Nearly everything that can and should be said about this movie already has been, so I will just put in my two cents and skip all plot summary.
This film most certainly has flaws. It is drawn out, has uneven pacing and strange unexplained events, and is at times a bit too aware of its cleverness for its own good. The ending I also found unsatisfying for reasons which can be boiled down to "inconclusiveness".
But I believe that the REASON this inconclusiveness is upsetting is to the films credit. Mr. Anderson has created an incredibly interesting cacophony of personalities that somehow manage to mesh beautifully, and the viewer cannot help but get caught up in their struggles. This film is a great example of a director creating with complete freedom, letting loose with all the flair and gusto he has. Virtuosity is a word that came to mind many times throughout its towering 3 hours.
Magnolia is big in many ways - its length, ambition, and subject matter to name a few; but this sheer ambitiousness of the movie in the end is its most stunning characteristic. The magnitude of confidence (cast and crew alike) required to pull off this movie, whether entirely successful or not, is most admirable, and at its best moments Magnolia could even be considered genius. Admittedly imperfect, Magnolia still manages to be a fantastic film, even if it does lose its way from time to time (and although it has been said many, many times - Tom Cruise delivers an unbelievable performance which I had not even thought him capable of, and is, even on his own, more than reason enough to recommend this movie).
This film most certainly has flaws. It is drawn out, has uneven pacing and strange unexplained events, and is at times a bit too aware of its cleverness for its own good. The ending I also found unsatisfying for reasons which can be boiled down to "inconclusiveness".
But I believe that the REASON this inconclusiveness is upsetting is to the films credit. Mr. Anderson has created an incredibly interesting cacophony of personalities that somehow manage to mesh beautifully, and the viewer cannot help but get caught up in their struggles. This film is a great example of a director creating with complete freedom, letting loose with all the flair and gusto he has. Virtuosity is a word that came to mind many times throughout its towering 3 hours.
Magnolia is big in many ways - its length, ambition, and subject matter to name a few; but this sheer ambitiousness of the movie in the end is its most stunning characteristic. The magnitude of confidence (cast and crew alike) required to pull off this movie, whether entirely successful or not, is most admirable, and at its best moments Magnolia could even be considered genius. Admittedly imperfect, Magnolia still manages to be a fantastic film, even if it does lose its way from time to time (and although it has been said many, many times - Tom Cruise delivers an unbelievable performance which I had not even thought him capable of, and is, even on his own, more than reason enough to recommend this movie).
Tell Your Friends