful job in transposing the book.
The Scopone Game
(1972)
1970s: Italian cinema at its best!
12 March 2011
Rome, 1970s. While a few benefit from the wealth of the modern world, many live in misery. Peppino, his wife Antonia and their five children live in a shanty town, populated by all sorts of tramps, pimps and prostitutes, plus a "professor" in disgrace who lectures everyone on the importance of reading and the beauty of Marxism. Every year a millionairess turns up to play cards with Peppino and Antonia, and every year they hope to win enough money to change their lives, not that they would need much, as they have nothing! The villa in which the old woman (la vecchia) lives is stunning, surrounded by the most beautiful roman trees, in stark contradiction with the grey poverty surrounding Peppino's family. The underlying theme of the film is class struggle and how the rich keep teasing the poor with the promise of a better future which never comes. But Comencini is not as bitter as his contemporaries (Monicelli, Petri etc): he celebrates love and humanity, something the old millionaire will never own. Needless to say, the performances are formidable.
Tell Your Friends