Change Your Image
czarina-yelena
IMDb member since December 2005
Reviews
Treasure Island (1990)
It's a faithful adaptation, but nothing more.
13 January 2018 - 7 out of 12 users found this review helpful.
I'm not sure where all the 10/10 and 9/10 reviews are coming from. This is a faithful adaptation of the book - so much so that you may as well be watching a dramatic reading, but that's the only good thing about it.
Christian Bale's Jim Hawkins sounds perpetually bored, worst of all when he's narrating behind the scenes like he's reading aloud in class. The settings are Hollywood-sanitized and look like the backdrop of a play, none of the grit of the 2012 British version.
A good adaptation has heart and adds something of its own to the story. This version does neither.
See more▼See less▲